Creating image version without specifying max-width (original size), results in smaller image file size (lesser quality?) than a smaller px image?

[Eric-Tran]

I created an image with different versions, however the original image size (which is larger in px), is a smaller file size than an image version that is smaller in px.

• Operating system

  • [ ] Mac

• Node.js version (node --version)

  • [ ] Node.js v6.x

• ImageMagick version (identify -version)

  • [ ] ImageMagick v7.0.x

• s3-uploader version

  • [ ] v2.x

Steps to reproduce

Resized image smaller than original produces a bigger file size than original image . Create an image size without specifying maxWidth: (i.e retain original px size). Compare that with an image with a smaller maxWidth. Original image is around 1000px.

example:

versions: [{ format: 'png', suffix: '-orig', quality: 100 }, { maxWidth: 600, format: 'png', suffix: '-med', quality: 100 },

This results in the -orig being a smaller filesize than -med.

-orig size ~24kb -med size ~165kb

Expect original to be larger file size since it is a larger image. Same quality settings.

[Starefossen]

Did resolve this issue, @Eric-Tran ?

[Eric-Tran]

Yes issue has been resolved, my mistake the original image was actually smaller than the -med version.

On Nov 17, 2016, at 2:34 PM, Hans Kristian Flaatten notifications@github.com wrote:

Did resolve this issue, @Eric-Tran ?

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.