bisq-network / roles

@bisq-network contributor roles
https://bisq.wiki/Roles
15 stars 16 forks source link

Arbitrator (formerly known as Refund Agent) #93

Open RefundAgent opened 4 years ago

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

My role is to refund traders who cannot resolve their differences using the mediators. The traders have their BTC sent to the Donation Address owner if they escalate to me. In my role I need to pay the traders according to my judgement of the dispute and is reimbursed by a highly volatile BSQ at the end of each voting cycle. Check https://github.com/bisq-network/roles/issues/80 for the present suggestion to reimburse my expenses which should reduce my exposure to the volatility.

Docs: https://bisq.wiki/Arbitrator Team: @bisq-network/arbitrators

ifarnung commented 4 years ago

This is certainly a very important role for BISQ and one that requires both skilled work, and a large degree of trust. Thanks for your efforts thus far!

I haven't seen any reports from your refund activity and the last known info. was given by @burningman2. Could you please update publicly the current state of your refund activities?

Update regarding refund agent accounting:

The refund agent has paid 9.639 BTC so far for reimbursing traders (cyle 8: 2.3925, cycle 9: 4.09617, pending for cycle 10: 3.15033). Due to lack of accounting and increased BSQ volatility the trades with the refund agent have been too much and the requested BSQ way too less.

He traded 195912.19 BSQ for 14.15 BTC, so that is 4,511 BTC too much and 122011.19 BSQ is missing from reimbursement requests. He made compensation requests for 73901 BSQ so far (should have been reimbursement requests).

If this summary was accurate, how much of the 4.511 BTC surplus do you have left from this month's refunds?

Another question regarding this role specifically, will it have an associated bond?

Thanks for your time.

For those that might be looking through thread #80, here is the relevant suggestion:

"Here is my suggestion how to do it:

Refund agent needs to refund trader with xxx BTC. He use his private BTC to pre-finance it.

At the burningmans weekly trade event he makes an BSQ offer to cover his outstanding BTC with the BSQ market price. He will sell his own BSQ as he has not got the BSQ reimbursement at that moment (he pre-finance it). He get xxx BTC for selling yyy BSQ. So his BTC pre-financing is recovered now. The BSQ amount which he pre-financed now he will add to the list for the reimbursement later. At the end of the cycle he will make a reimbursement request with the sum of all his pre-financed BSQ and after he gets that issued he has recovered also his outstanding BSQ.

The BSQ price change over the cycle is now less relevant as the trade activity is done relatively shortly after the refund (week). He still takes liquidity risk in case not enough BSQ are open for trading from the burningman. In that case he would try to recover his outstanding BTC at the follow up week.

For doing those 2 times pre-financing and taking the risk he should charge some amount of BSQ as well as for the work as refund agent (mediation). This should be made as compensation request, the BSQ amount he pre-financed should be done as reimbursement request."

huey735 commented 4 years ago

There's no reason for this role. The donation address owner, @burningman2, should have this function.

burningman2 commented 4 years ago

@huey735 No, those are 2 different roles.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report March 1 2020:

Paid out 11.4729727 BTC in 45 transactions until Feb 29 [1]. 39 dispute cases are closed, 10 are open [2]. Some cases had 2 payouts to both traders. Got reimbursed 73901 BSQ (26210 BSQ + 47691 BSQ) in past compensation requests [https://github.com/bisq-network/compensation/issues/447, https://github.com/bisq-network/compensation/issues/465]. I sold in total 195912.19 BSQ for 14.15 BTC in trades with the burningman [https://github.com//issues/80#issuecomment-579022534]. Due lack of accounting I over-sold BSQ to BTC. To enable a fresh start with a more solid strategy I prefer to remove those trades which have lead to the over-sell and start then with the posposal as suggested in #80 (comment). If I deduct the trades which have exceeded the real demand for refunding I end up with 11.5 BTC traded to 144701 BSQ at average price of 0.00007947 BSQ/BTC. This adjustment means I consider 3 trade as private trades and do not account them for the refund agent demand. Unfortunately those have been traded to very low BSQ prices and it ends up in a loss for myself of 20034 BSQ if I would convert the BTC back to BSQ at current market rate of 0.000085 BSQ/BTC.

From the 144701 BSQ which I received by refunding 11.5 BTC (0.03 BTC is difference to what I already refunded) I got 73901 BSQ already reimbursed, so it is missing 70800 BSQ.

@cbeams, @m52go Do you think that is acceptable with our current issuance limits? Please note that this is not a compensation but a reimbursement of the BTC the burningman has converted already back to BSQ by burning them. It should have been requested in the past cycles already but I did not had time to get to that final report to have a correct overview.

Summary: In total I spent 11.4729727 BTC. I traded 11.5 BTC to 144701 BSQ (average rate 0.00007947 BSQ/BTC). I received 73901 BSQ as reimbursement (past compensation requests). 70800 BSQ is still missing for reimbursement.

[1] List of transactions of payouts:

Date/Time,Details,Address,Transaction ID,Amount in BTC,Confirmations 22 Feb 2020 14:57:12,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 12sUDB5F4yoAmuhta8Rev9BosrMuHzzXAD,7469b8456f0e7f44259df8ee9327e7f0dd67d0c3fa1b95324fb9036d7c6e6fc1,-0.016026,1054 20 Feb 2020 10:54:06,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 12KfM7ojeUbvqpRYFfqe1gGxonCMtGdUWr,3ca708580d97c7c04ecca7f096b7d926fedf105b74f152cc21856becc29b3b24,-0.022026,1376 17 Feb 2020 15:10:49,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 17dKSkkxb5gsAXLtmXniBEVYQ5WrDezwDR,4819d61a64a31ff203954a9a4376680ca1ed6645e9d3f766898814a888d2eeaf,-0.07904160,1786 8 Feb 2020 16:08:29,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 17ZCLTtRk3oVSKxxZACh1cUhZZ6VMppKts,032f693275a99187c31ec70f2aee4bb05e176c41048a8a7d1960845cc48a2a5d,-0.02203640,3041 6 Feb 2020 11:19:34,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1M3LkV13nHGe8dLWJWUPsSuu4hLgXFYN1W,f1cb9a1a36ba8ba8fd0196d70d48a418a259ca4994c5e3e718f45194dc30f404,-0.016026,3344 28 Jan 2020 17:24:33,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1DKkizxMJ8UFGYtTqYvNFHYxHjiVGDQ1jC,ca8e4f67680b3e2f6c4b0dce2b9fb895126f12132a2d83d485546d2f5f4eca1d,-0.17242140,4643 28 Jan 2020 16:53:05,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1PK4yYGzKssnfRbTkzGbJy195MnVcHWHu8,53c7095a143acdafeffcd0867f82b1a617dcd29bc3fdc1430c86622685235cc6,-2.14004476,4645 26 Jan 2020 12:06:49,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 12XyZLducBpb6ozBrFqSp14kKH9esQ33nR,a113c206080d19e72aa117005141fcb11da97512201859af0f825a4850f5dd19,-0.020026,4947 26 Jan 2020 12:06:49,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1HaPQeNUUzaqiBdcSXAzBcbQ7tfghbUqEM,e0c083e6c8dc502d0091b9be05c09e0836660d10d29802c7e5fdc27e9f6c0f10,-0.016026,4947 21 Jan 2020 21:36:30,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1L1x6nB1YzpZcKtfARxGomxUgyxkUWm8FD,2dca2ed7beac18c24833c689f2a9eef33e0606ac68d2c0c101ebeca14af43e7d,-0.01606714,5671 21 Jan 2020 21:36:30,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1KgNJQtPczwCS3ApNjuKk67UrQANp2UkfL,29fe565fbdec039068328b68a62e21291306a1efba285370ec0787dfb9da51f4,-0.07504680,5671 21 Jan 2020 21:36:30,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1ARwVPpTkjUnpwyUNiBRA19iFJttMREBkd,fcf58c9646d4ae151b0cc728314cfedccab36b82ec2e28e8988f4ca208b50984,-0.01604680,5671 21 Jan 2020 21:36:30,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 19PtMGXeAsvrHGuXfyq1eBGpeggSznw46t,7ccf5fa3667829cec861afe8bc9930bfc354959e426096be4014ba437d759840,-0.01606714,5671 21 Jan 2020 21:15:23,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 17GX5p74pcz9sCHraxpe5oFSkd6WWruT5e,489c0dba61787d7e61a4da039d6669438a7119c9bd52398bf763bc75af6fa731,-0.01604680,5673 19 Jan 2020 21:24:15,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1D6aSjoejG3rL8q6VkTiRfvEkphtkY4fHF,bdab2e127978596cbe459a2b012de11a675aa3e1cd2cd80a4bf23a9efe7222ba,-0.018446,5979 13 Jan 2020 22:55:32,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1CYx5GVK68pJagaEW7Q6VfLcw5G2Wv9oUE,7da2eae261003b29fa1eb2334356a728eef2a271f6fc9af746d0767c33aaf09a,-0.01593640,6857 13 Jan 2020 22:55:32,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1CouPseGP4m9TyjZG1WBX36zsaUTBb2QmY,0f4e32ba4391d6bbc52bddaa76a6ae0d1f0f90d4bd5e9fa173947b11b090b553,-0.01593640,6857 4 Jan 2020 18:47:55,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1AaRhDZoE7fRSyGnG2C7Z9D7NaARXnsXeu,7c4ff560d2cec00fdaf36403e1669da7e7408563362fada1f4cea21d1ebd172d,-0.017026,8279 4 Jan 2020 18:47:55,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1PE6PRGoBsfSH9fovj7tr1stSf4BfpvgBV,864c78dabc1d706c46d11b0816d13917e752bb941995bd4851e08bb6567b2eeb,-0.008326,8279 4 Jan 2020 18:47:55,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1DUHm6n9FU6KNm4p1e6ARGvgYazjHFBvLZ,23fb73fa887137044b1f095ecb0cb5686d51c652d681a555e43bfc3c5b2ca8b5,-2.14003730,8279 4 Jan 2020 18:47:55,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1FRYgdPzoaSDafjEB3sV4kgXYnqNM6vW7G,290b8b6b3758ee6a559a16f3f95f1760df2df742e03e88ec657fafc8e0ac6afc,-0.017026,8279 29 Dec 2019 22:07:29,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 13qazV5CMfRbZq1EaFhvb43HZL2Ni9QgPh,49c898a7e13610c3046c478e457735d434fff5b75a06d18b28a7b61c86d830b7,-0.060026,9208 29 Dec 2019 21:24:04,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 17uVN4gaygZTfdMU65TNHhygF3g9xKFyBA,b811d2885054f6b96b433cccf78047aaa50ec795aa6c4a404862d67d39dd58ae,-0.019026,9212 25 Dec 2019 17:24:53,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 13sSPUwWAxjGtZzUTHyry4Q3coPDFdGyAe,38c86afaf3cbda2007372653447d81cf869ee5752609f8825afde7a58635aa7b,-1.90003740,9840 25 Dec 2019 17:01:33,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1DKPUG8fUSwaZugKKycx9G2QK8wtU4WZVq,a8aa99c420f7a729b9a021f7e6216e9d065d3aa2508f20472118eb524787d5e5,-0.017896,9844 25 Dec 2019 16:10:52,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 14KFhBbURvXiDSf7g6fNzerfmTqqnVzujd,c1bb3a442a33d071457f5beb7b2c0e43e15556a54f93bebe651897ab031924cd,-0.016136,9846 21 Dec 2019 16:17:32,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1H6sjydx1eJSTxDSuMeX9vfgwsrqVKcTbV,f6e0f91bdf2e457fe11a51626c77ca60f52087cd2580222f021d631c7d33fd2e,-0.019026,10434 21 Dec 2019 16:17:32,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 14CDYu8GRYiLK2L6DFSwU8Jqaxdm8n2ejk,84e65a2557ac533e707953dc5ce0f7c8ed907e54e823a4cf1d0ca577f7164f5b,-0.016026,10434 17 Dec 2019 22:45:09,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1gpFncr1eXHPjzAS9C3JXmqSVNGYJPsxn,7ce2af24e6cf95f4d48a7f742ec0f33e49554237837edb20406763ec12168359,-2.14006228,11009 15 Dec 2019 19:45:05,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1E71jRnXZzXoa8XbqRx3LPR7qJ5fXxiPyW,495d461cec4bbd31f143a05246070397783e097abfd1154153f6ef0036fab132,-0.01723640,11319 12 Dec 2019 19:10:27,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 19CoUfYLgLTrX8xATZEW6GLCuMp71HsDqh,22c9be8bae41e02732c171a1287a142970fa069147fd286a2469c44671f28079,-0.07703640,11750 12 Dec 2019 19:10:27,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1H1x3PywWcJiT5UMqsvpcx4x99ebW6XE9N,4c1516554fa81cc7720a47ebee585413380ee2bac7812570b11e2580da018a1f,-0.01605236,11750 8 Dec 2019 21:39:55,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1BTRX14qvot1eaaWYB4eFohVrgRrYPiADT,5c30579f8948a72cc06832379ffed0438ae687fd9e7ce7acc3ea2e51ebc407f6,-0.016026,12305 8 Dec 2019 20:59:38,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1MgM8gDxiGJhrLFueMxKwVYpJpZNiiGt7A,df582a5d82283e227b0c684d895e1f27c257d2cf234cd85f8619bd2c3c76f967,-0.015526,12307 8 Dec 2019 20:23:48,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1PCDQTW3VMLBAgfSLsHcYf4WVNGH8G1f8v,03c4440e20d1992994a67ea068c121592d63e87e5303185d6829a289af05ebb8,-0.019026,12308 6 Dec 2019 16:28:13,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1Fq3jLbkGNRpixTVCw9PU5FUKRUbCjzGs5,9ebe1e7d7013cd8ece4ff262b3baa0ea5d38ac27a00dd79eea931c9564f4de44,-2.20006252,12643 6 Dec 2019 16:28:13,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1uPeMoHeai8rgfa2fdor2QTDje1TPyFpm,82ca67fb990106bcf7c8ebe9132641977cc79e04f8de426bd75cc0293b8533ee,-0.01603640,12643 5 Dec 2019 22:51:15,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1JemZzwMfKrsoZZUPcKRfRFB1ZaRgrab71,b7024829e1b414e10472688cb4604efaee2a801ff89c4fd56a9f4437984288c3,-0.016026,12739 5 Dec 2019 22:25:04,Withdrawn from wallet,Sent to: 1PmPa9FQmMDwLk22aiUsJxCLAGb7inrfT,2f1fc07c1cc61dbeafd221ad5d6194b910e096589cbad87d4a1f4fd631059b7a,-0.016026,12741

