search

iho-ohi / S-100-Validation-Checks

S-100 Github repository for Validation Check development.
15 stars 2 forks source link

Part 7 check S100_Dev0088 #22

Closed rmalyankar closed 5 months ago

rmalyankar commented 11 months ago

S100_Dev0088 GM_Primitives are part of at least one GM_Aggregate

The cited S-100 clause 7-4.2.11.1 does say that but it is inaccurate and not supported by the UML diagram in Figure 7-3; nor have I been able to find the ISO 19107 clause it cites (ISO 19107 clause 8.10.1). ISO 19107:2003 describes GM_Primitive in clause 6.3.10 but that does not contain this statement from S-100 7-4.2.11.1.

The S-100 statement appears to be a misunderstanding or typographical error. Recommend removal of this validation check.

LizHahessy commented 5 months ago

Discussed at VTC 8. Agreed to remove check and Liz to feedback inconsistency to Julia. 'Strikethrough' check and close issue.

LizHahessy commented 1 day ago

S-100 Change Proposal Form submitted to S-100 WG9 Nov 2024 to remove statement in Part 7 at the next version of S-100.