search

operator-framework / enhancements

Apache License 2.0
9 stars 40 forks source link

[WIP] Add upstream downstream split enhancement #52

Closed ankitathomas closed 3 years ago

anik120 commented 3 years ago

Also, we should discuss moving operator-framework/operator-marketplace to openshift/operator-marketplace too

kevinrizza commented 3 years ago

@anik120

Also, we should discuss moving operator-framework/operator-marketplace to openshift/operator-marketplace too

Are we expecting an upstream community for that project? Is the marketplace operator even part of the cncf donation? At this point in the project, it feels like it mostly exists as a bootstrapper to configure OKD/OpenShift with some defaults. I think it maybe makes sense to move it into the OpenShift org if that's the case, but does it make sense to maintain an upstream operator-framework project as well?

anik120 commented 3 years ago

Are we expecting an upstream community for that project? Is the marketplace operator even part of the cncf donation? At this point in the project, it feels like it mostly exists as a bootstrapper to configure OKD/OpenShift with some defaults. I think it maybe makes sense to move it into the OpenShift org if that's the case, but does it make sense to maintain an upstream operator-framework project as well?

@kevinrizza with a default operatorhub catalog being installed with an upstream installation of OLM, I don't see why we would need the marketplace-operator at all since we don't plan on configuring those defaults on vanilla k8s clusters.

Also, at it's current state, I don't believe it provides much value to the upstream community, so I don't see it as being a part of the cncf donation.

That would mean we don't really need an upstream project for the marketplace-operator, but having said that, I'll defer to @dangeoffroy @dmesser to confirm.

ankitathomas commented 3 years ago

Closed in favor of https://github.com/operator-framework/enhancements/pull/56