search

dekuNukem / bob_cassette_rewinder

Renew and Refill Bob Cassettes for 98% Cost Saving!
MIT License
1.44k stars 44 forks source link
bob-cassettes bob-rewinder daan-tech dishwasher-detergents

readme

Bob Cassette Rewinder: Hacking Detergent DRM for 98% Cost Saving

Get Bob Rewinder | Official Discord | User Manual

How I defeated Bob Dishwasher's detergent cartridge DRM to refill it at 1/60 of the cost of buying new.

Alt text

Get one / Discord

To get your own Bob Rewinder, click me!

Feel free to join our discord for questions, discussions, and announcements.

Introduction

Back in Jan 2021, I watched Techmoan review the Bob Dishwasher by Daan Tech. In short, Bob is a sleek and compact countertop dishwasher with a built-in water tank that can be filled by hand, requiring no plumbing and minimal space.

Alt text

He seemed to be quite impressed, mentioning its ease of setup and use. I liked the idea myself too, and ordered one soon afterwards.

It arrived after a 2-months wait, and overall I'm very happy with it. It fits on my kitchen top, has enough space for my dishes, uses a tiny amount of water, and overall works just fine. No problems.

It is also internet-connected (of course), but I never let it online. Why in the world does a dishwasher need internet anyway?

Bob Cassettes

One of the headline features of Bob dishwasher is the Bob Cassette, an all-in-one detergent cartridge. Just pop it in and off you go! No need to manually measure and add detergent each wash, very convenient!

Alt text

There are two types of Bob Cassettes:

Alt text

Pop Cassette

Rock’n’roll Cassette

Advantages

Daan Tech quoted several benefits of Bob Cassettes:

Outrageous Cost

While those points are perfectly valid and I did enjoy using the cassettes, such convenience comes with a cost, and Daan Tech is more than happy to take it off your hands. Looking at their website, a 4-pack costs £35:

Alt text

With shipping and VAT added, it costs a whopping £43 ($60) for 90 washes! That is 48p (67c) per wash. It might not sound like much, but it quickly adds up.

Over a year of daily washes, it would have cost £174 ($242) in Bob cassettes alone! Imagine paying that much recurring cost for a dishwasher!

And remember its internet connectivity? Yep, the whole reason is that it can reorder more cassettes automatically when it runs low, just like those HP inkjet printers.

It is clear that Daan Tech are banking on the convenience of subscription models. I'm sure a lot of people have no problem with that, but personally, I can think of a few better uses of my £174 than on dishwasher detergents.

Another point to consider is what happens if they went bust? No more cassettes, and now you have a fancy paperweight, like so many unnecessarily-smart appliances before it.

Alternatives

Credit where credit's due, Daan Tech didn't completely lock down the machine with Bob cassettes. Once empty, you can leave it there and add detergents manually. However, they strongly suggest against this, quoting a few drawbacks:

It is clear that this dishwasher was designed with Bob cassettes in mind, and I do enjoy their set-and-forget simplicity. That's why I made it a priority to investigate how it works.

A Closer Look

Looking at the cassette, we can see it has a small circuit board in the middle, with 4 contacts on each side:

Alt text

At the receptacle, we can see the connector for the PCB, as well as two hoses to pump out the detergent during a wash:

Alt text

Notice there are only 4 wires going into the machine. Coupled with the fact that Bob needs to read the cassette to determine how many washes are left, and write to update it after a wash, I had a pretty good guess of what that mystery PCB contains.

The answer is an I2C EEPROM, a popular type of non-volatile memory. EEPROMs retain whatever's inside even after losing power, and are very cheap, making them perfect at holding small configuration data in embedded systems.

To settle it once and for all, I extracted the PCB from the casing by melting the plastic with a soldering iron. A bit messy, and I probably should have used a dremel, but I didn't have one.

Alt text

A closer look at the PCB confirmed my suspicion:

Alt text

It's simply a 24C02 EEPROM with 4.7K pull-ups on I2C lines, a bypass cap, and some diodes, probably for reverse-insertion protection.

Looking at the datasheet, 24C02 can only hold 256 bytes of data, so I guess there probably isn't much going on, but we'll need to dump its contents to be sure.

Bob the Dumper

So my plan now is to read what's inside the EEPROM. It seemed that a special connector is needed, but after rummaging around the parts bin, I found that it fits into a USB-A female socket just fine! Although I had to insulate the metal case so it won't short on the PCB contacts.

I found a leftover board from pimping my microwave, and quickly threw together a contraption to read the EEPROM:

Alt text

It would just read all 256 bytes and print them over serial, and I wrote a short Python script to save them as a .bin file.

