| Year | Champion | 2nd Place | 3rd Place |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Ron Mexico | LeathaHands | MAksRock |
| 2022 | No Time 4 Love AaronJones | jivechickenlove | Laconia Magnetars |
| 2021 | LeathaHands | phutang24 | MAksRock |
| 2020 | phutang24 | Washington Wildcards | MAksRock |
| 2019 | San Diego Fetts | Washington Wildcards | MaxRock |
| 2018 | San Diego Fetts | Ron Mexico | TwinbrookJiveTurkeys |
| 2017 | Washington Wildcards | Ron Mexico | MaxRock |
| 2016 | VT Knotty's | Ron Mexico | Washington Wildcards |
| 2015 | Washington Wildcards | Ron Mexico | Laruel Reapers |
| 2014 | Ron Mexico | VT Knotty's | Washington Wildcards |
| 2013 | Washington Wildcards | VT Knotty's | Symkaria Wild Pack |
| 2012 | Ron Mexico | Green Bitches | VT Knotty's |
| 2011 | Ron Mexico | Soho Suns | VT Knotty's |
| 2010 | Washington Wildcards | Ron Mexico | Aspen Hill Choadies |
| 2009 | VT Knotty's | San Diego Hawkmen | Soho Suns |
| 2008 | San Diego Hawkmen | All Out Blitz | Washington Wildcards |
| 2007* | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown |
| 2006 | S.D. Mighty Jesus | Washington Wildcards | Soho Suns |
| 2005 | Washington Wildcards | Ocean Beach Burnouts | TwinbrookJiveTurkeys |
| 2004 | San Diego Surfriders | Washington Wildcards | Aspen Hill Choadies |
| 2003 | Soho Suns | Washington Wildcards | Arizona Aids |
| 2002 | Dallas Dark Lords | Washington Wildcards | Germantown Goats |
* - The league this year was hosted by Fanball.com and the records have since been lost.