search

Minehut / Meta

Report bugs or issues and request features and updates for Minehut
31 stars 21 forks source link

Get payed credits for members with ranks playing on your server. #863

Open FlowScript opened 2 years ago

FlowScript commented 2 years ago

Feature request

Checklist

Platform Website

Describe the feature

Hello,

I think it would be a cool idea to add a feature where you get payed for ranked players playing on your sever. It could also vary by their rank; for example more expensive ranks give a higher payout. And of course the longer they play the more you get payed.

Any thoughts?

How the feature is useful

It makes it easier for players to earn credits, and minehut still profits from rank purchases.

Use 👍 and 👎 reactions to indicate you agree or disagree with this suggestion! Feel free to discuss the idea in the comments.

Blocksnmore commented 2 years ago

I don’t think this would be maintainable for minehut mainly due to the fact the market pays out in real life money. You could end up spending more on the market from that than the rank costed causing minehut to lose money.

Checkmate128 commented 2 years ago

What if the owner of a server has a rank? What if I were to just pay someone to sit around on my server? Seems highly exploitable and unmaintainable for Minehut.

drtshock commented 2 years ago

Roblox does this :)

expxx commented 2 years ago

eRrRr no

erenkarakal commented 2 years ago

90% of the players on every top server is AFK

FlowScript commented 2 years ago

What if the owner of a server has a rank? What if I were to just pay someone to sit around on my server? Seems highly exploitable and unmaintainable for Minehut.

Minehut can easily detect if a player is being active or not, or limit the amount of credits rewarded from certain players. Also I think it's pretty obvious that minehut wouldn't reward the owner for playing on their own server. - Same with server OPs.

Checkmate128 commented 2 years ago

What if the owner of a server has a rank? What if I were to just pay someone to sit around on my server? Seems highly exploitable and unmaintainable for Minehut.

Minehut can easily detect if a player is being active or not, or limit the amount of credits rewarded from certain players. Also I think it's pretty obvious that minehut wouldn't reward the owner for playing on their own server. - Same with server OPs.

How does Minehut know if a player is an owner? Also AFK/inactivity detection can be easily avoided by using a program or hacked client to randomly move in a set area. Servers could also teleport players randomly to make Minehut think they are moving and active. Also most servers don’t use vanilla permissions which is what excluding server OPs would find and exclude.

FlowScript commented 2 years ago

What if the owner of a server has a rank? What if I were to just pay someone to sit around on my server? Seems highly exploitable and unmaintainable for Minehut.

Minehut can easily detect if a player is being active or not, or limit the amount of credits rewarded from certain players. Also I think it's pretty obvious that minehut wouldn't reward the owner for playing on their own server. - Same with server OPs.

How does Minehut know if a player is an owner? Also AFK/inactivity detection can be easily avoided by using a program or hacked client to randomly move in a set area. Servers could also teleport players randomly to make Minehut think they are moving and active. Also most servers don’t use vanilla permissions which is what excluding server OPs would find and exclude.

They could detect if a player is an owner by limiting this feature to only accounts that are linked to minehut's website. Then they can tell if you own the server or not. Also the AFK/inactivity detection is a little iffy but they can limit the amount of credits a player can reward to a certain server. For example: player1 was limited to only awarding 25 credits to server1 for playing for a few hours. Then player1 went on server2 and rewarded server2 with 25 credits for playing for a few hours.

ntrogen commented 2 years ago

Doesn't this just make free credits for gen servers?

MrGeoTech commented 2 years ago

Maybe give ranked players a command to donate to the server with a cool down that varies on the rank (vip=1 per month to patron=1 per week) where it gives the servers owner account a small amount of tokens (10-25)?

drtshock commented 2 years ago

Revisiting this, I like it but I don't think it works for ranks in their current form. The reason it makes sense for Roblox is because it pays out a % of the player's subscription. If we moved ranks to a subscription, I think this model could make sense.