black7375 / Firefox-UI-Fix

🦊 I respect proton UI and aim to improve it.
Mozilla Public License 2.0
5.26k stars 184 forks source link

Inconsistent Pocket icons in toolbar & about:preferences #723

Closed Aleksandra0056 closed 1 year ago

Aleksandra0056 commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug

One empty Pocket icon is in toolbar, and one filled Pocket icon is in about:preferences in Home section.

Also, I want to say, that if you fix this, then you should also re-open this https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix/issues/693 because the filled “Shortcuts” icon above would be inconsistent to new empty Pocket icon.

Oh, and if you think, that it is an intentional decision, then should I rather file a bug in BugZilla? Because I remember, that you said, that the filled icon means, that the feature contains something, and the empty icon means, that the feature contains nothing (E.g. filled bookmarks icon means, that I already bookmarked it).

And I think, that Pocket recommended content is unsupported in South Korea (just correct me if I'm wrong), so the filled Pocket icon maybe wouldn't appear in your Firefox.

Expected behavior

The empty Pocket icon should also be in about:preferences.

Screenshots

Correct one in toolbar:

Empty Pocket icon

Incorrect one in Firefox settings:

Filled Pocket icon

OS

Others

OS - Others

Windows 11 22621.1848 (64-bit)

Firefox Version

v114.0.1 (64-bit)