Here is a quick look at whats inside a Pop cassette, with 26 washes left:

Alt text

We can see that:

There are few other bytes here and there, I didn't know what they do, but it doesn't really matter for now. I wanted to see what changes after another wash.

So I put the cassette back, had another wash, dumped it again, and compared the difference:

Alt text

Voilà, there it is! Only one byte is different at address 0xa1, and it went down from 0x4A to 0x49 while going from 26 to 25 washes.

Doing some interpolation, it seems that byte starts from 0x4e at 30 washes, and goes down from there.

I changed it to 0x3f, which should be 15 washes, and put it back. This happened:

Alt text

111 washes! Looks like they didn't do much bound checking 😅.

A bit perplexed, I tried several other values. In the end, it seems that the mapping is like this:

Washes Left Value @ 0xa1
30 0x4e
...
16 0x40
15 0x5f
...
0 0x50

Eagle-eyed user flopp pointed out the value at 0xa1 is calculated as Washes left XOR 0x50, thanks! Not sure why they did it like this, but anyway!

To reset the cassette to 30 washes, all I have to do is set that byte back to 0x4e, easy enough!

With the simple EEPROM chip, standard 0.1 inch contact spacing, one-byte counter, and no error checking, it sure seems Daan Tech didn't really try very hard!

Now what?

It's great now that I can reset the Bob Cassette counter, but what should I refill it with? After all, this whole endeavor would be pointless if they really do have some secret sauce in there that can't be found anywhere else.

Of course, Daan Tech themselves sure wish you don't play around with the cassettes:

Alt text

Alt text

So what exactly is in those cassettes? Fortunately, they did provide some details in the user manual:

Alt text

It's easy to see they kept things a bit vague to discourage loonies like me, but we can still extract some useful information out of it:

As the names suggest, detergent helps to break down grease and clean the dishes, while rinse aid reduces water streaking and improve drying performance. Technology Connections did a video about this topic, so give it a watch!

I also wanted to find out how much detergent Bob actually uses at each stage of wash, so I did a express wash on Bob, and weighed the waste water at each stage. Its water usage is as follows:

Overall, less than 3L of water for an entire load! Very efficient!

I can now calculate the detergent concentration:

Similarly for rinse aid:

A Clean Getaway

With those information, I can begin searching for similar dishwasher liquids on the Internet.

I first tried "Concentrated Dishwasher Detergent", which returned a lot of supermarket dishwasher gel, not quite what I want. But it quickly led to something much more promising.

The magic word appears to be: Commercial Dishwasher Detergent & Rinse Aid from Catering supplies websites.

A quick search showed quite a few very reasonably priced 5L detergents & rinse aids:

Alt text

Of course, the question now becomes which one do I pick? Fortunately, all chemical products in UK comes with a Safety Data Sheet by regulation, which contains the composition and concentration of what's inside. This way, I can compare an unknown detergent with Bob Cassette and get a rough idea of how close it is.

Looking at the cheapest detergent (top-left), its instruction states:

Alt text

The dilution ratio from my earlier calculation was 1:231, right in the ballpark. Looking the data sheet:

Alt text

Similar composition and concentration too! Both less than 5%.

Moving on to the cheapest rinse aid:

Alt text

Again, spot on. So there you go! Perfectly good substitutes for the detergents inside Bob cassettes.

Of course, I do realize that the chemical composition might not be 100% same, at least according to the label. But those bulk detergents are for use in professional commercial kitchens, so they are unlikely to be weak stuff. And just wait until we get to the cost analysis!

UPDATE 2021-05-29:

Another eagle-eyed user ziviossi seems to have found the exact detergents used in the Pop and R'n'R cassette, with the same UFI number.

Pop detergent, UFI: 9AD7-407V-T002-0TTS

R'n'R Cleaning Agent, UFI: P7D7-M0JG-G00K-AG7Q

Click the links for more info and datasheets. Backup copy here.

UPDATE 2022-03-19:

More information about the exact detergents are being investigated by Hawk-v3. Read about the details here:

https://github.com/dekuNukem/bob_cassette_rewinder/issues/13

Cost Showdown

Now comes the good part, let's work out how much I save by using commercial detergents.

Detergent

Rinse aid

With that, the total cost per wash is:

0.62p + 0.18p = 0.80p, or 1.1 US cents!

We know from earlier that Bob Cassettes costs 48p (67c) per wash.

Therefore, refilling it yourself is more than 60 times cheaper, resulting in a massive 98% cost saving compared to buying new!