[2] The disputes, including pending disputes, are as follows:

Dispute nr. 1 Opening date: 21 Nov 2019 03:19:19 Close date: 8 Dec 2019 20:06:18 Duration: 17 days, 16 hours, 46 minutes Summary notes: Buyer could not pay due to Zelle locking his account due to suspicous activity. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 2 Opening date: 25 Nov 2019 13:45:01 Close date: 5 Dec 2019 22:40:30 Duration: 10 days, 8 hours, 55 minutes Summary notes: Buyer did not pay and loses his security deposit. Reason: PROTOCOL_VIOLATION

Dispute nr. 3 Opening date: 25 Nov 2019 19:18:52 Close date: 8 Dec 2019 21:27:53 Duration: 13 days, 2 hours, 9 minutes Summary notes: Buyer showed evidence he paid. Seller did not respond to repeated messages. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 4 Opening date: 27 Nov 2019 02:26:55 Close date: 6 Dec 2019 16:16:11 Duration: 9 days, 13 hours, 49 minutes Summary notes: The buyer showed that he paid. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 5 Opening date: 27 Nov 2019 10:42:11 Close date: 15 Dec 2019 19:34:30 Duration: 18 days, 8 hours, 52 minutes Summary notes: Seller says buyer did not pay. Buyer is not responding. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 6 Opening date: 28 Nov 2019 06:35:58 Close date: 8 Dec 2019 20:46:04 Duration: 10 days, 14 hours, 10 minutes Summary notes: Buyer did not pay and did not reply to repeated messages. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 7 Opening date: 28 Nov 2019 09:29:23 Close date: 25 Dec 2019 15:55:15 Duration: 27 days, 6 hours, 25 minutes Summary notes: Seller got paid and buyer seems to have some technical problems with his app. The technical problems should be sorted out on e. g. Keybase or the forum. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 8 Opening date: 30 Nov 2019 12:29:17 Close date: 6 Dec 2019 16:17:29 Duration: 6 days, 3 hours, 48 minutes Summary notes: Seller says he got paid. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 9 Opening date: 30 Nov 2019 12:29:29 Close date: 5 Dec 2019 22:23:00 Duration: 5 days, 9 hours, 53 minutes Summary notes: Seller got paid but left the trade to arbitration in order to get signed. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 10 Opening date: 1 Dec 2019 00:41:25

Dispute nr. 11 Opening date: 2 Dec 2019 14:44:53 Close date: 12 Dec 2019 18:55:24 Duration: 10 days, 4 hours, 10 minutes Summary notes: Seller says buyer did not pay and buyer does not respond to repeated messages. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 12 Opening date: 7 Dec 2019 01:58:59 Close date: 17 Dec 2019 18:11:04 Duration: 10 days, 16 hours, 12 minutes Summary notes: Seller says buyer did not pay and buyer does not respond despite repeated messages. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 13 Opening date: 8 Dec 2019 12:08:27 Close date: 12 Dec 2019 18:51:22 Duration: 4 days, 6 hours, 42 minutes Summary notes: Buyer proved he paid. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 14 Opening date: 10 Dec 2019 11:14:22 Close date: 21 Dec 2019 16:01:38 Duration: 11 days, 4 hours, 47 minutes Summary notes: Buyer did not pay and did not respond. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 15 Opening date: 13 Dec 2019 00:28:32 Close date: 29 Dec 2019 22:02:29 Duration: 16 days, 21 hours, 33 minutes Summary notes: Buyer showed evidence he paid, seller did not reply despite repeated messages. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 16 Opening date: 16 Dec 2019 20:49:36 Close date: 21 Dec 2019 16:07:34 Duration: 4 days, 19 hours, 17 minutes Summary notes: Seller refunded buyer due to technical problems and buyer confirmed this. Reason: BUG

Dispute nr. 17 Opening date: 17 Dec 2019 04:00:15 Close date: 25 Dec 2019 16:34:20 Duration: 8 days, 12 hours, 34 minutes Summary notes: Buyer showed evidence he paid. Seller did not respond. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 18 Opening date: 17 Dec 2019 19:40:07 Close date: 29 Dec 2019 21:20:50 Duration: 12 days, 1 hour, 40 minutes Summary notes: Buyer apparently did not pay and did not reply despite repeated messages. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 19 Opening date: 22 Dec 2019 10:15:25 Close date: 25 Dec 2019 17:21:17 Duration: 3 days, 7 hours, 5 minutes Summary notes: Buyer proved he paid. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 20 Opening date: 24 Dec 2019 00:50:21 Close date: 4 Jan 2020 18:39:53 Duration: 11 days, 17 hours, 49 minutes Summary notes: Buyer apparently did not pay and buyer did not reply to repeated messages. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 21 Opening date: 26 Dec 2019 22:05:31 Close date: 4 Jan 2020 18:38:13 Duration: 8 days, 20 hours, 32 minutes Summary notes: Seller confirmed he got paid. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 22 Opening date: 26 Dec 2019 22:06:51 Close date: 4 Jan 2020 18:37:27 Duration: 8 days, 20 hours, 30 minutes Summary notes: Seller confirmed he got paid. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 23 Opening date: 30 Dec 2019 00:18:28 Close date: 4 Jan 2020 18:35:26 Duration: 5 days, 18 hours, 16 minutes Summary notes: Buyer proved he paid. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 24 Opening date: 31 Dec 2019 08:49:23 Close date: 13 Jan 2020 22:54:11 Duration: 13 days, 14 hours, 4 minutes Summary notes: Buyer says he paid and seller does not respond. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 25 Opening date: 6 Jan 2020 06:54:29

Dispute nr. 26 Opening date: 7 Jan 2020 08:07:29 Close date: 13 Jan 2020 22:50:44 Duration: 6 days, 14 hours, 43 minutes Summary notes: Seller confirmed that he got paid and forgot to confirm in the app. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 27 Opening date: 9 Jan 2020 03:24:42 Close date: 19 Jan 2020 21:20:45 Duration: 10 days, 17 hours, 56 minutes Summary notes: Some technical problem made the trade fail. Reason: BUG