Distribution

Theme

Theme - More Info

No response

user.js setup

user.js setup
```javascript // ** Theme Default Options **************************************************** // userchrome.css usercontent.css activate user_pref("toolkit.legacyUserProfileCustomizations.stylesheets", true); // Proton Enabled #127 || Removed at 97 #328 (Maintained for compatibility with ESR) user_pref("browser.proton.enabled", true); // Fill SVG Color user_pref("svg.context-properties.content.enabled", true); // CSS Color Mix - 88 Above user_pref("layout.css.color-mix.enabled", true); // CSS Blur Filter - 88 Above user_pref("layout.css.backdrop-filter.enabled", true); // Restore Compact Mode - 89 Above user_pref("browser.compactmode.show", true); // about:home Search Bar - 89 Above user_pref("browser.newtabpage.activity-stream.improvesearch.handoffToAwesomebar", false); // CSS's `:has()` selector #457 - 103 Above user_pref("layout.css.has-selector.enabled", true); // Browser Theme Based Scheme - Will be activate 95 Above // user_pref("layout.css.prefers-color-scheme.content-override", 3); // ** Theme Related Options **************************************************** // == Theme Distribution Settings ============================================== // The rows that are located continuously must be changed `true`/`false` explicitly because there is a collision. // https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix/wiki/Options#important user_pref("userChrome.tab.connect_to_window", true); // Original, Photon user_pref("userChrome.tab.color_like_toolbar", true); // Original, Photon user_pref("userChrome.tab.lepton_like_padding", true); // Original user_pref("userChrome.tab.photon_like_padding", false); // Photon user_pref("userChrome.tab.dynamic_separator", true); // Original, Proton user_pref("userChrome.tab.static_separator", false); // Photon user_pref("userChrome.tab.static_separator.selected_accent", false); // Just option user_pref("userChrome.tab.bar_separator", false); // Just option user_pref("userChrome.tab.newtab_button_like_tab", true); // Original user_pref("userChrome.tab.newtab_button_smaller", false); // Photon user_pref("userChrome.tab.newtab_button_proton", false); // Proton user_pref("userChrome.icon.panel_full", true); // Original, Proton user_pref("userChrome.icon.panel_photon", false); // Photon // Original Only user_pref("userChrome.tab.box_shadow", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner", true); // Photon Only user_pref("userChrome.tab.photon_like_contextline", false); user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_tab", false); // == Theme Compatibility Settings ============================================= // user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.accent_color", true); // Firefox v103 Below // user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.covered_header_image", true); // user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.panel_cutoff", true); // user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.navbar_top_border", true); // user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.dynamic_separator", true); // Need dynamic_separator // user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.os.linux_non_native_titlebar_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.os.windows_maximized", true); // == Theme Custom Settings ==================================================== // -- User Chrome -------------------------------------------------------------- // user_pref("userChrome.theme.proton_color.dark_blue_accent", true); // user_pref("userChrome.theme.monospace", true); // user_pref("userChrome.decoration.disable_panel_animate", true); // user_pref("userChrome.decoration.disable_sidebar_animate", true); // user_pref("userChrome.decoration.panel_button_separator", true); // user_pref("userChrome.decoration.panel_arrow", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.tab", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.tab.opacity", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.tab.blur", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.tabbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.navbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.bookmarkbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.sidebar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.fill_urlbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.back_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.forward_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.page_action", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.toolbar_overlap", true); // user_pref("userChrome.autohide.toolbar_overlap.allow_layout_shift", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.tab_icon", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.tab_icon.always", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.tabbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.navbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.titlebar_container", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.sidebar_header", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.sidebar_header.vertical_tab_only", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.urlbar_iconbox", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.urlbar_iconbox.label_only", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.bookmarkbar_icon", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.bookmarkbar_label", true); // user_pref("userChrome.hidden.disabled_menu", true); // user_pref("userChrome.centered.tab", true); // user_pref("userChrome.centered.tab.label", true); // user_pref("userChrome.centered.urlbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.centered.bookmarkbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.counter.tab", true); // user_pref("userChrome.counter.bookmark_menu", true); // user_pref("userChrome.combined.nav_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.combined.nav_button.home_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.combined.urlbar.nav_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.combined.urlbar.home_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.combined.urlbar.reload_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.combined.sub_button.none_background", true); // user_pref("userChrome.combined.sub_button.as_normal", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_button", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_dialog", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_panel", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_panelitem", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_menupopup", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_menuitem", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_field", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_urlView_item", true); // user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_checklabel", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.first_tab", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.first_tab.always", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.drag_space", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.drag_space.maximized", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.toolbar_button.compact", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.menu_compact", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.bookmark_menu.compact", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.urlView_expanding", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.urlView_result", true); // user_pref("userChrome.padding.panel_header", true); // user_pref("userChrome.urlbar.iconbox_with_separator", true); // user_pref("userChrome.urlView.as_commandbar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.urlView.full_width_padding", true); // user_pref("userChrome.urlView.always_show_page_actions", true); // user_pref("userChrome.urlView.move_icon_to_left", true); // user_pref("userChrome.urlView.go_button_when_typing", true); // user_pref("userChrome.urlView.focus_item_border", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.as_titlebar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.fill_width", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.multi_row", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.unscroll", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.on_bottom", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.on_bottom.above_bookmark", true); // Need on_bottom // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.on_bottom.menubar_on_top", true); // Need on_bottom // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.on_bottom.hidden_single_tab", true); // Need on_bottom // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.one_liner", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.one_liner.combine_navbar", true); // Need one_liner // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.one_liner.tabbar_first", true); // Need one_liner // user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.one_liner.responsive", true); // Need one_liner // user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.all", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.australis", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.edge", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.chrome", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.chrome_legacy", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.wave", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.always_show_tab_icon", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_pinned", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_pinned.always", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_pinned.background", true); // user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_hover.always", true); // Need close_button_at_hover // user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_hover.with_selected", true); // Need close_button_at_hover // user_pref("userChrome.tab.sound_show_label", true); // Need remove sound_hide_label // user_pref("userChrome.navbar.as_sidebar", true); // user_pref("userChrome.bookmarkbar.multi_row", true); // user_pref("userChrome.findbar.floating_on_top", true); // user_pref("userChrome.panel.remove_strip", true); // user_pref("userChrome.panel.full_width_separator", true); // user_pref("userChrome.panel.full_width_padding", true); // user_pref("userChrome.sidebar.overlap", true); // user_pref("userChrome.icon.disabled", true); // user_pref("userChrome.icon.account_image_to_right", true); // user_pref("userChrome.icon.account_label_to_right", true); // user_pref("userChrome.icon.menu.full", true); // user_pref("userChrome.icon.global_menu.mac", true); // -- User Content ------------------------------------------------------------- // user_pref("userContent.player.ui.twoline", true); // user_pref("userContent.newTab.hidden_logo", true); // user_pref("userContent.page.proton_color.dark_blue_accent", true); // user_pref("userContent.page.proton_color.system_accent", true); // user_pref("userContent.page.monospace", true); // == Theme Default Settings =================================================== // -- User Chrome -------------------------------------------------------------- user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.theme", true); user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.os", true); user_pref("userChrome.theme.built_in_contrast", true); user_pref("userChrome.theme.system_default", true); user_pref("userChrome.theme.proton_color", true); user_pref("userChrome.theme.proton_chrome", true); // Need proton_color user_pref("userChrome.theme.fully_color", true); // Need proton_color user_pref("userChrome.theme.fully_dark", true); // Need proton_color user_pref("userChrome.decoration.cursor", true); user_pref("userChrome.decoration.field_border", true); user_pref("userChrome.decoration.download_panel", true); user_pref("userChrome.decoration.animate", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.tabbar_width", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.tabbar_height", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.toolbar_button", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.navbar_width", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.urlbar", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.bookmarkbar", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.infobar", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.menu", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.bookmark_menu", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.global_menubar", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.panel", true); user_pref("userChrome.padding.popup_panel", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.multi_selected", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.unloaded", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.letters_cleary", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_hover", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.sound_hide_label", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.sound_with_favicons", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.pip", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.container", true); user_pref("userChrome.tab.crashed", true); user_pref("userChrome.fullscreen.overlap", true); user_pref("userChrome.fullscreen.show_bookmarkbar", true); user_pref("userChrome.icon.library", true); user_pref("userChrome.icon.panel", true); user_pref("userChrome.icon.menu", true); user_pref("userChrome.icon.context_menu", true); user_pref("userChrome.icon.global_menu", true); user_pref("userChrome.icon.global_menubar", true); // -- User Content ------------------------------------------------------------- user_pref("userContent.player.ui", true); user_pref("userContent.player.icon", true); user_pref("userContent.player.noaudio", true); user_pref("userContent.player.size", true); user_pref("userContent.player.click_to_play", true); user_pref("userContent.player.animate", true); user_pref("userContent.newTab.full_icon", true); user_pref("userContent.newTab.animate", true); user_pref("userContent.newTab.pocket_to_last", true); user_pref("userContent.newTab.searchbar", true); user_pref("userContent.page.field_border", true); user_pref("userContent.page.illustration", true); user_pref("userContent.page.proton_color", true); user_pref("userContent.page.dark_mode", true); // Need proton_color user_pref("userContent.page.proton", true); // Need proton_color // ** Useful Options *********************************************************** // Integrated calculator at urlbar user_pref("browser.urlbar.suggest.calculator", true); // Integrated unit convertor at urlbar // user_pref("browser.urlbar.unitConversion.enabled", true); // Draw in Titlebar // user_pref("browser.tabs.drawInTitlebar", true); // user_pref("browser.tabs.inTitlebar", 1); // Nightly, 96 Above // ** Scrolling Settings ******************************************************* // == Only Sharpen Scrolling =================================================== // Pref Value Original /* user_pref("mousewheel.min_line_scroll_amount", 10); // 5 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.mouseWheel.durationMinMS", 80); // 50 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.currentVelocityWeighting", "0.15"); // "0.25" user_pref("general.smoothScroll.stopDecelerationWeighting", "0.6"); // "0.4" */ // == Smooth Scrolling ========================================================== // ** Scrolling Options ******************************************************** // based on natural smooth scrolling v2 by aveyo // this preset will reset couple extra variables for consistency // Pref Value Original /* user_pref("apz.allow_zooming", true); /// true user_pref("apz.force_disable_desktop_zooming_scrollbars", false); /// false user_pref("apz.paint_skipping.enabled", true); /// true user_pref("apz.windows.use_direct_manipulation", true); /// true user_pref("dom.event.wheel-deltaMode-lines.always-disabled", true); /// false user_pref("general.smoothScroll.currentVelocityWeighting", "0.12"); /// "0.25" <- 1. If scroll too slow, set to "0.15" user_pref("general.smoothScroll.durationToIntervalRatio", 1000); /// 200 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.lines.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.lines.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.mouseWheel.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 200 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.mouseWheel.durationMinMS", 0); /// 50 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.mouseWheel.migrationPercent", 100); /// 100 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.continuousMotionMaxDeltaMS", 12); /// 120 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.enabled", true); /// false user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.motionBeginSpringConstant", 200); /// 1250 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.regularSpringConstant", 200); /// 1000 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.slowdownMinDeltaMS", 10); /// 12 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.slowdownMinDeltaRatio", "1.20"); /// "1.3" user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.slowdownSpringConstant", 1000); /// 2000 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.other.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.other.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.pages.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.pages.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.pixels.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.pixels.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.scrollbars.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.scrollbars.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150 user_pref("general.smoothScroll.stopDecelerationWeighting", "0.6"); /// "0.4" user_pref("layers.async-pan-zoom.enabled", true); /// true user_pref("layout.css.scroll-behavior.spring-constant", "250.0"); /// "250.0" user_pref("mousewheel.acceleration.factor", 3); /// 10 user_pref("mousewheel.acceleration.start", -1); /// -1 user_pref("mousewheel.default.delta_multiplier_x", 100); /// 100 user_pref("mousewheel.default.delta_multiplier_y", 100); /// 100 user_pref("mousewheel.default.delta_multiplier_z", 100); /// 100 user_pref("mousewheel.min_line_scroll_amount", 0); /// 5 user_pref("mousewheel.system_scroll_override.enabled", true); /// true <- 2. If scroll too fast, set to false user_pref("mousewheel.system_scroll_override_on_root_content.enabled", false); /// true user_pref("mousewheel.transaction.timeout", 1500); /// 1500 user_pref("toolkit.scrollbox.horizontalScrollDistance", 4); /// 5 user_pref("toolkit.scrollbox.verticalScrollDistance", 3); /// 3 */ ```

Additional context

Aleksandra0056 commented 1 year ago

Also, I don't know why you closed https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix/issues/693 as won't fix, because the icon from second screenshot from that issue is from Firefox's PDF reader and not from other application.

EDIT 1: And I want also say, that thin/empty icons are following the Proton standards, while the thick/filled icons are NOT following the Proton standards, which is also why I reported https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix/issues/693 earlier.

EDIT 2: And I also checked, that only difference of “Shortcuts” icon from Photon is only rounded corners, so Mozilla barely changed it.

EDIT 3: But I already reported the “Shortcuts” icon to BugZilla (https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1829141).

EDIT 4: But if you love these thick icons so much, then I have one proposal: Close this & keep the #693 closed, and I'll move them to discussions, and you'll keep that discussion open until someone makes a contribution. Does sound good this compromise?

black7375 commented 1 year ago

That's a page-thumbnails and top-sites. (Other icon)

https://acorn.firefox.com/latest/styles/iconography.html image image

Aleksandra0056 commented 1 year ago

So, should I rather move it to discussions as I said earlier?

Aleksandra0056 commented 1 year ago

Fine, I decided to move this issue and also #693 to discussions, anyways thank you for response!