search

iho-ohi / S-100-Validation-Checks

S-100 Github repository for Validation Check development.
15 stars 1 forks source link

S100_050, S100_061, S100_064 #8

Closed rmalyankar closed 1 year ago

rmalyankar commented 1 year ago

The following are rules for production, interpretation, or dataset management, rather than validation checks - they cannot be applied to check anything, instead they specify "what to do" rather "what the subject(*) must or must not have".

S100_050 When a datasets is cancelled it must be removed from the system S100_061 The start and end instants of [t]he interval calculated by combining userDefinedMaintenanceFrequency with the issue date/time must be interpreted according to Part 3 Clause 3-8 S100_064 If both userDefinedMaintenanceFrequency and the maintenanceDate are encoded in the same discovery metadata block, the maintenanceDate supersede the userDefinedMaintenanceFrequency

(*) dataset for 050, metadata discovery block for 061 and 064

Check 050 specifies the state of the end-user system after ingesting/integrating a cancellation; 061 and 064 specify how the end-user application must interpret certain elements in discovery metadata. They might perhaps be rewritten as requiring verification that the producer's intent is consistent with the mandated action or interpretations, but was that the intent in including them or does it stretch the meaning of "validation check" further than we want?

LizHahessy commented 1 year ago

Agreed at S100 Validation VTC 3 to move to S-164 https://github.com/iho-ohi/S-164-Sub-Group/issues/38