Closed pacamaster closed 2 months ago
@noahtalerman FYI - if you want to update the priority order of this, up to you.
Hey @sharon-fdm I think this bug deserves P2
.
With Luke out (DRI of the release), up to Sharon on adjusting the priority (P- label)
As part of #18187 we intended to disable AI feature by default for existing users (migration) while enable for new Fleet deployments.
Hey @pacamaster and @nonpunctual FYI I made this small tweak to the expected behavior:
Disable AI feature by default for existing Fleet deployments (migration) while enable for new Fleet deployments.
@noahtalerman NP. we can take it as high priority.
3 cases: Migration from a version without the feature (<4.50 (?) ) --> disable. Migration from a version WITH the feature --> leave the status as-is. New installation --> enable.
@noahtalerman @sharon-fdm My opinion would be that they should be disabled by default. Again, what customer-reedtimmer took issue with was compliance. I guess the assumption would be that someone setting up new would have checked this off their list, but, what if they don't & what if we forget to tell them? There may be a strict policy in an org against enabling AI anything & that mandate may be an SLA or a legal agreement.
Hey @nonpunctual we decided to take the risk here and enable by default for new deployments.
Why? Triggering AI-features is up to the user. They have to click the "Auto-fill" button to send an osquery query (SQL) to OpenAI. Also, the only data they can send are osquery queries.
what if they don't & what if we forget to tell them?
They can immediately to settings to disable the feature.
If you have any concerns let's chat about this during product office hours :)
@noahtalerman Queries can contain proprietary data that is intended to be private to an organization:
I am not saying what we should or should not do. I am pointing out the reason why security-minded orgs object to sending data off to a 3rd party.
Upgraded Fleet shines, AI features, default off, Balance, users find.
Fleet version: <!-- Copy this from the "My account" page in the Fleet UI, or run
fleetctl --version
--> 4.50.0 Web browser and operating system: Current browser and OS💥 Actual behavior
🧑💻 Steps to reproduce
🕯️ More info (optional)
Related to #19351
🛠️ To fix
Disable AI feature by default for existing Fleet deployments (migration) while enable for new Fleet deployments.