search

MrClassicT / bibla

A simple BibLaTeX linter, based on bibl.
https://mrclassict.github.io/bibla/
Other
5 stars 0 forks source link

title or journalTitle #3

Closed JochenVanSeveren closed 2 months ago

JochenVanSeveren commented 2 months ago 
@article{Nissi2021,
  title={Improving Event Management Implementation on Odoo Business Management Software},
  author={Nissi, Miika},
  date={2021}
}

I got this: bachproef/bachproef.bib:10 M01ArticleJournaltitle: Missing required field journaltitle for entry type article

Changed title to journaltitle

@article{Nissi2021,
  journaltitle={Improving Event Management Implementation on Odoo Business Management Software},
  author={Nissi, Miika},
  date={2021}
}

And got this: bachproef/bachproef.bib:10 M01ArticleTitle: Missing required field title for entry type article

Which one is it : )

MrClassicT commented 2 months ago

Was this by using bibla lint {file.bib}? Or did a custom command get used?

JochenVanSeveren commented 2 months ago

Was this by using bibla lint {file.bib}? Or did a custom command get used?

The default command was used

bertvv commented 2 months ago

This is not a bug. The field title is for the title of the article. However, if you cite an article, you have to specify in what journal it appeared. That's what the journaltitle field is for.

Hence, the feedback from the tool is correct, the bibliographical data is incomplete. Only author, title and date are not sufficient to find the cited source.

JochenVanSeveren commented 2 months ago

This is not a bug. The field title is for the title of the article. However, if you cite an article, you have to specify in what journal it appeared. That's what the journaltitle field is for.

Hence, the feedback from the tool is correct, the bibliographical data is incomplete. Only author, title and date are not sufficient to find the cited source.

Oh that clarifies it Thank you!