unable to continue development

atsushieno / managed-midi

[Past project] Cross-platform MIDI processing library for mono and .NET (ALSA, CoreMIDI, Android, WinMM and UWP).

MIT License

195 stars 26 forks source link

unable to continue development #42

Open atsushieno opened 5 years ago

atsushieno commented 5 years ago

managed-midi development is achieved based on the premise that dotnet tools run on Linux without problem. Unfortunately it's been broken for not short terms. Microsoft keeps shipping broken .NET Core on Linux releases which makes it difficult to continue development.

So far, until Microsoft fixes those issues it is going to be impossible to continue development of this library and all the relevant projects.

https://github.com/dotnet/sdk/issues/2902
https://github.com/mono/mono/issues/13537 or probably https://github.com/dotnet/source-build/issues/1025 and/or https://github.com/dotnet/source-build/issues/1033
probably more, impossible to examine further.

atsushieno commented 5 years ago

As a managed-midi alternative, a partial Kotlin port of managed-midi is available at https://github.com/atsushieno/fluidsynth-midi-service-j/tree/master/ktmidi (source only, not very mature, no decent API consideration yet). MidiPlayer seems to work so far.

noname22 commented 5 years ago

Well that sucks :(

atsushieno commented 5 years ago

I rebased my development environment to Rider and it's been a while (or, I did that a while ago when I was writing C# code) and I dumped dotnet as MSBuild engine, then it worked again. I recommend any cross platform developers to dump .NET Core until Microsoft really becomes serious about development on Linux. "Microsoft &heart; Linux" is just fraud.

jeroenwalter commented 5 years ago

I'm glad you got it working again :)

PlatinumLucario commented 2 years ago

Just a curious question: Has dotnet improved since then? I'm aware that Standard and Core have been unified since .NET 5.

Reason I ask, is because I'm actually trying to port C# libraries and applications to use cross-platform (mostly Linux) APIs.

atsushieno commented 2 years ago

Since Visual Studio team (which was on top of xamarin and mono teams when I exited) killed monodevelop a few years ago, I didn't even evaluate later dotnet versions.

maximilien-noal commented 10 months ago

I work with .NET 8 and JetBrains Rider or vscode on Linux daily without any issue, but I don't use multi-targeting.

The only issue I have is built-in cross platform audio (including MIDI) support. There is none.

For MIDI, managed midi was my last hope, but alas. :/