What's more, the 5L detergent can last well over 3 years of daily wash, while the rinse aid can last almost 12 years! Over those time you would have spent £2088 on Bob cassettes, and who knows if they will even be around then.

Of course, this calculation really is the best-case scenario, it didn't account for shipping of the detergents, and they might go bad before all gets used up. But even considering those possibilities, 2p per wash should be easily achievable, which is still almost 30 times cheaper. It's a no brainer to refill your Bob Cassette if you can.

Testing it Out

I went out and bought 2 jugs of detergent and rinse aid:

Alt text

I picked them up locally, so I didn't have to pay shipping. The total came to around £17.

Refilling the cassette is easy, I taped over the PCB window to prevent liquid getting in, and injected the detergents into the cassette with a syringe with blunt needle, poking through the one-way membrane. WARNING: See this guide for more details if you plan to do it yourself.

Alt text

I then popped the cassette back, as expected, Bob reads it having full 30 washes left:

Alt text

I did a wash, and the resulting dishes are just as clean as before, nothing seemed different, except I'm now paying 60 times less for the privilege! Job done!

Bob Rewinder Board

Everything's coming together nicely! But as I will refill the cartridge frequently in the future, I do want to make a proper gadget to renew a cassette at the push of a button, instead of using the flying wire contraption earlier.

So I quickly designed a circuit board, christened Bob Rewinder, and hand-soldered a prototype:

Alt text

Bob Rewinder simply plugs into the cassette:

Alt text

Pressing the RENEW button will reset the EEPROM, and I can then refill and re-use the cassette for next to nothing!

Thoughts and Conclusions

In this project, I wanted to explore the possibility of refilling and reusing Bob cassettes so I can preserve its set-and-forget convenience at a fraction of the cost.

In the process, I...

Looking back, nothing was particularly difficult, but it did involve a lot of topics, and I learned a lot about dishwasher cycles and detergents in the process, probably more than I would have liked :)

What I find ironic is, Daan Tech isn't shy about their "positive cycle" of environmentally friendly practices, while having no problem selling you single-use cassettes at 60x of the price that lasts only 30 washes. The only justification is that you are supposed to mail them all the way back to France so they can be refilled (and of course, sold again).

If they truly wanted to cut down on single-use plastics, what's wrong with user-refillable detergent compartments like every other full-size and commercial dishwashers? That sure seem a lot less hassle than mailing plastic cartridges back-and-forth around the world.

Despite the DRM and warnings about not to refill the cassettes yourself, they even admitted themselves that the cassettes can be reused hundreds of times:

Alt text

They also mentioned how conventional detergent plastic bottles is bad for the environment, while the cassettes themselves only last 30 washes and uses way more plastic and electronics.

The more I think of it, the more I can draw parallel between Bob cassettes and DRM-enabled inkjet cartridges, often costing more than the printer itself. It wouldn't be surprising if Daan Tech took some inspirations from there.

In the end, I'm glad I tamed another totally unnecessary subscription-based internet-connected "smart" device, and managed to reuse and refill the cartridge for 1/60 the cost of buying new.

By doing so, the biggest change is I no longer have to worry about using Bob at all. There used to be a constant niggle in the back of my head about getting the most out of each wash, because once it runs out, I'm in for a long wait and expensive bill. Now that the cost is so low, I find myself using it much more liberally whenever I want, often multiple times a day.

Despite my lengthy rants, I actually really like the dishwasher itself. It is quiet, water-efficient, fast, compact, looks great, requires no plumbing, and perfect for small homes. Funny how once DRM-based nickel-and-diming is out of the equation, Bob is actually excellent at its job.

I want one too!

I have made a few extra Bob Rewinder boards, you can get it here.

For instructions on how to use it, click me!

Other Stuff

I've done a few other fun projects over the years, feel free to check them out:

duckyPad: Do-It-All Mechanical Macropad: A 15-key mechanical macropad with hot-swap, RGB, and sophisticated multi-line scripting.

Pimp My Microwave: Fixing my microwave by grafting an RGB mechanical keyboard to it!

Daytripper: Hide-my-windows Laser Tripwire: Saves the day while you slack off!

exixe: Miniture Nixie Tube driver module: Eliminate the need for vintage chips and multiplexing circuits.

From Aduino to STM32: A detailed tutorial to get you started with STM32 development.

List of all my repos

Questions or Comments?

Please feel free to open an issue, ask in my discord server, DM me on discord dekuNukem#6998, or email dekuNukem@gmail.com for inquires.