ntra00 / marc2bibframe

Convert marc to BIBFRAME 1.0 - see lcnetdev/marc2bibframe2 for current release
http://www.loc.gov/bibframe/
Other
64 stars 20 forks source link

MARC 520 again #204

Open kiegel opened 9 years ago

kiegel commented 9 years ago

The changes to the annotation look good.

<http://example.org/99149418740001452summary11> a bf:Summary ;
    bf:annotationAssertedBy <http://id.loc.gov/vocabulary/organizations/dlc> ;
    bf:annotationBody "The Daryl M. Brotman political portraits photograph collection consists of autographed photographs of political figures: American presidents, Supreme Court justices, congressmen and women, cabinet officers, governors, and one newspaper columnist (Drew Pearson) during the 20th century. Most of the photographs were taken between the 1930s and 1970s; these include portraits of Adlai Stevenson and Richard Nixon by Arnold Newman and a photograph of Henry Wallace by Philippe Halsman." ;
    bf:label "Summary" ;
    bf:summaryOf <http://example.org/99149418740001452> .

However, the body of the annotation (field 520) still appears in the Instance in bf:note. That should be removed.

Also, where does bf:annotationAssertedBy come from? In this record, there is nothing from the Library of Congress. A default value of dlc makes sense for LC but not other libraries using the converter.

(OCLC # 732757871)

kiegel commented 9 years ago

The range of annotationBody is defined as rdfs:Resource. Doesn't that mean it should be a URI, but it has a literal in the example above. Should the range be redefined?

kiegel commented 9 years ago

The contents of the label property should be determined by the first indicator value, instead of always being "Summary".

520 2_ |a The Ibsen A. Nelsen papers consist of two accessions: Accession No. 4007-001 contains biographical features and some correspondence, but is primarily comprised of project files arranged by project number (a key to the project numbers is available in the repository). It also contains five boxes documenting Nelsen's interest in civic concerns, particularly historic preservation. Material relates to his involvement with Allied Arts, Forward Thrust, the Seattle Municipal Art Commission, Seattle Design Commission, the Seattle chapter of the American Institute of Architects, and the Washington Roadside Council. Accession No. 2858-001 are two oral history interviews with Nelsen conducted by Gloria Peck in 1977 for the Archives of Northwest Art project.

becomes

<http://example.org/99125858260001452summary14> a bf:Summary ;
    bf:annotationAssertedBy <http://id.loc.gov/vocabulary/organizations/dlc> ;
    bf:annotationBody "The Ibsen A. Nelsen papers consist of two accessions: Accession No. 4007-001 contains biographical features and some correspondence, but is primarily comprised of project files arranged by project number (a key to the project numbers is available in the repository). It also contains five boxes documenting Nelsen's interest in civic concerns, particularly historic preservation. Material relates to his involvement with Allied Arts, Forward Thrust, the Seattle Municipal Art Commission, Seattle Design Commission, the Seattle chapter of the American Institute of Architects, and the Washington Roadside Council. Accession No. 2858-001 are two oral history interviews with Nelsen conducted by Gloria Peck in 1977 for the Archives of Northwest Art project." ;
    bf:label "Summary" ;
    bf:summaryOf <http://example.org/99125858260001452> .

Instead it should be:

bf:label "Scope and content" ;

(OCLC # 123952248)