search

jenkinsci / hipchat-plugin

HipChat notification plugin for Jenkins
https://plugins.jenkins.io/hipchat/
54 stars 85 forks source link

Stride API support #115

Closed vkotovv closed 6 years ago

vkotovv commented 6 years ago

Since Atlassian encourages all teams to migrate to Stride, I think it's pretty important to support new API. Looks like HipChat is deprecated, after you migrate your Jenkins plugin integrations with HipChat will not work with Stride.

aldaris commented 6 years ago

Pull requests welcomed

vkotovv commented 6 years ago

@aldaris ok, I see. What do you think, should this be a separate plugin or just additions to this? Because the name will be confusing I suppose.

aldaris commented 6 years ago

The card concept exists in Stride as well, but probably the JSON schema is going to be different. I think first the two APIs should be compared, and then see how well the new impl would fit into the existing code.

vkotovv commented 6 years ago

@aldaris I dig a bit into it and I think it is somewhat different. For example, we can send private messages to users through the API.

aldaris commented 6 years ago

That was also possible with the old API, but had some additional authorization requirements. See PR #19 for further discussions on that topic.

vkotovv commented 6 years ago

One major change that I've found is that it is no longer possible to send messages in HTML format anymore in Stride. Instead, you'll need to use plain text, or craft cumbersome JSON (pretty similar to Cards JSON that existed in HipChat) even for simple rich text formatting.

kmadel commented 6 years ago

I would think it should be a new Stride plugin

tcrusson commented 6 years ago

Hi all, Tanguy from the Stride product team. Stride is a fundamentally different product to Hipchat, and as such the APIs are very different. This definitely calls for a separate plugin. Based on user demand we've decided to build it ourselves. You can track the progress in this ticket: https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/STRIDE-1973

aldaris commented 6 years ago

Closing this issue, nothing to do in hipchat-plugin.