kalebpederson / nunit.dependencyinjection

Add support to NUnit for constructor injection using an inversion control container, such as Unity or Autofac.
8 stars 2 forks source link
dependency-injection extension nunit unity-container

Introduction

Outside of pure unit tests it sometimes becomes desirable to do dependency injection in automated tests. By their nature these aren't the typical unit tests as they have dependencies. These could be, for example, acceptance tests against a standalone application. The dependencies to be injected, in this case, might be things to provide information about the environment to hit, such as hostnames and database connection strings, or may be client SDKs to the system under test. This framework is intended to support these scenarios.

Warning

Good unit tests shouldn't need to inject dependencies into the test fixture. If you need dependency injection into a test fixture in unit tests then consider whether the design of the system could be changed in such a way that the system under test can be easily unit tested without that need.

From here on out it is assumed that the purpose for dependency injection within tests has been validated and is appropriate.

API Stability

In accordance with semantic versioning, all versions prior to 1.0 are assumed pre-releases and are NOT subject to API/ABI compatibility.

Usage

The below is subject to change at our whims until version 1.0, though note that we don't expect it to change. For a working example see the different test projects in the Validation folder.

Two different mechanisms are currently provided by which dependencies are discovered, though custom processes can be added as well:

  1. Explicit registration of dependencies via the IIocRegistrar
  2. Convention based assembly scanning and registration of types

These approaches are described below.

Discovery/Scanning of all IIocRegistrars

When many different assemblies are present it can become difficult to automatically register all interfaces with their corresponding concrete types. Or, perhaps we prefer that everything be manually registered to make the process and choice very explicit. The example below demonstrates that process:

// First import the following NuGet packages: 
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Abstractions
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Unity

using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection;
using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Abstractions;
using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Unity;

// tell the extension that we will be using the Microsoft Unity Injection
// factory
[assembly: NUnitTypeInjectionFactory(typeof(UnityInjectionFactory))]

// If we want to manually register the different types we need to create
// one or more implementations of IIocRegistrar that register with the
// container and then use the IocRegistrarTypeDiscoverer.
[assembly: NUnitTypeDiscoverer(typeof(IocRegistrarTypeDiscoverer))]

// The registrar above will scan for implementations of IIocRegistrar,
// which the RegistrarBase class implements, and then execute each
// discovered registrations:
public class MyRegistrar : RegistrarBase<IUnityContainer>
{
  protected override void RegisterInternal(IUnityContainer container)
  {
    container.RegisterType<IDependency1, Dependency1>();
    container.RegisterType<IDependency2, Dependency2>();
  }
}

// Loaded assemblies are scanned for interfaces and corresponding concrete
// definitions. For example:
public interface IDependency1 {}
public interface IDependency2 {}

public class Dependency1 : IDependency1 { }

// Instead of using the [TestFixture] attribute when declaring a test class
// you'll need to decorate the class with a DependencyInjectingTestFixture
// attribute:
[NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.DependencyInjectingTestFixture]
public class MyTests
{
  private readonly IDependency1 _dependency1;
  private readonly IDependency2 _dependency2;

  // once everything is properly configured, dependencies can be injected
  // directly into the constructor
  public MyTests(IDependency1 dependency1, IDependency2 dependency2)
  {
    _dependency1 = dependency1;
    _dependency2 = dependency2;
  }

  [Test]
  public void Test_something_using_IDependency1()
  {
    Assert.That(_dependency1, Is.Not.Null);
    Assert.That(_dependency1, Is.InstanceOf<Dependency1>());
  }
}

Convention Based Type Discovery

Sometimes it's convenient if the inversion of control container picks up all of the interfaces and their mapping registrations automatically. For example, given an interface IDateTimeProvider and a corresponding implementation DateTimeProvider, we might want to register the interface IDateTimeProvider as corresponding to the concrete implementation of DateTimeProvider. This example demonstrates that process:

// First import the following NuGet packages: 
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Abstractions
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Unity

using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection;
using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Abstractions;
using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Unity;

// tell the extension that we will be using the Microsoft Unity Injection
// factory
[assembly: NUnitTypeInjectionFactory(typeof(UnityInjectionFactory))]

// If we wanted to automatically register all interfaces with their concrete
// implementations for which the NUnitAutoScanAssembly attribute is present on
// the assembly is present we could do the following:
[assembly: NUnitTypeDiscoverer(typeof(ConventionMappingTypeDiscoverer))]