Dispute nr. 28 Opening date: 9 Jan 2020 22:33:13 Close date: 21 Jan 2020 20:11:04 Duration: 11 days, 21 hours, 37 minutes Summary notes: Seller says buyer did not pay and buyer does not respond despite repeated messages. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 29 Opening date: 9 Jan 2020 22:52:53 Close date: 21 Jan 2020 20:46:42 Duration: 11 days, 21 hours, 53 minutes Summary notes: Seller says buyer did not pay and buyer is quiet despite repeated messages. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 30 Opening date: 9 Jan 2020 22:53:02 Close date: 21 Jan 2020 20:12:01 Duration: 11 days, 21 hours, 18 minutes Summary notes: Seller says buyer did not pay and buyer does not respond despite repeated messages. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 31 Opening date: 9 Jan 2020 22:53:10 Close date: 21 Jan 2020 20:45:18 Duration: 11 days, 21 hours, 52 minutes Summary notes: Seller says buyer did not pay and buyer does not respond despite repeated messages. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 32 Opening date: 12 Jan 2020 01:09:21 Close date: 28 Jan 2020 16:50:39 Duration: 16 days, 15 hours, 41 minutes Summary notes: The buyer proved he paid, the seller did not respond to repeated messages. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 33 Opening date: 16 Jan 2020 19:28:04 Close date: 21 Jan 2020 20:04:29 Duration: 5 days, 0 hours, 36 minutes Summary notes: Buyer could not pay since the trade was moved to failed trades. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 34 Opening date: 16 Jan 2020 19:28:31 Close date: 26 Jan 2020 12:03:18 Duration: 9 days, 16 hours, 34 minutes Summary notes: Seller confirmed he got paid. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 35 Opening date: 16 Jan 2020 21:26:26 Close date: 26 Jan 2020 12:06:03 Duration: 9 days, 14 hours, 39 minutes Summary notes: Buyer could not pay due to some bank issue. Reason: BANK_PROBLEMS

Dispute nr. 36 Opening date: 24 Jan 2020 05:45:06 Close date: 28 Jan 2020 17:23:58 Duration: 4 days, 11 hours, 38 minutes Summary notes: The buyer paid but a bug did not allow them to accept the mediation suggestion. All transactions seem OK. Reason: OTHER

Dispute nr. 37 Opening date: 24 Jan 2020 19:56:14 Close date: 6 Feb 2020 11:17:53 Duration: 12 days, 15 hours, 21 minutes Summary notes: Seller sent fiat back, buyer stopped responding. Reason: PROTOCOL_VIOLATION

Dispute nr. 38 Opening date: 30 Jan 2020 16:24:13

Dispute nr. 39 Opening date: 30 Jan 2020 16:24:28

Dispute nr. 40 Opening date: 31 Jan 2020 22:20:45

Dispute nr. 41 Opening date: 5 Feb 2020 09:53:42 Close date: 8 Feb 2020 16:02:17 Duration: 3 days, 6 hours, 8 minutes Summary notes: Buyer apparently did not pay and does not answer despite repeated messages. Reason: PROTOCOL_VIOLATION

Dispute nr. 42 Opening date: 6 Feb 2020 14:28:32

Dispute nr. 43 Opening date: 10 Feb 2020 01:29:12 Close date: 17 Feb 2020 15:05:18 Duration: 7 days, 13 hours, 36 minutes Summary notes: Seller could not confirm. Reason: BUG

Dispute nr. 44 Opening date: 11 Feb 2020 01:19:55

Dispute nr. 45 Opening date: 12 Feb 2020 17:44:50 Close date: 22 Feb 2020 14:54:31 Duration: 9 days, 21 hours, 9 minutes Summary notes: Seller says buyer did not pay and buyer does not respond to repeated messages. Reason: NO_REPLY

Dispute nr. 46 Opening date: 16 Feb 2020 16:33:00

Dispute nr. 47 Opening date: 16 Feb 2020 23:36:48 Close date: 20 Feb 2020 10:52:53 Duration: 3 days, 11 hours, 16 minutes Summary notes: Buyer did not pay he says. Reason: BUG

Dispute nr. 48 Opening date: 24 Feb 2020 02:08:23

Dispute nr. 49 Opening date: 28 Feb 2020 13:04:19

Summary of reasons for disputes: OTHER: 20 NO_REPLY: 11 BUG: 4 BANK_PROBLEMS: 1 PROTOCOL_VIOLATION: 3

cbeams commented 4 years ago

Per bisq-network/admin#69, I've just updated the description of this issue to link to the new https://bisq.wiki/Refund_Agent article and @bisq-network/refund-agents team.

The wiki article is just a stub for now. I've asked @RefundAgent to flesh it out, detailing the duties and rights of this role, etc.

cbeams commented 4 years ago

From the 144701 BSQ which I received by refunding 11.5 BTC (0.03 BTC is difference to what I already refunded) I got 73901 BSQ already reimbursed, so it is missing 70800 BSQ.

@cbeams, @m52go Do you think that is acceptable with our current issuance limits? Please note that this is not a compensation but a reimbursement of the BTC the burningman has converted already back to BSQ by burning them. It should have been requested in the past cycles already but I did not had time to get to that final report to have a correct overview.

This sounds reasonable, though we may want to break it up over a couple cycles so as not to create a huge spike all at once. Before we do this for Cycle 11 (or possibly break it up over Cycle 11 and Cycle 12), I have the following request:

There is a lot of confusion about this role, and the closely-related role played by @burningman2. To my knowledge, the relationship and workflow between these roles has never been properly documented anywhere. I would like to see this clearly written down somewhere on the wiki, probably at https://bisq.wiki/Refunds (which would be a member of the Processes category). This document would take an end-to-end approach to documenting the refund process, including:

I will create an issue regarding this documentation immediately after submitting this comment, and I ask that @RefundAgent and/or @burningman2 raise their hands to own that issue. I suggest make the writing and review of that document a condition for complete reimbursement in Cycle 11/12. The purpose of doing so is to make sure that all interested parties, especially stakeholders who see these large reimbursements spiking issuance beyond planned budget levels have a resource they can refer to in order to understand why things work this way and how it all makes sense.

cbeams commented 4 years ago

I will create an issue regarding this documentation immediately after submitting this comment, and I ask that @RefundAgent and/or @burningman2 raise their hands to own that issue.

Done, see bisq-network/admin#70. @RefundAgent, @burningman2, please indicate who among you will own this and I'll assign you accordingly. Thanks.

huey735 commented 4 years ago

@huey735 No, those are 2 different roles.

@burningman2 those are two functions that don't need to be separated into two roles.

burningman2 commented 4 years ago

@huey735 Seperation of concerns makes sense for several reasons. Security, censorhsip resistence and to not mix different requirements (burningman does not need to scale with 100000 of users, refund agent must as well with language extensions). Both have very different risk profiles which makes it easy to scale up the refund agent (he is taking the risk).

burningman2 commented 4 years ago

@cbeams I think the link was wrong (#70).

cbeams commented 4 years ago

@cbeams I think the link was wrong (#70).

Fixed, thanks. See bisq-network/admin#70.

burningman2 commented 4 years ago

Ok, I can take that: https://github.com/bisq-network/admin/issues/70#issuecomment-593964647

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Payout for dispute: Amount: 1.6250373 BTC Date: 8 March Tx ID: 4a45b40cb79a029fa2f9fd60eeeafab2084a856ead8a6db817d02b8f582879db
Trade ID 83494

Traded with burningman: 0.6 BTC for 7500 BSQ at price 0.0008 BSQ/BTC on 8 March.

Remaining BTC not covered yet (try to cover it at next trade event): 1.0250373 BTC

BSQ for reimbursement: 7500 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Payout for dispute:
 Amount: 0.08125 BTC
 Date: 12 March
 Tx ID: ce496815596584d413f32432f04eabe7d61a54555f18bb227d0843b1e50e74c6
Trade ID Trade ebmbz

Amount: 0.0196676 BTC
 Date: 15 March
 Tx ID: 7ee74812f0933783f89b3596a832f67a752648a6d3457a111aaa7d0b6479492f
 Trade ID 313858

Traded with burningman:
1.126 BTC for 13566.27 BSQ at price 0.00083 BSQ/BTC on 15 March.

BSQ for reimbursement:
13566.27 BSQ

cbeams commented 4 years ago

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT

@RefundAgent will cease to own this role starting with the beginning of Cycle 13 (the next cycle at the time of this writing).

This means we are looking for a replacement to take over this role as soon as possible. If you are interested, please speak up!

Note that basic documentation for this role is available at https://bisq.wiki/Refund_Agent and @m52go is working on putting together more comprehensive documentation of the processes involved between the refund agent and the donation address holder (@burningman2).

Suitable candidates for this role will need to have a considerable amount of bitcoin on hand to perform payouts to traders. That bitcoin will be paid back through trades with the donation address holder. The Refund Agent may request compensation for the time and effort expended in handling cases and for the time value of the bitcoin used in these payouts prior to being paid back.

cbeams commented 4 years ago

Note that I have just announced this in the bisq.support Keybase subteam as well. I'll announce it more broadly if I don't hear any interest within the next few days.

clearwater-trust commented 4 years ago

What will happen to trade funds in the interim? I know all funds get donated to some stranger in the 2 of 2 system. I assume traders will have to go directly to the DAO to get compensated in BSQ then trade for BTC if indeed there is any liquidity for that?

