Open yonisidi opened 1 month ago
First note that tbl-label
is not a known option. I don't know what you expect from it, but I don't think it will have any effect.
When setting fig.cap in global knitr::opts_chunk
When you are doing this, this is equivalent to setting fig-cap
in all your chunk individually.
---
title: "Test"
date: today
format: pdf
---
```{r}
tbl_data <- tibble::tibble(a = letters[1:5], b = LETTERS[1:5])
#| tbl-cap: 'Test GT'
#| tbl-label: test_gt
#| fig-cap: '123'
tbl_data |> gt::gt()
So basically, you get what you are asking, as you set two caption in the cell. I don't think this is really good practice so set `fig.cap` as a global option. What use case do you have for this ?
We could probably do better to help users do the right things, and check for them the option, but it could happen only in some specific context (like a prefixed label like `#[ label: tbl-tab` is used, so we know the caption should be `tbl-cap` and not `fig-cap`.
But just to re-clarify here, the result is what is asked to **knitr**
I believe we will fix this when we will have the correct intermediate markdown syntax for computation
* https://github.com/quarto-dev/quarto-cli/issues/7062
because **knitr** nor **jupyter** shouldn't be allowed in Quarto write a caption in a div syntax, and an attribute.
## Issue to fix: Two caption attributes shouldn't be set on a cell
````markdown
---
title: "Test"
date: today
format: html
keep-md: true
---
```{r}
#| tbl-cap: 'Test GT'
#| fig-cap: '123'
tibble::tibble(a = letters[1:5], b = LETTERS[1:5]) |> knitr::kable()
![image](https://github.com/quarto-dev/quarto-cli/assets/6791940/d00d1768-66da-4b9b-b6c9-a47373b93a58)
with this intermediate
````markdown
---
title: "Test"
date: today
format: html
keep-md: true
---
::: {.cell tbl-cap='Test GT'}
```{.r .cell-code}
tibble::tibble(a = letters[1:5], b = LETTERS[1:5]) |> knitr::kable()
::: {.cell-output-display}
a | b |
---|---|
a | A |
b | B |
c | C |
d | D |
e | E |
123 ::: :::
We see the in div caption text, handle by **knitr** and the attributes.
This should not happen
right, i was pointing out that i am rendering a table and getting the figure caption too. which is an issue.
from the documentation of quarto: tbl-cap
comment regarding fig-cap as a global settings is right, I think that is an old habit from rmd settings that you had to "turn on" fig.caps at one point for it to work (maybe bookdown).
When setting fig.cap in global
knitr::opts_chunk
every table gets appended the value set globally to fig.cap