Closed CrowdfordBot closed 1 year ago
shapechange: <@242983689921888256> <@544125116640919557> <@432509498574503947> (pinging you because you've had some name suggestions for other roles in the past) - any thoughts on this?
the8thsoul: Pack Brothers
the8thsoul: idk
shapechange: Ideally it would have Wolf in the name
mctsts: I agree that the name is not optimal, but I don't think there's much value in renaming it
the8thsoul: Wolf Siblings
mctsts: We barely ever use the role
the8thsoul: lol yeah
mctsts: We last used it in S9G1A
mctsts: But I'm currently struggling to understand why
the8thsoul: maybe coz it's only useful against WWW
the8thsoul: there is literally no other point in the role existing
mctsts: Incorrect
e_thsn: Vampires too
mctsts: it also works against old Cupid and Vampire
the8thsoul: Ah
the8thsoul: forgot
the8thsoul: But we also rarely use Vampire right? In comparison to Hell, Pyro and WWW
mctsts: Anyway it seems in S9G1A it was used potentially as it was a partial list(?) and to throw off the counts of categories?
mctsts: so it wasnt even used to have HH from what I can tell
e_thsn: I think we don't use it because it wastes 2 wolves and we never really have many basic wolves unless we have www which WWW can't mimic HH
e_thsn: basically
e_thsn: we can't have 2 wolves with an extra power if we have hh
e_thsn: whereas AW which fills a similar role costs 1 wolf and has extra powers
the8thsoul: maybe hh should have some slight buff
the8thsoul: like an ability that can only be used when there are at least 2 alive
e_thsn: I think maybe HH can mimic an arbitrary Pack role each
mctsts: We've only used the role 4 times on this server OS3C For its main purpose as WWW counter S6G6 As Vampire Counter (since then this use has been superceded by AW) OS8E Actually for its purpose from what I can tell (WWW counter) S9G1A Lone HH Reason unknown? Only to throw of a partial list?
e_thsn: that way you can have HH + not waste a slot
mctsts: So this role has been used 2 times for its actual purpose here
mctsts: And that purpose is to counter one of the already harder to play as solos
mctsts: And the solo that already makes it harder to design a wolfpack
mctsts: Which coincidentally is the same thing HHs also do
mctsts: The role barely has any value as it, so we might as well remove it honestly
e_thsn: remember we had them Os8D as vamp + Graveyard counter but we used hellish scared wolves
mctsts: that's been superceded by Alpha Wolf since then
e_thsn: Also
the8thsoul: So basically Alpha Wolf should've just been a complete replacement to Hellhound?
e_thsn: AW used to have a reveal to pack when it uses it's killchange that's been completely mitigated in use by it's loyalty ability
mctsts: AW just does alignment change counter better than HH
mctsts: so HH only really work as WWW counter now
e_thsn:
When they overwrite the wolfpack poll, the Alpha Wolf may also choose to reveal themself to the pack.
This was so AW could prove they hadn't changed alignment
Kinda useless now
mctsts:
This was so AW could prove they hadn't changed alignment ??
mctsts: source of that quote
e_thsn: quoted wrong part
mctsts: Yeah, that's not correct
mctsts: The announcement is so they can prove themselves same way as RK/Barber/Exe
e_thsn: but why would they need to do that outside of alignment changes
e_thsn: they paint a target on their back if they do it vs www
mctsts: its so they can prove themselves as not WWW 🤷
shapechange: Hellhound should, imo, be renamed for two reasons: a) improving consistency - all other lycans, except bloody butcher, have the word "wolf" in their name: this also makes them easy to identify b) potential confusion with hell team - whilst i don't think actual confusion has been an issue, it really doesn't make sense to have a role called hellhound on a team other than hell
So, this is really two issues in one: should Hellhound be renamed, and if so, to what?