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report April 3, 2020. This covers the payouts after March 15 which was reported above. I now give the collateral tx so the readers can check that the funds were sent to the donation address. The cases where I paid out to the buyer and seller addresses are caused by bugs such that the dispute was never sent to the Refund Agent but had to be settled on Keybase. I have given the nyms of the support agents that were involved, in case it was not only me.:

-------------------------------------------------------------------------- At this stage I am even and got compensated by the DAO

19 March ID payout tx af384ec62086bce704fc7ccdea41900b90b76eb08ff4564074de7dade105743c -0.072947 collateral tx aa2f276d691612988984e9b85f1f291efe35942716d5b98e6355cc98aeb7cf64

19 March ID payout tx ee73c63e23083b388d230c5e949c25f43b68dd0c58b5f02f7bc4f734bea4085d -0.0174716 collateral tx 6624227e159f8e2e89f5069c9c9179d755bcdd63848b26ca515464d048f11b78

19 March ID payout tx 713b97bf2fc82dcf68e48e2c64017d6fa74e8bb2916b013cc158946b58ef491d -0.050182 collateral tx a3decdc2a758bf8d735bcdc6d10831b6773ae7c886d20b29faa2f6b502ec315e

20 March ID payout tx 0486bfc5504417d032e736adaff8fa9bd4b2958179e71eb92ca985c3775be0fc -2.60028026 wiz collateral tx 1aeb1cd90e617b75dace8630a17b9c7e23d61f41b80c00db23b18e6f07f0f226

21 March ID 0.57505876 btc to buyer at address tx 54cc39b595d8ec10e602813daf578196c66806a0120e3ed632dccd36a112a67d 0.07505876 btc to seller at address tx f6f7789a866f1d11fbb4e887bad9c8f9f011e9fad2fcab372fa91af62190b0d4 collateral tx eef321786d5492625022189ee75146e057f562299a611eb2ed785be8d8d38389 This trade was never sent to refund agent and communicated by wiz at Keybase

25 March ID payout tx 56ed5871a162cabd13a7991d6cb267921cfd42cdaf939e5d9693a8461f2d8351 -0.0220404 collateral tx 3dec9f3adc71624a41e7eb451f12f759bd190e65a699702c05becd6e9793642a

25 March ID payout tx 98a5212723ffc0ff913a7fe1ce8197468deb24bcd9a29a46268a5010a6057a9d -0.0338244 collateral tx e8fe3d540e0487291714dc2829fdfd5c58f0009c74ccd0ef699251f0838f82d0

29 March ID payout tx ab452f470cf53f1a160c5bd365e94a831d7de662600cd09cd58fa00f2d2e678a -0.057526 collateral tx 0a98f0a9f9fdd821977182a4d3e5fd4c9d2510af3c61e239295210107405fec8

29 March ID payout tx db678f3901f97af49b802fb2112ff9e65fdae7b52156ca0c04315f2305e4e450 -0.037026 collateral tx 67a035c058f57d19521a4631f3e6fb0e2a304d1038d5c8e769cbcba98dad15d1

31 March ID payout tx 9db4246df730710111a1000c5bde40c9fceb06773c1d428bb26e36830574ef58 -0.0220676 collateral tx b8b161db9d8cc2e1855c7f3c2bd9d13d687c82a5d80348dc7f51504439eb6c94

31 March ID payout tx To buyer 0.0195452 at address f4ae090366420e612f0031cba0f7873b9442144a30f646b863e8d9970b73c097 To seller 0.007545 at address 77e9553f9bae6da28a7c74b04bdcfac675b20af387ebb8f7f54aa40e301caaca collateral tx 73016b2ef98da93cba4a5c7878d565ccbf8ee3c1b68e4f8c3e56641872ca908a

1 April ID payout tx 3dd3bcab478e729ff97cb4f9f44d23628bca733277ef062d9a357b003217a4f2 -0.0144364 collateral tx aeb584fbe3cb467200ef6b9b4de5ab174ee4c671c45e81b831359a30e48f1d0d

1 April ID To buyer 0.0220476 at address f4af84df763206a442a81a06bb73466ece777a191dc2be08bf9ec7c88150e983 To seller 0.0060315 at address 43143f2374bec0fc70fd0d3b9478c779cf679be7e7aaee8586c8ddc72eeb47fd collateral tx 90b0a76673268f7b8abae2edf860b84763bbbfc2f8c48a22095951dcb490365b This trade was never sent to refund agent and communicated by leo at Keybase

2 April ID payout tx e6ec888a95d1d698a57e3cfa2b44102db8b61fb608d949a19c2ec1afcdf2a205 -0.048526 collateral tx 86c7ee0c9721345b99e1b5c819b1c2c26ff2c9f8f5883b250c6117d526f333d6

2 April ID payout tx 47e4d17ac0f4cba74b3de5ebde3b2beaa4b1b76f3183376085d76e7000c9e473 -0.016026 collateral tx f6985830acdca4b4406c957803669210005bcb68ff0c6e80ac1dcc3768514611


The sum of the BTC is 3.64436 for the refunds from 19 March to 2 April

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report 11 April:

4 April ID 1.38 BTC was bought in tx 94fac2f181902ddcd6892fc0767faae8a65adaf751952f8e153b63dc27327f4b for 13986.01 BSQ bsq-tx b1b55e385ffab1254db2a2be904de292084030e8a96fcd28ba315cb74a69abaf 4 April ID 0.665 BTC was bought in tx 0692740a26359f2a275f5420cbc546751564976a30a9e18bff15fdce8ef27f68 for 6526.81 BSQ bsq-tx 0acbd7e53b77c7c9928d96d7c6ad796683594c6de0ec87ef9db4a61c3a47ed2f

4 April ID payout tx f182dd4ad734a86725e82aec33e36845ed47ea27beef1a98c8ed635af8c2655e -0.060026 collateral tx d85111121b708b61c4b4acf69b716fdba2d246d09403fc84ae02af569b375f80 bomai on Keybase

6 April ID payout tx c9813a4579dac5baadeadbb50247f3a75d7cc56eebe674fbf57c37a48df1f8ee -0.047971 collateral tx 14b046f12bb6cca49e5d31d24ee90367310009841e6cfe10e4141a5a3996b811

6 April ID payout tx bd30a0448219958bd0197316e086e354de751fcc49935a8daea0936b4d641b1e -0.3250373 collateral tx a0b82d67817372708ab457e40612438ccb848dc1411d382e858878e5f85ca996

9 April ID payout tx 273983ff4c6178220cec6b32c68f956d23d9ab22b427fc3ceb08f4f306aa53ab -0.037026 collateral tx 46630b34ebb1f352378c19b43b4e64494a64363ce274fcedc5b09759ff0d87c5

9 April ID payout tx 2fba1c0cf2e9b1314c5ae56229b0378c2b30a4cc81846dbc07c59f813755d452 -0.022026 collateral tx fc262faf509044a3060af8e6e327b8d1d399a928b0336fc4742e4ab988709c10

9 April ID payout tx a83ee511ad7fd1a7f45dc59025f6d4ec3c0d70eb07ea66d113d83b52b139eed4 -0.016026 collateral tx 5079a7a9570dbc2ea94b193ffa67a579d27250f8cc0b5881d4a9bd1fdfc6c898

9 April ID payout tx a344c418eb66ca34ba99f20c8acdd5efbee4612e79ac3d5900d04ba2ce0d8325 -0.2874223 collateral tx 6c0543010df174dff1f7e1c56087758e1b78da43f799135510864f3c865f0904

9 April ID payout tx 4a2c36b7c59d925325a38a0650d360cba51282d22f7c93d0163e63f3cecc2f30 -0.156206 collateral tx 7f516ea25f9e45b5dd57e4c36dc749afcde5c732782b8e968543a8875582ca76

11 April ID payout tx 9b98a81405ddf3d08497fa61c72bf0964006d37a7dfdaad4180feeba15a375ff -0.016026 collateral tx c84538e8496648c7e99c4d3adc208ad186a4dd055672607c5035a7174d12aec2

11 April ID payout tx e9bc24376a1c2491d4051c3351f3187b5eb209ec4bbda4395a91e1b92d747ab9 -0.23766 collateral tx b5d4c4c8ea5de05ec68de52d4c8567bdfd7126399015cf28c367de83ce11a61d

11 April ID payout tx 03d40ee973886f78ce6c034d7ab428beea47725e6c81cbd82e509e174d7572c7 -0.065026 collateral tx 77d294318bb4313d388ba5692a8e923f942befc220ee2e4e8adeeaa573b67ed6


Including the payouts and BSQ sale between 4 April and 11 April I am out 2.86981 BTC. I have paid 20512.8 BSQ.

11 April ID 0.6 BTC was bought in tx 88c53a76c07e9656467dea00371c27ce7f5c171a5c9796ec785c4338447fff7d for 7334.96 BSQ bsq-tx 2dfc1302f443a6d4d33742dd927dc74ebc00a6114cca76689d594f68706a7c67 11 April ID 0.35 BTC was bought in tx ef7836984c83d0f26507cc3ee66ddbe156b523428ea7087b483bbe5f4d5971ce for 4278.73 BSQ bsq-tx 202be94e90b704d5f594cb065f07f308c940522133aebb60e468d76d8aab9023 11 April ID 1.9 BTC was bought in tx 12ab1938b914d4e17ad90f656a74dfb89e0521736f1a4938f51fdc296af39731 for 23227.38 BSQ bsq-tx 492aea1df2c458a37c80152b1ef23f8487dcf91eecc12e3025eeb1d8d37512ae 11 April ID 1.9 BTC was bought in tx bd0e7daa81859f666430a01539c8ab954103861fa2a9357aa6eddb0e6b90bc9f for 23227.38 BSQ bsq-tx 7f07fde24f511fd32a3a30b9cd68c8fa716c547f16349628165966da1bd93df2


Including the BSQ-sales 11 April I have 1.88019 BTC too much and have used 78581.3 BSQ to buy BTC which the DAO owes me. I have more than 2 BTC in expenses for pending Refund Agent cases which will be paid out shortly.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report 18 April

14 April ID payout tx eb08c45cfe602f1dd6b4bf7e3d13ba97efef09dc5de02aa72383d68a3a8b8608 -0.256852 collateral tx 6e1f7d22f99b91a2bd047cd835d9e638902e256ac46ad0786096df4bf40fe582

16 April ID payout tx 7995d8b0fad1a46341b739ffafd8ad0317b29e17533c9feaf7a646a0238e3aff -2.6000468 collateral tx 052b91bf4f28f1aaac74a7e7ed548a5ba6d003eef7817a0c3f8c82b5df948885

16 April ID payout to buyer -1.14 BTC in tx 00635984761fe2c3faebce3bcd00b952a74676e79af8d4011a1ee04de0404f14 deposit tx 9ff51e9b50818e681ec344252392d21a5fb13e385a72076dfba5a28b5a0ac17a which later goes to the donation address This was reported by leo on Keybase and not sent to me in the app.

16 April ID payout to buyer 2.04 BTC tx ae63f6181f98a433aba94de6052d61da681f2ef660cc2139f96a9dd0a52cab40 payout to seller 0.10 BTC tx 912b4315fa1ad47b3768715784ccb13e33570ed596ebe29b046404a301ee77d4 deposit tx 1ad408ffca2c5a81a12451d2be347d89819b12d246a9f928471ba98e1273c9b0 which later goes to the donation address This was reported by leo on Keybase and not sent to me in the app.


18 April The sum of the BTC is 6.1369 BTC for the refunds from 14 April to 16 April (including these dates). So at this stage I am lacking 4.25671 BTC. I have used 78581.3 BSQ to buy BTC which the DAO owes me.

