Solve failed

[unktomi]

decoding Gray code images for projector 0, camera 0 elapsed time 1588 projecting depth points to color camera 0 rejected 14.13666% pixels for high variance elapsed time 1770 projector 0 is seen by camera 0 (20180 points) elapsed time 1858 calibrating projector 0 RANSAC iteration 0 error = 429.497279415675 RANSAC iteration 1 error = 151.60088993423 RANSAC iteration 2 error = 116.755996115679 RANSAC iteration 3 error = 114.391513594397 RANSAC iteration 4 error = 93.634629536181 RANSAC iteration 5 error = 79.4883445206181 RANSAC iteration 6 error = 97.0091158968851 RANSAC iteration 7 error = 77.5354579378281 RANSAC iteration 8 error = 71.8200025854655 RANSAC iteration 9 error = 60.2050934296484 Solve failed RoomAliveToolkit.ProjectorCameraEnsemble+CalibrationFailedException: Unable to successfully calibrate projector: 0 at RoomAliveToolkit.ProjectorCameraEnsemble.CalibrateProjectorGroups(String directory) in E:\GitHub\RoomAliveToolkit\ProCamCalibration\ProCamEnsembleCalibration\ProjectorCameraEnsemble.cs:line 668 at RoomAliveToolkit.MainForm.Solve() in E:\GitHub\RoomAliveToolkit\ProCamCalibration\CalibrateEnsemble\MainForm.cs:line 1115 Solve complete

Any ideas?

Thanks!

[thundercarrot]

Can you zip up your calibration directory and put it some place where I can download it? Thanks

[devhci]

Hi I am also facing the exact same issue , @unktomi were u able to find out the solution ?

@thundercarrot when I started the calibration I could calibrate for first time correctly but now when i am trying to calibrate again for new location it shows the error message .....

"Acquire complete decoding Gray code images for projector 0, camera 0 elapsed time 7190 projecting depth points to color camera 0 rejected 35.47501% pixels for high variance elapsed time 7813 elapsed time 8145 calibrating projector 0 RANSAC iteration 0 Solve failed System.NullReferenceException: Object reference not set to an instance of an object. at RoomAliveToolkit.Matrix.Copy(Matrix A) in C:\Users\test\Desktop\Roomalive\RoomAliveToolkit-master\ProCamCalibration\ProCamEnsembleCalibration\Matrix.cs:line 129 at RoomAliveToolkit.ProjectorCameraEnsemble.CalibrateProjectorGroups(String directory) in C:\Users\test\Desktop\Roomalive\RoomAliveToolkit-master\ProCamCalibration\ProCamEnsembleCalibration\ProjectorCameraEnsemble.cs:line 741 at RoomAliveToolkit.MainForm.Solve() in C:\Users\test\Desktop\Roomalive\RoomAliveToolkit-master\ProCamCalibration\CalibrateEnsemble\MainForm.cs:line 1130 Solve complete "

Thanks in advance /\

Regards Devender

[thundercarrot]

Devender, can you zip up your calibration directory and put it some place where I can download it? Thanks

[devhci]

Hi @thundercarrot

I got this Solve failed error again , I downloaded the fresh code from git & just compiled it without any modification. I am attaching the image of error message. (One kinect one projector)

Thanks Devender

[thundercarrot]

Try making the projected image larger -- i.e. move the projector back.

Can you zip up your calibration directory and put it some place where I can download it? I will take a look.

[devhci]

Hi Andy ,

Yes, by making projected image larger the error disappeared! I wasted 2 days resolving such a silly thing (I was debugging code ) but than your comment came as a New Year GIFT :smile: Thank u so much

Happy New Year! Devender

[sapratte]

Hi,

I'm also getting the solve failed error: Solve failed RoomAliveToolkit.ProjectorCameraEnsemble+CalibrationFailedException: Unable to successfully calibrate projector: 0

Here is my calibration directory:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/1q3ou58lvb4dmx1/Calibration.zip?dl=0

Thanks!

[thundercarrot]

Sapratte,

The projected image as seen by the camera is too small. Try moving camera closer.

Also, your projection surface is too flat for the calibration to recover projector intrinsics. Try shooting into a corner or temporarily place some large objects like a box in the scene.

[sapratte]

Hi Andy,

Thanks for the fast response! I got the projector and camera calibrated and I think I have successfully run the sample project.

However I am now at a loss as to how to proceed. I believe you spoke to a friend of mine, Teddy Seyed about the device communication toolkit (Society of Devices Toolkit) we've been working on at the University of Calgary. I want to make a simple map application that links the projected display to a physical display. Could you give me some tips on how to get started on linking the RoomAlive toolkit to another application?

Sorry to bother you with this, I just thought it would be faster to get your help right away.

Thanks, Sydney

On Tue, Jan 26, 2016 at 12:04 PM, Andy Wilson notifications@github.com wrote:

Sapratte,

The projected image as seen by the camera is too small. Try moving camera closer.

Also, your projection surface is too flat for the calibration to recover projector intrinsics. Try shooting into a corner or temporarily place some large objects like a box in the scene.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/Kinect/RoomAliveToolkit/issues/14#issuecomment-175180948 .

[thundercarrot]

Sydney,

I'm not sure I understand what you're trying to do, but I'll go after "linking the RoomAlive toolkit to another application". You have a couple of options. First, if you have the source code for the application, you could wire it into the ProjectionMappingSample directly. If you do not, your second option is to look at the "desktop duplication" feature of the ProjectionMappingSample, where any application that renders to the Windows desktop can be used as the target view for projection mapping.