search

ntra00 / marc2bibframe

Convert marc to BIBFRAME 1.0 - see lcnetdev/marc2bibframe2 for current release
http://www.loc.gov/bibframe/
Other
64 stars 20 forks source link

MARC 780 $g #216

Open kiegel opened 9 years ago

kiegel commented 9 years ago

Field 780 $g (Related parts) is not converted.

780 02 |a Russia. Departament narodnago prosvi︠e︡shchenīi︠a︡. |t Zapiski |g 1825-29

<http://example.org/99129152590001452work16> a bf:Work ;
    bf:authorizedAccessPoint "Russia. Departament narodnago prosvi︠e︡shchenīi︠a︡. Zapiski" ;
    bf:contributor <http://example.org/99129152590001452agent21> ;
    bf:title "Zapiski" .

(OCLC # 1779370)

ntra00 commented 9 years ago

Where should this go? bf:extent?

kiegel commented 9 years ago

The information in this subfield relates to the preceding entry and needs to be associated with it. It is not extent. The kind of information in $g varies: "numeric and/or alphabetic, chronological, or other designation that identifies the relationship of the resource with the related item" (CONSER Editing Guide).

We talked about it and don't see a good solution. $g is part of the description of the related resource, not the resource being described, yet it is specific to the resource being described. In other words, it needs to be part of the Work for the related title, but coded to show that it applies only to the Work referring to it. BF doesn't have properties for that.

ntra00 commented 9 years ago

well, it is in the related work; I could make it a bf:note for now.