18 April ID 0.4 BTC was bought in tx e4ff8872436edd12050a4439f6ef61153a17bc3277e27233c8cc82ade3f7b12c for 5128.21 BSQ bsq-tx 2e0bb2e3cef9c019c6a99791e00c333f860cdead5655f27a263139d667cdd0e0 18 April ID 0.9 BTC was bought in tx 43d39a5f830b153c7e3d086a8a2c614e42bd1c4c7c322995f15600e4c76b05ca for 11392.41 BSQ bsq-tx 1dcdcb8bf4e6fdc84d8ced475ff36b002b44ccbab72f121151d08a1603abeca6 18 April ID 2.0 BTC was bought in tx f5cb57a1e4d9b631cf968ff1110333300286a37e544678725b3a0cb9978009ae for 25316.46 BSQ bsq-tx 35bfabe3c61651a6dd260a80fb2e0b156f2ecf30fb3deaa65392bc6de6a3f688


18 April I now lack 0.95671 BTC after trading with Burningman. I have used 120418.38 BSQ to buy BTC which the DAO owes me.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report 25 April:

19 April ID payout tx 64a3db5d80a07233d5afe9863ef2a9a689f2c0df196f6bce857c8aaf2479ac70 -0.032026 collateral tx a574e8e94412ceb823b23f1d727d8597f30a6003d051210f1e75ae5d65de9942

19 April ID payout tx 3ed16dc0ce8326b6f1716e5458b1e5802eaa84c9ed932b0ac2d9182bc1c022b2 -0.022026 collateral tx fe0d9f6b60d907106e09f44b229d43294708c73c7c92910708db2249dd051a5f

24 April ID payout to buyer 0.28758206 BTC address tx c18820ce54ff14cd57e512b56348da2d8e8c19a92b9dde7bfbe450225866b0b5 payout to seller 0.03754972 BTC address tx 4d921dc745ecc91461a11e24e56d307465bc8e429d306cf6a7e14d2bc455bd77 deposit tx 6b2f521db77bc09ae5df11d3bc0110f65d687ef2fd28642511fcb29dffa56d21 which later goes to the donation address. This was reported by leo on Keybase and not sent to me in the app.


I now lack 1.33589 BTC and 120418.38 BSQ (which is being voted upon for reimbursment). I also have a dispute for 2.6 BTC that will be paid out shortly.

25 April ID 0.65 BTC was bought in tx 663560ebb979bd07772aa3e9a98217b8d08576c27b99975da6ad0c5c2d134c3b for 8239.32 BSQ bsq-tx c04635a0ac08f6d7fdb196607a764c35ae099f9653fbfead2bca5304f5804cd7 25 April ID 1.99 BTC was bought in tx 529dd7fa2e80c87347fb635e62900157395dfac98f09fc69d51ef82f878894fa for 25225 BSQ bsq-tx af4ab846ab0369507c3a48df8ca87a093ea302ce9309f70c944b8f7ef8d2b117

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report May 2: 27 April ID payout tx da50d181e8e2fba442c75089a6a1bf9d6c555377dcc846659da9235550c40f09 -2.60003730 collateral tx 44dbc6f6f6420ebf7c01289951aa27646f4e6c8ee54dd3ee9104dffcb16faf9d

1 May ID payout tx 9fa6f42734a9c7dba3e7a3486803b010fca97f83767ef10996d58fded65bd77d -0.01625480 collateral tx 35fea08fd7d1205cc26c701a470d0aaeec1a57fc0a35d351009fba084c40c486


2 May I now lack 1.31218 BTC. I have used 33464.3 BSQ to buy BTC which the DAO owes me. (The previous 120418.38 BSQ got reimbursed.)

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report May 9 2 May ID 0.83 BTC was bought in tx 84dcdbb6cda269b969837388a1c83e563ba9f7afe286fca4f600c350ff20b369 for 11072.57 BSQ bsq-tx 05d2d736de21a0d98fdc83a002398da7a3067574e332cda2844cd9ba74dc1fa1

3 May ID payout tx 96ff0f5f0c2f8d4f0a0a88db7fce0e64adc929cfea7ad17d0a5d83ada5c5327f -0.0782548 BTC collateral tx c0dccb6cd6c82b2252af0cfb2418c81944c576f2e4768e98ff54e1c9284cb391

7 May ID payout tx 78ae774d57bfc302dc234e38cd42b6c9a74f49edec2d9c134619f3daeb6511c6 -0.0378742 BTC collateral tx 48d8491741c795dfca479cb0a040a193a2c6cff960115e93e49eb3e32870c04c

7 May ID payout tx 3a0d4c6276bec23c86d19c438156ade0573a969b64f63be566949a1a430be6bc -0.0521742 BTC collateral tx 77357968fcc5f64445ddb892573d8720f1398a184d19ef934a30467477486568

7 May ID payout tx 4fea8df795dfc0d522885328be06486711fec2c7590eeb9fcaf0e149753a8494 -0.0145482 BTC collateral tx e50bcf36f2f9d89068e06741dcbcd


9 May I now lack 0.665031 BTC. I have used 44536.9 BSQ to buy BTC which the DAO owes me.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

16 May. There was a question what "collateral tx" means. It is the tx which paid out to the donation address. I provide this to show that my expenses were indeed paid to the donation address.

ID 0.665 BTC was bought in tx 87273f4be7ce0e148b53ddb61f99b2a18c88ffafe0222ed9d64b6aca952a800a for 8750 BSQ bsq-tx c24f4125278f45888c619cefef8b7d294870fc744ef60c5360096dd8d9464a8f

12 May ID payout tx 3cb52f508c8ef2977039aa465fb9319e3ea59fdc373e7c8d0764cccc9cfb22d5 -0.0221418 BTC collateral tx d7208bbd3ee326c96fdf41f8db5409e86a9e8858731fe7aed5494841115f7f4b

13 May ID payout tx 844b0e7e03c50a82fa410b76427603eedb0c235d566ecfa8b8600eee17524691 -0.0172652 BTC collateral tx 207ce31b9ac154e229c22a26d2f02397f42398abeda82c0b51a63162219ba91c

16 May ID payout tx 30849d6b73dab5d1adfff8bbc4e864b4e8a464b60467c305a3f4256c5edf1337 -0.021939 BTC collateral tx ec613a2d230e45943f9a8f27dbb564a92736ba48658b53ca14ca64ad2bf83226


16 May. I now lack 0.0613774 BTC. I have used 53286.9 BSQ to buy BTC which the DAO owes me.


RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report May 24

16 May ID 0.0613 BTC was bought in tx 08358e56558dbcaca8271f93808d5ecdec1de1b76a4afbdd72981df0d3524190 for 834.01 BSQ bsq-tx 154083611a6fca7fbdae8b8431130718504e561f5927184157ce1bfdee52795a

18 May ID payout tx 1a359f2404ac63cbdf531254229301210b3dae0d7f7cb6b4918c75dc65c925bd -0.0653822 collateral tx b406e6c20fab7f26c62cae6060fc4b99127e2000374ea506f4491467979b28e3

19 May ID payout tx 16f72b954c026d193c4a7ec30a98665b7d845233a11e14839248fcc44fb735d5 -0.0220754 collateral tx b0660cd1f451b9e074a8f367e6b7f2335fe4328ba3103694615ff588bf99c7e9

19 May ID payout tx f56a1c24679d4815764e7631464679643edb56888beaa6f79af8d6615b4fffd6 -0.0220754 collateral tx be92ef8eed24bbd4691619c490ab61fc7d2a023a279179e7b990e0d0d09417d3

22 May ID payout tx cdf4c7d099372b5c7db6d545233ca6f721854c7d15ad8c7b52bfd6b341a90aa8 -0.0220546 collateral tx 57d688876a22021cfc528b1317c3a4aeb4a876b3f96550b3ceaecbe21d846a4b

22 May ID payout tx e8f997e928d51cd283f3d65df3775d5ba48c75d5673708a0ba5618aa369ee2a7 -0.0220676 collateral tx 47972c0c92d53fc924dc81ee2cb1904e76908cf01adfc4854cfeb141778a4329

22 May ID payout tx 318fe5ff179f705f647745953277f6880c6819e2ecf74002a4d24ec88750c486 -0.0220676 collateral tx f65718ef5f1be69deee5493b67aca4a364abacfb44979dad7305eca9d45f90bb

22 May ID payout tx 75df2c1678112aec5cc0a97224e431601a00138f9029ce570b1f2bbf4b2c98bd -0.022052 collateral tx 6272b3fb82c8604f7e4530029eed82f4c599fd8043bd717ab2f959da5975ce58

22 May ID payout tx 1ea1ce0922b4426f72f28c03564f176f50a145b320b09bc66768529164e09c25 -0.0189416 collateral tx 08a21d1c89a35045f3779bf80d72cb37eb6f1d38d33fed50526ab1ff67ddc2c8

22 May ID payout to buyer 0.022 BTC address 1PTUiijER6aE4XwfgtHcLzfqGMXvjM45vj tx bebc3ee767f69b7ddf5b6a146ca11153fb4c247accca74cf6dccc5ba7d4747ca payout to seller 0.0060315 BTC address 1BiLYbJH8FBXRGEcQoyq5viNSU8TqNdjS4 tx 463dbe831d428c42c040f5403b8a1a7d536ca7c39d1d399794798318e4bcb2df deposit tx 42c2dffe105be612a6879899c65988177ad502ef3a353512b0d776cbfa295bcc which later goes to the donation address. This was reported by leo on Keybase and not sent to me in the app.

