WerewolvesRevamped / Werewolves-Roles

The role book for Werewolves Revamped
7 stars 8 forks source link

Horseman Discussion OS10C #1191

Closed CrowdfordBot closed 11 months ago

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: Does anyone have any issues, comments, opinions or anything else on Horsemen after OS10C?

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

shapechange: I think they were good this game.

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: better demo of hm than previous games

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: I think they were pretty solid too

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: they had a reasonable shot at winning which mostly was destroyed by an unlucky N1 death

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

phantomtomic: Give horses n1 attack protection /hj

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

shapechange:

Give horses n1 attack protection /hj

no

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

shapechange: git gud

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

phantomtomic: <:cri:998956661618266132>

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: <@&1045732542399131769> <@&1128435183113220106> Are there any further things we nee to do with HM or are they ready for unlimiting?

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: are they?

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: They seem like it

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

captainluffy: i have no issues with it

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: one keeps dying n1

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: They have been through 6 games without major issues or changes

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: i feel like that doesnt show proper balance

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: 6 hm games??

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: huh

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: Well we can still tell from that

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: 6???

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: i remember exactly 1

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: If they were winning games with unlucky N1 deaths so we could think they're too strong

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: yeah

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: They've been used 6 times and have not received major changes

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

e_thsn: I think the N1 deaths are an occurrence of wolves randomising the kill that's not a HM issue just a luck issue

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: id say try until one doesnt did early

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: The only somewhat significant change we've had is giving extra dooms

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

captainluffy: the only thing we changed is that yeah

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

captainluffy: which i guess hasnt been tested much

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds:

I think the N1 deaths are an occurrence of wolves randomising the kill that's not a HM issue just a luck issue

hm dying n1 makes it impossible to show proper balance because one team member is missing for the entirety of the game

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: S9G7 did not have a N1 death

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: the previous usage

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: same for S9G1B, the one before

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: I think 3 seasons and 6 usages is reasonable

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

e_thsn: They came close to winning this game despite one of them throwing and one dying early

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds:

S9G7 did not have a N1 death

hm lost after 4 days without even going apoc, was that before or after the change?

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: before

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: that's why we buffed them

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds:

They came close to winning this game despite one of them throwing and one dying early

so if 1 was still alive they would have more dooms

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: i think the change is good but its such a big change that id say we play one more hm game with this change just to see if it doesnt make them too strong

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: as the list was balanced for 3p hm and hm were extremely close to winning with 2p

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: and one even missed n1 dooms

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: this sounds strong

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: like

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: too strong

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: I don't think they were that close to winning?

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: they were

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: they got apoc

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

mctsts: They could've still been lynched easily

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: true

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

venomousbirds: but it was close