lexibank / abvd

CLDF dataset derived from Greenhill et al.'s "Austronesian Basic Vocabulary Database" from 2020.
https://abvd.eva.mpg.de
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
2 stars 2 forks source link

11 -> 1 for 1193-92_toopenuncover-1 ? #23

Closed HedvigS closed 1 month ago

HedvigS commented 1 month ago

I suspect that the form below should be in cognacy class 1 rather than 11. The same is perhaps also true of 983-92_toopenuncover-1.

ID  Local_ID    Language_ID Parameter_ID    Value   Form    Segments    Comment Source  Cognacy
1193-92_toopenuncover-1 287978  1193    92_toopenuncover    mukaʔ   mukaʔ           67307   11

For brief context

Other members of 11:

duuki
suuki
suugiɪ
suughi
sukej
bukaʔ
sugeg
shoeegu

Other members of 1:

buka
puke
bika
munukə
mo-muʔo
muka
mbukak
wuʔa
bukaʔ
buŋgăhu
buka
bukáʔ
buka
fuka
buka
bukuəʔ
mukaʔ
uk
bukkaʔ
céŋka
wuka
ma-móha
puk
vuke
boka
mbukaʔ
buge
məmukaʔ
boke
hoka
buka
fukac
puke
-puki
wuka
buka
mukā
mamuka
buka
mambuka
bo'ahaè
buka
bukaq
mabbukka
buka
ŋəbukaʔ
nguka
buka
wu
membuka
bukaʔ
bukaʔ
mambuka
*buka
*buka
*buka
mbikak
mukɘ
buka
bunggero
bhugera
buwa
bugera
buke
bungga
bungga
bowa
bukaʔ
pʷak
úka
káuka
membuka
bukaan
bukaʔ
movoɣ
m+buka'+en
buka
puk
buka
muhka
buke
buka
buka'
bukis
mawuka
wuka'an
mbuka
buke
bukɑʔ
bukɑʔ
bukɑʔ
bukɑʔ
bukɑʔ
bukɜʔ
bukɑ
bukɑ
ŋɑbukɑʔ
bukɑʔ
ŋɑbukɑʔ
ŋɑmbukɑ
ŋubukɑ
ŋəbukɑʔ
ŋɑbukɑʔ
bukɑʔ
bukɑ
buke
bukɑʔ
bukɑʔ
dibukɑʔ
momuko
mukǝ
muka
dibukɨ
mukǝ
mukǝ
muka
buka
buka
buka
buka
bukak
baək
búka
vu31 ha31
*bukaʔ
pŏk
pŏk
mabuká
*bukaʔ
buká
buka
*buka
*bukas
buka
ipki
bukaʔ
bukaʔ
bukaʔ
bukaʔ
bukaʔ
bukaʔ
boeka
boeka
mi-vòha
bukaʔ
bukaʔ
vuka
bukaʔ
məmbukaʔ
bukáʔ
boksán
boksí
boka
buka
barlowrussell commented 1 month ago

Yup, those look like "1" to me (from PMP buka 'to open, uncover, expose', with with actor-voice prefix maN- probably in the case of 1193-92).

HedvigS commented 1 month ago

moving to email.