24 May ID payout tx 4c7ca00377c162e8771447936823c4f92d10666fb0be83f39ae8494184e5d05e -2.60055738 collateral tx 60015dc4cb0460f944d64a4697e5269005edab0a51f3f4932b88203021ab202b


24 May. I now lack 2.90668 BTC and is out 834.01 BSQ and is waiting for 53286.9 BSQ to be reimbursed.

I have about 2.6 BTC in outstanding cases.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

31 May:

24 May 1.4 BTC was bought in tx 906eb567c24a5f86e5544fa02e0b014029194b1ab05bcea3e4dfb37ca7c57ebe for 18421.05 BSQ bsq-tx 02eb8da20b9dccfc4734ef2295e6cc6659afd8f5526f7752f3092affc04d8e62 24 May 1.99 BTC was bought in tx e5c085639af895852d4a3a4954a017e170f459b25635b9b636ff8a727b3f310c for 26184.21 BSQ bsq-tx fb2ed4ff5c085e7786e68559fd07a886e0108f7c0d70bb46c8d4046a8fe99e74 24 May 1.99 BTC was bought in tx e3cf298431bd291d3003021556e33aabb271478289e68f65f75f91e638d0225e for 26184.21 BSQ bsq-tx 060cb894731dffd15d0bdcf3a8d5b95acb3889b9ce37ee26d3e78694fc17c38c

27 May ID payout tx 51096a0d160b231d39d2fa365c3567e61870c62ea3f6ad6e4857540765781c61 -0.0220286 collateral tx 0d01c9bcff0ac262bef1ee4556fec274ad6c62f9355f3f585443033bfb1f64fc

27 May ID payout tx 7d7b939ca84f1371664ce3e86908ba97e73179ad00e3f19412ac3061043792d8 -0.04718060 collateral tx c65ab73e1a514845d60f211d6404355822a4e75a31aa18b6ab83f6830676ab87

27 May ID payout tx 40bd7db711e05443212759b08e7a115ce05b0a26aec477cb768b3a2818dbb293 -0.042626 collateral tx 9f803b361428a6090cd74f526fca4d41eb602e208fe0262d2dc627516d761693

27 May ID payout tx c38a1dbff07955f90b0474e884fc76068a20df6c15819c4ce5ddac8b78b3cfd7 -2.6001994 collateral tx df497f9e9916b374e775de3a347b58058e5ac2555609b53ddfec807c1349ddd7

31 May ID payout tx cc89e49839a8abf647947588bf1fb278f3636d153b82786916cece140e9765ec -0.0519572 collateral tx 193fc52192d2356cf7ffee1273f6f62d58c02ed0b3a68eeee3e8fc11b74a3f64

31 May ID payout tx 8538f9436272e16f49cd3231b0523d8c216c14cd8c17fec53d479a0c20b63749 -0.031978 collateral tx 256abae951e7ba49e3268f6fa1fcb90778f0878bd977414fadabfd958b75eca0

31 May ID payout tx c2d4532b3e473401ed09dd4142d3c4ffb61d6117f01bbdcb7f19a530f7db8877 -0.022026 collateral tx 54582e3a3c00c20df0ce2d845bf6cc55228ca703714fdbaf675df39cad242401

31 May ID payout tx c15e90808a603b6455fa2730837bcb542b60875392eb6f014dee7789b2c7ca06 -0.8795169 collatoral tx e28313bfde9be3d754035c4be4bf339deb751abd489c502afb6192645b5d2d1d

31 May ID payout to buyer 0.03912260 BTC address 17vvjppdkpi29HZdUayrdPijoUxfXy414x tx 657ebcf48c389f0fcd5b67636b4d47f6458762e51edd796bbdeb11de1d145b66 seller unresponsive deposit tx 4655a162c915760422a61d7992738b7f858d167c9da81673add7540dcfd7b618 which leads to the donation address. This was reported by bayernator on Keybase and not sent to me.


31 May. I now lack 1.26332 BTC and is out 71623.5 BSQ and is waiting for 53286.9 BSQ to be reimbursed.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

June 6

31 May ID 197025 1.2633 BTC was bought in tx a00bdd5783d003004602f560bc03cc026933271c74659e2bc24d11240377d9dc for 17071.62 BSQ bsq-tx 1b437076295f62d6ebd2fcea0ecf927183f83277db7856c08c740c8ee817d012

4 June ID payout tx d67f73542eac4589fd87700fc35e8e2e047de2e3d1fa054fe9c3d6e7571873a0 -0.0219468 collateral tx cfcd6d7b412f2b2b3dd912ef27fafbb40d36cb0945d623ab2c1de784daffb9c7

4 June ID payout tx 011138e39e5b259496662d936f24eb3ae7a4b71ccfb7788dfe904b4745426611 -0.03304680 collateral tx ae1328a50b5655a0935785ec0e8054791d3d7f9eea470b384226890d23a3a142

4 June ID payout tx c84917e754fc49489127446caf248f5c4ac9615a0f9985de3d8aeb5510b5a80e -0.02204680 collateral tx daf51e33528fb979a1dcf40e520038f2de8b065f20999f1d5fbf78136dc04e8b

4 June ID payout tx 2858862b17bc56c8931db023d2bb380632e17938d396e666af4a0ba849b002a6 -0.02204680 collateral tx e2feb11a30fe9119cc7f8bf8b1035932a4a39dd6bbc9ce3c7073262e52c02363

6 June ID payout tx cf40acfed147122ff2be1dfb32e17c560bc0f48f94d155b1991e4d8198f1d68d -0.0812786 collateral tx 900ad79e0a897e9d9b9d8758a55fdabd2c097d00191aa7e985d708984031bbaf


June 6. I now lack 0.180381 BTC and is out 88695.1 BSQ.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

June12

6 June 0.1804 BTC was bought in tx 384b6b1814ac474947a8334941f085ad9a968e15f2397be7c1bf36991345a378 for 2692.54 BSQ bsq-tx 4ed38182cf3e3ee26093bd0b54d36c270e5cdb1c92f73b73f7b70b7975120e90

10 June ID payout tx 294652287429ae098091a3a62c73d14e51f81422dbc4b26892808c712946c307 -0.0220312 collateral tx 2ef1f6e9c603b4cfbd9fd3d211a97e444ebbd82fd051dd85ae9d7d9e396d9230

10 June ID payout tx faeac442911a97e6af6ba3e88f6b2e6dea577236c785f7e201f3dd0229ffd2f7 -0.02202860 collateral tx 9e35a9479bd3226536e86db3dd90b24f1782c1ab0195316683c6759d852df117

10 June ID payout to buyer 0.00302712 BTC address tx 2a8ee5a04a4b84b8eb763fb69f096e2b43e43c58010144bda2451a67b187773f payout to seller 0.01902250 BTC address tx 80e0d2f69d8e31f937bb12aa30b1361cb4b1f8fb9485151eeab034bfa573a8a1 deposit tx cea9550d28c0131851d901da548a9a56adf3047157c9295a663524f07f60cbfb which leads to a donation address. This was reported by leo816 on Keybase and not sent to me.

12 June ID payout tx 16f7568df4e70e04f83971f2e6e04cfe1af455d48df77e1421f45c0a9c3b9fc2 -0.0220468 collateral tx 47aed5935f2204d669a074a5818703bf397bde2ba5cef1c2c8805ac1ae99d034

12 June ID payout tx b308eec21ff878d59ff6c7043a24b6d1add71c4531bb1282cc327063df6cf8c2 -0.0144680 collateral tx 7217638032d8dfcdf699ce1d4ddc4a662f49a4e81664c3f7b9cc2e3684da923b

12 June ID payout tx 5fb81f3304c42b8de138718469a035e8d05fd063f2b346273a36c551062470e4 -0.0825468 collateral tx a4cc9e0905c0b6ad64cf3333e7257da0f0586fc8ae9d97ad5a02db2dbba34e6c


June 12 I now lack 0.185152 BTC and is out 91387.6 BSQ.

clearwater-trust commented 4 years ago

Hello @RefundAgent

Please explain your status going forward. Are you still planning on leaving? Thank you.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

Report June 17 for compensation: 30 payouts including June 12 from May 17 and out 4.534 btc giving 0.04534 btc in interest. The compensations for my case work is then 1500 dollar. Given the rate of 0.63 usd/bsq I should get 2381 BSQ for work and 629 BSQ in interest at a rate of 0.000072 BTC for one BSQ. In total 3000 BSQ (rounded down).

Due to refunds to monero-traders this has been an expensive month. The rate of disputes is about one per day or slightly less. Almost all the cases involve a trader not responding. I hope the security deposit will be increased such that future trading decreases.

clearwater-trust commented 4 years ago

Can we increase security deposits for altcoin trades only? Assuming most of the unresponsive trades are from chain to chain speculation?

@RefundAgent One arbitration a day for one person (30/month) seems reasonable for 1500 dollars as far as compensation goes. Can you speak on the compensation rate for the role? Is it satisfactory? Could you share the work with other people? Is the work level okay?

What makes the role expensive? Are you able to keep a medium of your reimbursements in BTC by trading your BSQ to the burningman or other market makers?

Thanks for sharing your experience. We should try to capture as much info as possible from this role so we can make the protocol better.

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

June 20:

15 June ID 0.1852 BTC was bought in tx bece1b3b291486bd394758f18d1c48d7e3773127b97033e748f12d1b3ebe99d6 for 2944.36 BSQ bsq-tx 566c9f97d435529b9d717acd47672b0fffae1a370d8d0b15f111cc29ad7f787e 20 June ID payout tx 5c8cba4e275dfbce6d3586700d6e00305dcc6ade513fab52d8f159d8d6a0d269 -0.02203380 collateral tx 735508f5811cb7d58b74b6595913eaf5dd284518444c2ed5ae342b309385a81e

20 June ID payout tx 0f9648106480843df7742ffd134354a2e2bd8aa2e06e39d291a5a82fc0642ffa -0.043626 collateral tx 30cc49c3a526cb9ac1b10f7fe0dd723c8b6d2faed7c7047b5a2c0c960b759f9d

20 June ID payout tx d4c915f498ea7072d5ae4cd33e87f52efcd7b79d4cbefa15dcb98754a462caf8 -0.022026 collateral tx a30bdd407fda529956b402046f1e233c3bc0e1cb80d1d0f7d929f2145e1b5607

20 June ID payout tx 25cfb45fb303b31b5e544f531f2bda36331c0244ac59fc8a15ed70935ab8693f -0.022026 collateral tx 70912d20c3c257cb366184d54a015cb65203c1e735c9253b409cca5d47169a3a

20 June ID payout tx f2d67a582b8f0d154b98ced59fa33b7468e203552485460b678c65bb359cc0b7 -0.165026 collateral tx dcfeb1a53972fcd1fcfcc77c6c9199447096c31d9116f5f9bbbb411cd0ee6ba6


I now lack 0.27469 BTC and is out 94332 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

June 28: 21 June ID 0.2747 BTC was bought in tx 2978285a3f78bc2962f4a5482092ba43dd40db5c481b70e3ab0e953b3491a9e9 for 4437.80 BSQ bsq-tx 743ef80e10ceb91439bd3fe665b8c18a10b6b4321a63fd58ef9aaf1c4459a8ec

24 June ID payout tx 7635662c758ed9f0df98144ac1e4d4533970dbcdaab27520ad2fa658cba1ec81 -0.022026 collateral tx 19a3fa98b1cdab0c876df12d2c04dfb62b2f799aff132d479bbc3fbd55ed0405

