anjoru
commented
6 months ago Thank you for the review and comments. They were all very helpful and relevant and I will work on addressing them. I suspect the issue you had with the processing file stems from the bird data file. It was so large that I did not store it in GitHub. It turns out that it was crowd-sourced data that was not reliable. I thought I had deleted that chunk, but I didn't. The other reviewer could not run that portion of the qmd either.
You must have worked with Rosmarie Kelly or maybe Tiffanny at DPH. They are both great. Did you use gravid traps or light traps? I think they are using both, but I can't remember for sure.
Regarding this project, this work is going to inform how I will approach my dissertation research that will start later this year. I will need more and better data, for sure. I am working on gathering that now.
Again, I appreciate the feedback. Have a great weekend!' Andrew
On Fri, Mar 22, 2024 at 7:37 PM rachelr989 @.***> wrote:
Hi Andrew, Your project is very interesting to me so far! I have been interested in vector-borne disease transmission dynamics for a while and have done research with Zika virus. I also got to do some mosquito trapping with the GA DPH for West Nile surveillance. I am excited to see your interesting findings with ecological factors that affect EEE prevalence in mosquito vectors! Overall, your manuscript was very well written and easy to understand. Your data was reproducible, however I had issues with my system. Some of the readme files need to be updated, but most provide a good amount of detail and steps for how to run the code. This is a great start. For further comments and your “grade”, please see the attached document. [ Part-3-Robertson-Review_Ruiz.docx https://github.com/anjoru/RUIZ-MADA-project/files/14729318/Part-3-Robertson-Review_Ruiz.docx ]
— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/anjoru/RUIZ-MADA-project/issues/4, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AZVEVYLK54LC4FJFBUTWWV3YZS6CRAVCNFSM6AAAAABFEEE5R6VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43ASLTON2WKOZSGIYDGNJQGIYTEOI . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: @.***>
Hi Andrew, Your project is very interesting to me so far! I have been interested in vector-borne disease transmission dynamics for a while and have done research with Zika virus. I also got to do some mosquito trapping with the GA DPH for West Nile surveillance. I am excited to see your interesting findings with ecological factors that affect EEE prevalence in mosquito vectors! Overall, your manuscript was very well written and easy to understand. Your data was reproducible, however I had issues with my system. Some of the readme files need to be updated, but most provide a good amount of detail and steps for how to run the code. This is a great start. For further comments and your “grade”, please see the attached document. [ Part-3-Robertson-Review_Ruiz.docx ]