search

Wulf2k / DaS-PC-MPChan

78 stars 30 forks source link

Autostart Dark Souls #79

Open Chronial opened 8 years ago

Chronial commented 8 years ago

Should we add a flag to autostart Dark Souls with DSCM? That would probably make life easier for most users.

Wulf2k commented 8 years ago

Maybe a button. I'm not sure on autostart. Not opposed, just not sure.

Is it easy to do?

Keep in mind, it's not as simple as launching the EXE. Steam launches it in some unique way, or else it just immediately exits.

Chronial commented 8 years ago

A button would defeat the purpose: To save on clicks. Yes, it's quite easy. The trick is hidden in the shortcuts that steam creates in your startmenu. Opening steam://rungameid/211420 will run the game via steam.

Wulf2k commented 8 years ago

Keep in mind the possibility of machines that could have Steam sandboxed, or just have the steam:// association broken. As long as it handles failure properly then I'm ok with it being automatic.

gpotter2 commented 8 years ago

It is pretty easy actually to start dark souls without the "steam://" association: you just got to start steam.exe with the "-applaunch 211420" param. I added the function here: https://github.com/Wulf2k/DaS-PC-MPChan/pull/84

It might also be a good idea to add an option to disable it... But as adding checkboxes again and again would not have been relevent, i haven't done that...

Chronial commented 8 years ago

How is it a better idea to rely on undocumented registry values instead of using the documented way?

gpotter2 commented 8 years ago

Huh, that's what wulf2k just said (or at least what i've understood :smile: )

Keep in mind the possibility of machines that could have Steam sandboxed, or just have the steam:// association broken.

Cause if the "steam://" association is broken,

steam://rungameid/211420

won't do anything at all... where as using directly the steam.exe will work.

Those values are not documented, but there are used by any steam program to get the steam path, so they always exist

Wulf2k commented 8 years ago

I was thinking more of a "fail gracefully" situation than anything else.

I'm at work right now so I can't look into the code here yet.

Chronial commented 8 years ago

Why do you think that there could be a situation where the registry keys that you look at are set, but the registry keys required for steam: to work are not?

gpotter2 commented 8 years ago

Well, i don't really know We could use the steam: of course, but if the user reseted the url protocols, it won't work... Moreover, it's harder to detect if the link is working or not, than just launching a file...

Chronial commented 8 years ago

I think this is blocked by #94. When we add this, we should probably also add a close with Dark Souls option. The question is how we should handle updates in that case. Due to DSCM-net we very much care that everybody is on the latest version, and if we autostart and -close with DS, nobody will see the update notices.

Wulf2k commented 8 years ago

I'm still not convinced this is a necessary feature.

What are your thoughts after a week+ of pondering it?

Chronial commented 8 years ago

I think it would be nice to have, but rather low priority.

Chronial commented 8 years ago

The people are hungry for it :) https://www.reddit.com/r/darksouls/comments/4o26oj/is_there_a_way_to_run_dscm_automatically_when_i/ https://www.reddit.com/r/darksouls/comments/4nk0ta/tutorial_how_to_launch_dscm_dark_souls_with_one/

karasuhebi commented 8 years ago

Yeah I'll throw in my two cents and say that I'd like to see this feature implemented. :)

gpotter2 commented 8 years ago

This function is still useable https://github.com/Wulf2k/DaS-PC-MPChan/pull/84

darkarrow commented 7 years ago

If you do choose to implement this I would ask that you make it optional. Because I play Dark Souls using steam in-home streaming currently and it auto-starting the game wouldn't be beneficial at all.