CMLFS - Clang Musl Linux From Scratch

CMLFS can either mean "Clang-built Musl Linux from Scratch" or "Clang MLFS". It started as a hobby to see if a Linux system can be built with clang as primary toolchain and GCC as secondary (for packages that cannot be built with clang). This is based on Linux From Scratch and my previous work MLFS. Big thanks to Chimera-Linux that had patches that fixed a lot of issues.

DISCLAIMER

Use at you own risk. This builds a Unix-like system that may not be stable enough as a 'daily driver' for most users. Security-hardening of the built system is beyound the scope of this project. This repo started as means to backup and archive my work.

Getting Started

The master branch may be unstable when I am working on upgrading CMLFS.

To build this project, pick a branch other than master OR choose a tag. Each branch & tag are based on the LLVM version. As of this writing, llvm-15.0.6 is stable. Older branches maybe incomplete or unstable (may not compile).

When I have time later, I will write a more thorough introduction for users new to CMLFS.

Specification

• C Runtime Library (system libc): Musl
• Default C Compiler: clang (LLVM)
• Default C++ compiler: clang++ (LLVM)
• Default linker: lld (LLVM)
• Default binary tools: elftoolchain
• Secondary C Compiler: GCC
• Secondary C++ compiler: GCC
• Secondary binary tools: GNU Binutils & LLVM
• Secondary linker(s): bfd, gold
• C++ standard library: libcxx (LLVM)
• C++ ABI library: libcxxabi (LLVM)
• Unwinding Library: libunwind (LLVM)
• Init system: skarnet's S6 & S6-rc
• Device manager: Udev
• TLS Implementaion: LibreSSL
• Secondary TLS Implementaion: OpenSSL
• System Shell: Bash
• System Gettext: gettext-tiny
• Curses Library: netbsd-curses

Supported Architectures

• AMD64/x86_64: Toolchains and final system build sucessfully (musl & glibc hosts) .
• i686: Pending
• AARCH64/ARM64: Pending
• ARMV7L: Pending

Goals

• [x] Build a toolchain (llvmtools) with LLVM+stage1_clang but without GCC
• [x] Build final root filesystem with LLVM
• [x] Set default linker as lld(LLVM)
• [x] Set default C++ standard library as libcxx(LLVM)
• [x] Set default C++ ABI library as libcxxabi(LLVM)
• [x] Set default stack unwinding library as libunwind(LLVM)
• [x] Eliminate dependacy on GCC's libgcc_s
• [x] Build GCC as a secondary systen compiler.
• [x] Build toolchain (llvmtools) with GCC as secondary compiler
• [x] Merge cross-tools build with cgnutools
• [x] Build successfully on a Glibc host
• [x] Build final system without GCC
• [x] Replace binutils with elftoolchain
• [ ] Reduce LLVM size & build time for cgnutools and llvmtools
• [ ] Create initramfs with busybox & mdev
• [ ] Build on aarch64

Host System Requirements

• CMake
• Ninja/Samurai
• wget/cURL

Required Base Development tools (may refer to LFS)

• bash 3.2 (/bin/sh should be a symbolic or hard link to bash)
• binutils 2.25
• bison 2.7 (/usr/bin/yacc should be a link to bison or small script that executes bison)
• bzip2 1.0.4
• coreutils 6.9
• diffutils 2.8.1
• findutils 4.2.31
• gawk 4.0.1 (/usr/bin/awk should be a link to gawk)
• GCC 6.2 (including the C++ compiler, g++)
• Glibc 2.11 / Musl Libc 1.20
• Grep 2.5.1a
• gzip 1.3.12
• linux kernel 3.2 (not sure if it matters, as most distros are running 4.x/5.x kernels
• m4 1.4.10
• make 4.0
• patch 2.5.4
• Python 3.4
• sed 4.1.5
• tar 1.22
• texinfo 4.7
• xz 5.0.0

• (if hostdistro is MLFS/LFS, then all development packages are installed)

Current Method

Build 'cross-tools' with Mussel to cross-compile a stage0 LLVM+clang. This stage0 clang will still link to libgcc_s [in cgnutools] but will later be used to build a stage1 clang free of libbgcc_s. The goal is to build clang+friends with clang and not GCC.

• Some packages can be built once to be used by the toolchain [llvmtools] and the final system, but will be built twice to make it easy to implement a package managment system [which is outside the scope of this project].

1. Bootstrap build of cgnutools with mussel
2. Use mussel-built toolchain (cgnutools) to build stage0 LLVM+clang
3. Use cgnutools to build stage1 LLVM+clang with sysroot at llvmtools with stage0 LLVM+clang
4. Build enough of llvmtools to enter a chroot with stage1 LLVM+clang
5. Build the rest of llvmtools under chroot
6. Build final system with llvmtools

Issues

• Test for C++11/14 fails when testing stage0 & stage1 LLVM's. Not sure what issue this will cause or if test needs to be revised..
• Coreutils will not build for llvmtools under 32-bit x86 (i386/i586/i686)
• Ninja for llvmtools fails to compile with python3. For now use cmake instead of python3

Change log

• 4.0.0: Upgraded to LLVM 17.0.5
• 3.0.0: Upgraded to LLVM-15.0.6. cgnutools is now bootstrapped with mussel. Replaced binutils with elftoolchain. Most of llvmtools will be build under chroot to avoid contamination from host.
• 2.0.0: Upgraded to LLVM-12.0.0. Upgraded GCC to 10.3.1-x Replace ninja with samurai. Replace zlib with zlib-ng. Patched elfutils to build libelf under clang. No longer using /llvmtools/gnu and /opt/gnu.
• 1.2.0: Incomplete: LLVM-11.0.0, Install GCC & Binutils in /llvmtools & /usr instead of /llvmtools/gnu and /opt/gnu
• 1.1.0: Sucessfully merged cross-tools and cgnutools to include GCC & binutils.
• 1.0.0: Sucessfully built on x86_64. GCC built as secondary compiler in /opt/gnu
• 0.1.3: Configure Stage1 clang correctly with x86_64-pc-linux-musl.cfg.
• 0.1.2: Use stage0 to build a stage1 clang...Stage1 clang will be used in chroot. Stage1 clang fails to compile
• 0.1.1: Build stage0 clang by building clang, lld, compiler-rt, libunwind, libcxxabi, libcxx together in llvm source tree. Stage0 builds binaries with host's dynamic linker in /lib
• 0.1.0: Build cross-tools with GCC to build stage 1 clang... first build libunwind, libcxxabi & libcxx - stage1 Clang broken
• 0.0.0: First attempt, modeled afer Genshen's repo: Stage 2 clang fails to build.

Projects of Interest

• [Mussel](https://github.com/firasuke/mussel)
• [Musl Linux From Scratch](https://github.com/dslm4515/Musl-LFS) - Based on LFS, but uses Musl instead of Glibc
• [Beyond MLFS](https://github.com/dslm4515/BMLFS) - The Musl version of LFS's BLFS
• [MLFS-S6-Bootscripts](https://github.com/dslm4515/MLFS-S6-Bootscripts) - Boot scripts for CMLFS/MLFS/LFS using skarnet's S6+S6-rc init system
• [MLFS-Pkgtool](https://github.com/dslm4515/MLFS-pkgtool) - Musl LFS with Slackware's pkgtools
• [Genshen's docker-clang-toolchain](https://github.com/genshen/docker-clang-toolchain)
• [Build a freestanding libc++](https://blogs.gentoo.org/gsoc2016-native-clang/2016/05/05/build-a-freestanding-libcxx/)