Open albertmeronyo opened 3 years ago
Concepts collected in this document
Relevant concepts in the CQs of Sethus
“Scale” discussion:
Models:
Patterns:
Scope question (for later):
Relevant ontologies:
Next steps:
2nd maninpasta: Marco's work on requirements for a Modal Ontology https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1odOcpU8E7eFmCyhcgy-uLMqMGzwC6h_ned0Rfex2Xx0/edit#gid=0
2nd maninpasta: we came up with a graffoo diagram for an ontology of musical theories for analysis (also at the SharePoint > Maninpasta > Sethus)
Session 14-05-2021: Absolutely brilliant first draft for a modal tonal ontology by Christophe and Marco at https://github.com/guillotel-nothmann/modal-tonal-ontology/tree/main/historicalModels
Instances of the ontology will typically (but not always) be segments/fragments pointing at some section of an MEI document
AP: discuss ontology engineering issues around this draft in the OntologyDesign working sessions
The ontology is an interpretation of the Michael Praetorius book http://diglib.hab.de/drucke/1-1-musica-3s/start.htm?image=0053 It's digitised at Huma at http://tmg.huma-num.fr/xtf/view?docId=tei/Praetorius%201619/Praetorius%201619.xml;chunk.id=div_2_3_6;toc.depth=1;toc.id=div_2_3;brand=default#X Christophe has an article about it at https://www.gmth.de/zeitschrift/artikel/1073.aspx
Ontology contains provenance links to sections of the book that were used to model concepts
Challenge: distinction between classes and individuals (instances)
Documenting classes and relations
Pointer to W3C PROV: idea of "trusted ontology engineering" with full provenance traces of decisions made during conceptualisation
Pointer to https://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-schema/ Container Classes to model multiple interpretations over the source, possibly with order
Issue to discuss progress in OntologyDesign#1, focusing on ontologies to describe modes and modal analysis