fast4x / RiMusic

A multilingual Android application for streaming music from YouTube Music.
https://rimusic.xyz
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.23k stars 69 forks source link

Ability to remove song from playlist #1785

Open abdulkarimx1 opened 1 month ago

abdulkarimx1 commented 1 month ago

Description

The user cannot remove a song ( currently playing ) from playlist unless he exits the player and minimize it, and then removing the song from the list

Suggested Solution

Adding a button to be able to remove the song while already being in the song

Alternatives

No response

Additional Context

Screenshot_20240505-171508_RiMusic Screenshot_20240505-171931_RiMusic

AquamarineDreams commented 1 month ago

That's probably because the queue may contain songs from other playlists. So, when opening a song menu, directly of the music player, the queue would need to know where that song came from, in order to delete it from your playlist.

Let's imagine the following situation: You open your playlist like normal and, let's suppose, you have back in black in it. After hearing back in black, you add it to your queue again, but, you add it from the music search. When listening to the song again, you decide to remove it from your playlist. You Open the song menu, and you wouldn't be able to, because the song you added isn't from your playlist.

I think this would clutter the app with an unnecessary feature, which would possibly confuse users.

AquamarineDreams commented 1 month ago

Remembering that this is my opinion, and fast4x is the one who decides whether or not to add it.