// When using the ConventionMappingTypeDiscoverer it can be problematic and
// dangerous to scan lots of framework assemblies and types and pre-register 
// them, so assemblies to be scanned **MUST** be decorated with the 
// NUnitAutoScanAssembly attribute.
[assembly: NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.NUnitAutoScanAssembly]

// Loaded assemblies are scanned for interfaces and corresponding concrete
// definitions. For example:
public interface IDependency1 {}
public interface IDependency2 {}

public class Dependency1 : IDependency1 { }

// Instead of using the [TestFixture] attribute when declaring a test class
// you'll need to decorate the class with a DependencyInjectingTestFixture
// attribute:
[NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.DependencyInjectingTestFixture]
public class MyTests
{
  private readonly IDependency1 _dependency1;
  private readonly IDependency2 _dependency2;

  // once everything is properly configured, dependencies can be injected
  // directly into the constructor
  public MyTests(IDependency1 dependency1, IDependency2 dependency2)
  {
    _dependency1 = dependency1;
    _dependency2 = dependency2;
  }

  [Test]
  public void Test_something_using_IDependency1()
  {
    Assert.That(_dependency1, Is.Not.Null);
    Assert.That(_dependency1, Is.InstanceOf<Dependency1>());
  }
}

Manual IIocRegistrar Selection

When conflicting IIocRegistrars are present it's not possible to use assembly scanning. In this case, it's helpful to create a single IIocRegistrar that is manually defined and which will perform all necessary registrations.

// First import the following NuGet packages: 
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Abstractions
// * NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Unity

using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection;
using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Abstractions;
using NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.Unity;

// tell the extension that we will be using the Microsoft Unity Injection
// factory
[assembly: NUnitTypeInjectionFactory(typeof(UnityInjectionFactory))]

// If we wanted to automatically register all interfaces with their concrete
// implementations for which the NUnitAutoScanAssembly attribute is present on
// the assembly is present we could do the following:
[assembly: NUnitTypeDiscoverer(
  typeof(ManualRegistrarTypeDiscoverer<BundlingRegistrar>))]

public class BundlingRegistrar : RegistrarBase<IUnityContainer>
{
  /// <inheritdoc />
  protected override void RegisterInternal(IUnityContainer container)
  {
    container.RegisterType<IDependency1, Dependency1>();
    container.RegisterType<IDependency2, Dependency2>();
  }
}

// Loaded assemblies are scanned for interfaces and corresponding concrete
// definitions. For example:
public interface IDependency1 {}
public interface IDependency2 {}

public class Dependency1 : IDependency1 { }

// Instead of using the [TestFixture] attribute when declaring a test class
// you'll need to decorate the class with a DependencyInjectingTestFixture
// attribute:
[NUnit.Extension.DependencyInjection.DependencyInjectingTestFixture]
public class MyTests
{
  private readonly IDependency1 _dependency1;
  private readonly IDependency2 _dependency2;

  // once everything is properly configured, dependencies can be injected
  // directly into the constructor
  public MyTests(IDependency1 dependency1, IDependency2 dependency2)
  {
    _dependency1 = dependency1;
    _dependency2 = dependency2;
  }

  [Test]
  public void Test_something_using_IDependency1()
  {
    Assert.That(_dependency1, Is.Not.Null);
    Assert.That(_dependency1, Is.InstanceOf<Dependency1>());
  }
}

Changelog

Contributing

Please submit a PR. If the change is major it may be worth filing an issue first even if only it only serves as a mechanism for discussion to ensure that the work your doing aligns with the goals of this project.

For more information on the project structure and validation process please see the Development_Readme.md document.

Troubleshooting

Although we have put a lot of effort into ensuring that the error messages are descriptive and self-explanatory, unfortunately many of the test runners hide error messages that occur while setting up the test. Suggested steps:

  1. Verify that all the steps required to setup dependency injection for the given type discoverer have been performed.

  2. If possible, run the test using dotnet test or the native NUnit test runner as they provide better error information, such as the full exception and stack trace.

TODO

  1. Support for other containers - Autofac and other containers that are more popular should be supported. I may just target the new .NET Core dependency injection abstractions in hopes that it will be a sufficient bridge between all others.