25 June ID payout tx 9bf06ba1106b80cc1388261245bce67a6d3e7ec7e6d24142f00ca0ccb3eeda32 -1.95003640 collateral tx cd3f94e86e1297277298277aa025cd1c5d6516778af5fbfb6f29546dce5fa749


I now lack 1.97205 BTC ad is out 98769.8 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 4 years ago

June 22 I got reimbursed 91835.60 BSQ in tx 89798bda*****

28 June ID 1.9721 BTC was bought in tx c95a79d32ca4ae62f1c17287990d86c0dc677927104774e235cd713b0067a5b7 for 32066.67 BSQ bsq-tx 973edb4ebe55a91aa0e0e317775d9c000bdc69f08e7e3ebd04129a60e9542f36

2 July ID payout tx 5d283e70bc500b07bae7288f8c22fff32afb9f0f9ebda2e55c59f47575829cac -0.0813514 collateral tx 3c1a61acd3f84064e52695e9da662411cb9b427d550f0bf905e7f52aaaeedc95

2 July ID payout tx 062dd4d96515c9853248ce58a564ed4fe1f7a8cb8f6d5f1916315eb3bdbe9904 -0.0221092 collateral tx 609826a909d0cf81cadd0347303c1dcd1a53ebe2820e0bfe3e8b787159d5379e

5 July ID payout tx 6c4ef8d8cd63119ebcef284dc5a70bbcae07edb8047bcf45d937ed044a93e95a -0.130026 collateral tx 5283ffa1b34fb773047bed395189c27e607d7ae2094a24fa1fd8f7cdf5c21776

5 July ID payout tx bfe04ab923c569a50f989b222bd53901fa2d44e08feb7617a959207469161b23 -0.028206 collateral tx 58659578c8daf78cc4162238ea70d3f09f3d8a68404c3c7cf53d4eb824611f3c

5 July ID payout tx 59c1e9ce681da5b233730a2f0d71695910546a81798c9a51a83749a79f1369d6 -0.024026 collateral tx f26a154b7147fb26a8e5e0a29b6bfe27b6eee36e3029a28218b0624bb0a16e24


I now lack 0.285669 BTC and is out 39450.9 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

5 July ID 0.286 BTC was bought in tx bab1b503a43940caeca406525a0c6e02a5bf1ea3c873c44a6e6fe7d0028eb488 for 4688.52 BSQ bsq-tx 8c63fe962f8d5a1c8f03940b90ae9ba342ec37a6d624d14da81e54e1577e7bb3

6 July ID payout to buyer 0.0667226 BTC address 1Q2o4obSytTFuQdgctYwpSrLpx3DmhcrzJ tx 86e96cb9d7b2b26125960f64c3535bfd82ecd1e7772e1ef1a29da03d57eba438 payout to seller 0.0030225 BTC address 1D2ANqAafxXeah4GcQp6qgXedmWaRqWbyV tx 7044858f6fd66df7e70c7a415c423e7377a4f6c11ff985665a1ce8cb115de183 collateral tx 1509475e26833e889e4d6d46419b0d679fb7078ab7beafc6ce43d4dd617f416a This trade was communicated by wiz on Keybase and not sent to me.

12 July ID payout tx 68482ef5c9f813cafe39aab99bd723ac7785d0659f144185ad813e4eded23e47 -0.025026 collateral tx c77ce6d05bdb2f07165b10c99ef2123c277b31e0f7e819dfcfc41a9ee2112070

12 July ID payout tx a354b85db33a322f9340861503d133e022cd0b9f5883543d97d5efee13f7db62 -0.025026 collateral tx 0b16574cf534f40afba4d3d3b7109c5abfad9fe0b7ceeecfb167c80c97684130

12 July ID payout tx 1d414ff4f5d8b534a150e52d847c155bba3b6f689c7afc11afa5d4b02deee67f -2.1400816 collateral tx 8bdd69ebf157fc9f5f86e897dc80162a637e9f055e619d7a480a8ae0b96c630a


I now lack 2.25955 BTC and is out 44139.4 BSQ

wiz commented 3 years ago

I have some concerns regarding the 2.14 BTC reimbursement claim in your report today:

12 July ID payout tx 1d414ff4f5d8b534a150e52d847c155bba3b6f689c7afc11afa5d4b02deee67f -2.1400816 collateral tx 8bdd69ebf157fc9f5f86e897dc80162a637e9f055e619d7a480a8ae0b96c630a

The payout TXID you provided doesn't appear to be a Bisq payout TX, and the collateral TX you gave seems to have already been reimbursed to you in April:

16 April ID payout to buyer 2.04 BTC tx ae63f6181f98a433aba94de6052d61da681f2ef660cc2139f96a9dd0a52cab40 payout to seller 0.10 BTC tx 912b4315fa1ad47b3768715784ccb13e33570ed596ebe29b046404a301ee77d4 deposit tx 1ad408ffca2c5a81a12451d2be347d89819b12d246a9f928471ba98e1273c9b0 which later goes to the donation address

You can see both the 8bdd and 1ad4 transactions visible on this address: https://mempool.space/address/393KX5iKbPP3n8u6xXVoGBnkKDAcVcxRA3

Can you please explain:

1) Why are you claiming reimbursement for a payout that you already got reimbursed for in April? 2) Why does the payout TXID you provided not appear to be a Bisq transaction? 3) What are the actual payout TXIDs to the buyer and seller for the 2.14 BTC?

It seems something is strange here.

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

I've made a mistake and the traders involved got paid twice. The dispute was communicated to me on Keybase and was paid out April 16. The trade itself is from mid February. At that time it had not arrived as a dispute to my application and the buyer had to use Keybase to get reimbursed. The dispute did finally arrive to my application around July 10, that is several months after it should have come. I did not check whether the dispute was already paid out, since it has never happened before that a message arrives with a delay of about four months and I did pay it out again. The payout TXIDs provided are correct. They are BTC-transactions and not Bisq-transactions.

I have sent messages to the buyer who got most of the BTC (2.04 BTC) but have so far not gotten any response. This has been done both in the application and on Keybase. The relevant mediator has done the same. The seller has since long stopped responding but has nevertheless been messaged.

I will now change my routines to avoid similar mistakes, for instance by carefully checking disputes against my fairly detailed notes. I nevertheless expect there will be more unusual cases where I will make mistakes similar to this one.

The developers should note that messages can apparently be delayed by many months and it would be very helpful if this bug could be corrected.

clearwater-trust commented 3 years ago

The refund agent is a scammer.

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

12 July ID 0.1202 BTC was bought in tx b17a89d26926c7017b72d23b63d376b802b77d458291f5ac435f615d2ae90a5e for 2003.33 BSQ bsq-tx e8393d0ac79589ecdb28785df557f456888f301f037be2678a5cf3a83723ca5b

19 July ID payout tx b11a9418b04de866caa095b01020eae16c2b8c70f67d065d1d4d3017b36b3fcf -0.022026 collateral tx 5f08c7863b035b334c45f12da4674994f0dd7109590a9039d94a44554ddba35a

19 July ID payout tx 11649cd19000cd756e43f4500cabf109a046a7746e86b2357726bc22275e9fb3 -0.022026 collateral tx ca2bf85fde5df35dd89baba75a3c91a9ff22d6c9ecb7bcfaa0152e9dc0d01431

19 July ID payout tx 9f57eaf42a2ed95b52c112e49c9dc856c39e6721d0350230efc3372cc927761d -0.032026 collateral tx afab69d326e5bc716fed6c0972412535b5587b566796bfed19ae9e3cdfaa7574

19 July ID payout tx 8693749ffecc951508eca080157d5e5f87f4f629d0f0d507cbd26b643e73d9e7 -0.022026 collateral tx b6d0a98a44d01c75cbe89c8a84cde096e728b24054cc4a6ffa5be3b6016f6032


I now lack 0.097454 BTC and is out 46142.7 BSQ. I have not included the erroneous payout in this.

ripcurlx commented 3 years ago

The refund agent is a scammer.

I guess you have good proof making such an accusation. There can be human error and I don't feel it helps in our discussion to reduce/eliminate refund agent cases by providing such unfiltered brain output.

leo816 commented 3 years ago

The refund agent is a scammer.

@clearwater-trust The @RefundAgent has been involved with Bisq for some time, he has been extremely helpful. He offered to take this role when no one else stepped up. At the very least, deserves the benefit of the doubt. Unless you have evidence for your claim please avoid making statements like such.

clearwater-trust commented 3 years ago

THE @RefundAgent SHOULD NOT BE ABLE TO DOUBLE CHARGE THE DAO. FIX THIS SYSTEM.

We should NOT have to birddog this role. Just fix it.

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

12 July ID 0.0981 BTC was bought in tx 80a80de15979327a999ef826b0871eb2a7e1729de0811ba9ee37802e1583261e for 1486.36 BSQ bsq-tx 57c3aa839877fecfe2c46fc6a7f76866e6afb12a22c67bcd9806c856ca00266b

25 July ID payout tx b5a322dbabf4c41a2ff6bc558d27bb69d1ce49725d49aa6bf689edfc814c9648 -0.0422002 collateral tx 11a408acec0c058059b61eb60174a5308027e6a3a7c23a2459d4ad1707e5f645

25 July ID payout tx 82f4ed9e110c3fa157c7a8c5142762317b0b88ec02ed6c640c62c3e706ba05bb -0.022108 collateral tx e9c29defbac830380dc9ddcebee4e494d128c3d62161b78d4e82ca25eabbbd15

25 July ID payout tx 2c09867a314eaf90443b8fe9909522466e2152a2d5f10038fb52544a5eeedbcd -0.14222880 collateral tx b3deb36828646d0be800cdd26633b2edb867a2c6b9ceef4f8d423b414d62a595


I now lack 0.205891 BTC and is out 47629.1 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

26 July ID 0.2065 BTC was bought in tx d8300850ca6bce213f09df19c50704d94f6a9633606b8cbc9217d7880021701e for 3226.56 BSQ bsq-tx 282c87a0833861b213576fd18386b571e028b01dc225f3e1f4bb64a157282326

2 Aug ID payout tx 56bf2f7d46f65163fd868652c3bac07c75cedafab3831879ba6c6e02dce4eb13 -0.100496 collateral tx 142123ca5e18a50776dcd029b80b9834dd1875fba3fba68c239e33d15b00a080

2 Aug ID payout tx 55db70f16c31b0990f674cac810407a5cd4179431fcff78b37baa995ec03b621 -0.062546 collateral tx 8d6d31f8338e0f4e80d2098587d0b5fb2c4479ec6c34d6b4c80698cf8a0072bb

2 Aug ID payout tx 7a2a17f52b31000251fb8a0817feb3821982d00209749f757eb3a1d61e4568e2 -0.0715286 collateral tx 76e4531c5881599cff5a523515d8763e9d8163aaac8639d9103fa879e1e1bee1


I now lack 0.233962 BTC and is out 50855.7 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

2 Aug ID 0.2340 BTC was bought in tx bb3e544ffc326cd79dbff9082042698ce045ab60fe464caadfd9c9dca47e9afe for 3600 BSQ bsq-tx 0748e2a0bcc61ab7fb12578fffa64219543c609854537af1bd0eec538b742a6f

I was reimbursed 46142.7 BSQ by the DAO in cycle 15.

