end-4 / dots-hyprland

Modern, feature-rich and accessible desktop configuration.
https://end-4.github.io/dots-hyprland-wiki/en/
GNU General Public License v3.0
3.04k stars 196 forks source link

[Issue] Song change notifications build up in sidebar notification list #543

Open b4shful opened 1 month ago

b4shful commented 1 month ago

To be clear, the timeout (disappearing from the center of the screen) works fine, and it's probably the desired behaviour for most notifications, but specifically for song change notifications it can be very annoying as they stack up in the sidebar. Like so:

image

Interestingly, closing any one of the song change notifications from the sidebar then closes ALL song change notifications from all music apps.

l4v3nx commented 1 month ago

disable this setting in spotify's settings image

b4shful commented 1 month ago

disable this setting in spotify's settings image

@l4v3nx Ah apologies, I wasn't clear in my original post. My issue is not with the existence of the notifications I'm aware they can be turned off in individual music player's settings. The notifications are fine actually, and they go off screen within a few seconds. I would like to keep this brief few second "pop up". The issue is that when they disappear from the main screen, they still remain in the sidebar.

I think for most people the expected behaviour of a song change notification in particular would be that it briefly appears on screen, and then disappears completely (including from the sidebar). Otherwise you get dozens of "unread" notifications appearing in the sidebar when listening to music.

l4v3nx commented 1 month ago

isn't this the intented behaviour? i guess something can be done with notification importance in code to show them as pop up but don't save in sideright window, but I'm not sure if these applications use "quiet" notifications (or whatever they are) to make any changes possible. at this moment i can suggest you to use another notification daemon such as mako (but you won't see notification history in sideright window at all)