9 Aug ID payout tx 97f4597a7128df4ec2504fcb0b63bc94b5350430528143b6703b05211b02c61e -0.078026 collateral tx 9edd31fea0e0c022164ac73a3e3f5209ccfd4c62eb109d94e72030ccac7efd40

9 Aug ID payout tx a7cd6185ce91139c4d3ec983b282e2332c1a032cec676561f14a287260ee0de2 -0.097496 collateral tx 51599fa6ab51ad8b55ffc47e5a89fdb21fb704d06563573f326211039d92f9c7

9 Aug ID payout tx bb0195735040324cfc60079acda4c879ba389ee85f68365c8b4f35a60f18697d -0.0220372 collateral tx f09bf1deb2cf68b5ee6940ca0c239630bd54d482074965fb9d2f1e31d9569ac4

9 Aug ID payout tx d94a83410cd4bda1b07f2ed1edff89a467ce51bb8dd9bd99ce9cf915aa9f6337 -0.026926 collateral tx 1ca8ae8eae5edb6bdbe321d0935b152931d8fbcede8a20ea6caac105b897163d


I now lack 0.224447 BTC and is out 4712.92 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

9 Aug ID 0.2244 BTC was bought in tx 9404814c326520fde7d235c4ce4dac1365e006675144eee66c0d191ef5ee233b for 3619.35 BSQ bsq-tx 59229cdb1cc78bbe4361cad12d711296736790ef174dea8e7b48f36182561967

16 Aug ID payout tx 4d6ff989a714751c30152afbc7ac8874fa4b8d96cd354cdf2decef135fa89321 -0.022026 collateral tx b56c89fc7d2ea23d55e52d542ffbe6fc1c8ae8396a561e9ec123125d292eeb47

16 Aug ID payout tx 53f84ca33f35f063af908f5c8093a3ce623d733d9d215358a090a46259392bd5 -0.069006 collateral tx 84afab8d29387aa91acad4aefeaef84b3559d2c81751ae9b2ed3f3de6a981f9a


I now lack 0.0910789 BTC and is out 8332.27 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

Report 23 Aug.

16 Aug ID 0.0911 BTC was bought in tx 23adb091bb6730fdcf058bd37c3e0c592bd26d72d2695ce16d74595f6150bfd8 for 1518.33 BSQ bsq-tx 5fa18150fd83a1d5545ad91510cfc7f140431614524669edb850d41c60aa6665

23 Aug ID payout tx 853e23e17a9bfc27e946973e5e1af17e21d116a71586f70742754b721e09f8e8 -0.0525538 collateral tx 317cd7e6f242b8569b180318f5b3c9b8e5a9da374d4e5ac5a95e77273945330a

23 Aug ID payout tx 73cb797f419dead5650450637f4cf700b6c941a6e6721d38a507e852294bcb81 -0.026026 collateral tx af20d46de3d742258822bce078a18273140658f424fee731814e843bc01091a3

23 Aug ID payout tx 1b6f78b788f6689c9df70393d69e8ac28c686644ce54a236200a5ac8220fb9c3 -0.022026 collateral tx a1427e16a733dacebf9847b9a67e440fb76b692a804c60ac45e220a816d6de40


I now lack 0.100585 BTC and is out 9850.6 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

Report Aug. 30

16 Aug ID 0.1006 BTC was bought in tx 0d471fa2436c1a6077ebc9e1dd7302d7470c85aa6ccf73cf4c5313f8da00ad63 for 1705.08 BSQ bsq-tx 21bd4b9d4b0acea74c8dc9d2b16e2716b622a64ff3adb3ae975dc5b8b0b145d0

30 Aug ID payout tx 3382c66b0a8ad046b179f2e34fe6a9206adc2d9ccf3e0c4a2f452ad5f10cd3e8 -0.022026 collateral tx 3e5df850c530fe6d3542c1f4174fc673c19af89a25608227e766ffa46c595609


I now lack 0.0220107 BTC and is out 11555.7 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

Report Sept. 7

I was reimbursed 9850.6 BSQ by the DAO in cycle 16.

30 Aug ID 0.0220 BTC was bought in tx ad8493c0d436ee4d191a8c2917b2a117cec129a328aaa6dc2a7653b1e3a560d2 for 379.31 BSQ bsq-tx 7adab32210772180b2cff0ec0b17efd038975c9a2989468562144c5ec92c27c4

6 Sept ID payout tx f2929cdb2908110210cad2e7d384af9b8256d5e78ba9f6aebf44cca724ea9299 -0.0599472 collateral tx 7ae7556109b4f008e313c7ff038939eb24c73cdfc633e3579462dba9d738ac20

6 Sept ID payout tx e713954f6aa5ffd87de812220ed5675ec12608532b48aaa4a9f63e3e12f77466 -0.021126 collateral tx 15b851a117f9168fa6e6f4554563f5022e1094da11a000296005f1bf63733328

6 Sept ID payout tx 036ab7dcb6a848050048949086295009e956a3304894f8e60986634bca01ba7c -0.130026 collateral tx c430b313202e45a3eb0846becd3d8c05ee5bd340f5f4f6c41c0941de526b1473

6 Sept ID payout tx 1d671c34bfbf1f504243230c385ead49525002e5d6d04053f6b9ccf731ec3281 -0.052026 collateral tx bdce1eddd5f0fefbc6b94372fc1e37a78fe61477e8da2ce5755b2364bde88842

7 Sept ID payout tx d23be9bb708f49c8e17b950b2e32dcd7628b4af9bb231482e618ecd2671a90af -0.100026 collateral tx 04f036cbe1cc39fa8c7e5a6c84274d8e7610380a7c8e0c61b465af6f7e26445e


I now lack 0.363162 BTC and is out 2048.41 BSQ

RefundAgent commented 3 years ago

Report 19 Sept. (due to technical issues the report is late)

7 Sept ID 0.3632 BTC was bought in tx 665c01c7c176d5fbc90c21d7dc88cacfcddb3868fa1a077fdd5c4bb56447e7c7 for 6229.85 BSQ bsq-tx 3f5b2889cb497725b099832a1d0de24317171d2ba363f5fb229b63736a8eaddd

9 Sept ID payout tx 95244a015dd273376e4123a7af339406d3f3a9e1691cd3a98b5fb2a18d78888d -0.022026 collateral tx 43016c16f09f4caff386099dfd668cc9affa5529b1ac967e6376527088fd6a57

9 Sept ID payout tx 9f915e1a615c8f9dc603c1844e399549f953ba175efc81a9fbc44a823e69f124 -0.040026 collateral tx 032f39a58ed434c334c7db37c5b61470dd15bf090a2912980a8422463ce6af66

9 Sept ID payout tx c49cc7c2562f113f17224e68b109484321e162e862b0ea7d0f1f85640db16b33 -0.035526 collateral tx 382dae8cc2c9ca647e43431d6a2d81c388a5057f5680ac2ef4c64c50acb02004

9 Sept ID payout tx 1a00aefeac9988ae149c4777b438918b70cd90e727e8db7dcd6e870059bef4d9 -0.063076 collateral tx 7bfddc258d028f600ccf2914713fd557d0843d4be785cba45d92e704cdc8c887

17 Sept ID payout tx 7706139cd794fd9ae5f04e5a5a1b38f731fbf3b934a7da8baac092464a2a258a -0.260026 collateral tx 585c7b1e972dcf441a4d506db5d9988ab95abd83c58127c5e3cd616d9dab8964

17 Sept ID payout tx 0de51f3bbe0afac67f490b42c785756ad21c63e0edfe00dba4816ffff2a7deb8 -0.027026 collateral tx 1af1cc22b5a76a7002019665e34a3d0892681d8c1c882342a4fb9203f9ae4ad1

17 Sept ID payout tx 61e30696637a9830eddd37e29fd9ace9b892845e584757874943dc10e3384198 -0.137526 collateral tx 170aa5be2e50178892b6a4832878b4d6f34041b2bfdb78c2759b4d7e984a9597

17 Sept ID payout tx c5598dcccd576212b3fba1e7b20e33061e6e0607c68f25f12e8628705b602d92 -0.022026 collateral tx d087f20c3dd40c744597d869a2ead6340f20dad5754e137965b95225d0aa458d

17 Sept ID payout tx 857b8f7cb6a9b4d48c7056c332df6476a1e49b982a7b27d15f5ada99abcc4457 -0.021926 collateral tx af4eceeadf51a84ff1ea615a90b68831efe8ad7d93ef3bdc70c1653359f3591c

17 Sept ID payout tx 7707b3579241e23904c9fe7cb55e02f319923e8b9ed6d8825df07256c5eecc9b -0.0510468 collateral tx 1ac8d6791e7cd389b319943ec8ef23a58f62156132d5251daf277ae4a9b16399

17 Sept ID payout tx 9acdf51398cd9c2b9a7371cb546230e50f61b699f124e45bf16178b602ad322c -0.022026 collateral tx 4b5521f5bb4f1d32cd9ca7cd3700fb8f7084638b06c3dd31ae0b32bef16a9427

17 Sept ID payout tx 278409cccc1ed312ea2d840cf6ef4f3b977055a2ba8be8c0406998dfc17bf33e -0.022026 collateral tx 4a0d26ffc3a205071387b42e17d2ef41f58895a0333ca2ccf7be5475574519e6

17 Sept ID payout tx 249453d8e544fd9a14a7ecd2817fb4c48680bd4f49ae555944dbfb802c522fd6 -0.022026 collateral tx b98b4ca6b92a379ef42e2567224729900918e16320090aeb8dfa3b80560cecc6


I now lack 0.746271 BTC and is out 8314.25 BSQ