reduxjs / redux

A JS library for predictable global state management
https://redux.js.org
MIT License
60.94k stars 15.26k forks source link

Redux's brand id #151

Closed dariocravero closed 8 years ago

dariocravero commented 9 years ago

Hi all,

As some of you know we've been following, and lately using, Redux more extensively at UXtemple.

We wanted to contribute with a nice touch and @tomatuxtemple, my friend and business partner, started designing a brand identity for Redux. Here's his first iteration at it:

redux-brand-id

I hope you like it and would love to hear your thoughts about it :) Best, Darío

erikras commented 9 years ago

Just saw this on the tweet-machine.

graham

nuragic commented 9 years ago

Hi! I like so much the @malte-wessel logo! When you see it it's like: "Redux?! Mhh sure it's some kind of futurist arquebus...." :smile:

redux to the future

benlesh commented 9 years ago

"Where we're going... we don't need ducks"

erikras commented 9 years ago

Just goofing around with the letters...

redux

Delapouite commented 9 years ago

Beware @erikras , durex is a condom brand http://www.durex.com

erikras commented 9 years ago

Ha! It never occurred to me to read it like that. :-)

benlesh commented 9 years ago

Cannot unsee

volkanunsal commented 9 years ago

Extending React's use of atomic imagery, how about using a Feynmann diagram for the logo? (Just replace the word Feynmann with Redux.)

erikras commented 9 years ago

I :heart: Feynman as much as the next nerd, but the two particles leaving breaks the notion of "reducing".

Maybe something involving nuclear fusion?

benlesh commented 9 years ago

It came to me in a vision...

20150904_122714

erikras commented 9 years ago

@blesh Nice! :clap: :clap:

paoyong commented 9 years ago

@blesh +1

Cmdv commented 9 years ago

@blesh hands down the winner :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

insin commented 9 years ago

ThreeDucks for the win!

LarsJK commented 9 years ago

@blesh nice! Now just color them red and it's the perfect "redducks" icon.

bmueller-sykes commented 9 years ago

I dunno guys, do you really want the Redux logo to be three butt-sniffing ducks?

erikras commented 9 years ago

It's not butt-sniffing, it's tail recursion.

bmueller-sykes commented 9 years ago

Is that what the kids are calling it these days?

vslinko commented 9 years ago

:+1: for @jepezi idea

andrewrothman commented 9 years ago

I like how @jepezi's icon could eventually be used in a devtool as a small tab on the page to show/hide the actions history and such, but I really like the design of @tomatuxtemple's and @WoodyWoodsta's.

smmoosavi commented 9 years ago

Is there any final logo?

GeorgS commented 9 years ago

Here are some basic ideas I came up with

redux_2 redux_4 redux_3 redux_1
rossipedia commented 9 years ago

My two cents:

Redux Logo Idea

qur2 commented 9 years ago

I also thought that it should play well as a small devtools icon.

rockneurotiko commented 9 years ago

I really love the left one of @malte-wessel

paoyong commented 9 years ago

@gaearon My take, based on the concept of how an electron moves to a higher state after absorbing energy

capture d ecran 2015-10-21 a 8 56 40 pm

capture d ecran 2015-10-21 a 8 57 47 pm

camsong commented 9 years ago

@keithyong this one make me think of Ionic, quite misunderstanding.

image

Dakuan commented 9 years ago

I vote something duck related as

a) its funny b) its memorable c) its distinctive d) it involves ducks e) duck related conference swag will be better f) lol ducks

duckconf2016

omnidan commented 9 years ago

Not sure if you guys are really getting serious about this now, but...

I don't think having ducks in the redux logo is a good idea. It might be funny, but it's really an inside joke and people who are new to redux will be like "wat". Also, I don't think ducks scale well (fit into devtools, etc).

Ideally the logo should be something simple but distinctive that looks good in any size (that's one of the reasons why the Google logo was changed).

Oh and, we can still have duck related conference swag, even if the official logo isn't a duck! :grin:

Dakuan commented 9 years ago

I see where you are coming from, but while the others are not an inside joke per say, they are arguably cryptic and require explanation. A n00b isn't going to guess how the logo ties to redux (unless its one of the R variations)

The :hamster: never did ember any harm. A duck outline will scale up or down nicely too. Maybe a lamda, or R or atom thing inside the duck could work on the bigger ones.

erikras commented 9 years ago

See also: Tux

Dakuan commented 9 years ago

Thats my bikeshedding done for the day. Back to work :smile:

omnidan commented 9 years ago

@Dakuan you're right - it was mostly my personal opinion. I just really can't imagine a duck as the official logo for redux. :stuck_out_tongue: As a mascot on the other hand...

As others have pointed out, the meaning isn't that important as long as it's simple, distinctive and scales to different sizes. So yes, a duck would be fine in that case - it still feels like a joke to me, though. (again, this is just my personal opinion)

gaearon commented 9 years ago

Electron is a really good metaphor. Any way we can make it less like Ionic, and simpler in terms of count of shapes?

Dakuan commented 9 years ago

simpler in terms of shapes == more like ionic :crying_cat_face:

Dakuan commented 9 years ago

theres also the fact the react does the atomic thing too. I guess thats both a good and a bad thing!

simplesmiler commented 9 years ago

Npm and wombat anyone?

paoyong commented 9 years ago

Some variations capture d ecran 2015-10-22 a 9 07 24 am

omnidan commented 9 years ago

@simplesmiler yeah, but it's not part of the logo, it's more like a mascot

@gaearon @dakuan I like the idea of having something related to atoms, but it'll be hard to stay distinctive in this field (so many projects already use it, atom, electron, react, etc)

@keithyong the last one looks really cool :ok_hand:

paoyong commented 9 years ago

@omnidan I was also thinking about the theme of biological mutations, but stumped on how that can be visualized in a logo. Nuclear fission may also work as a metaphor too

paoyong commented 9 years ago

Some more variations, playing around with fonts and stuff capture d ecran 2015-10-22 a 10 14 50 am

vslinko commented 9 years ago

@keithyong I think Redux label should be near orange electron. Like that:

Alt text

Sorry for my skills :smile:

gaearon commented 9 years ago

Also, Flux capacitor:

I know Fluxxor used it:

Maybe there's a way to make it more symbolic and less square-y.

ghost commented 9 years ago

Yessssss, flux capacitor for the win haha. It is a fitting date for that. On Thu, Oct 22, 2015 at 2:50 PM Dan Abramov notifications@github.com wrote:

Also, Flux capacitor:

https://camo.githubusercontent.com/230e52e7c791df90de478c40369c4562ba36ce58/687474703a2f2f7669676e65747465322e77696b69612e6e6f636f6f6b69652e6e65742f627474662f696d616765732f622f62362f425454462d67616d652d53532d30392e6a70672f7265766973696f6e2f6c61746573743f63623d3230313031323134323035353139

I know Fluxxor used it:

https://camo.githubusercontent.com/49bffd9b0c9a11fbdcf857a577b1b62feda48abc/687474703a2f2f666c7578786f722e636f6d2f666c7578786f722e706e67

Maybe there's a way to make it more symbolic and less square-y.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/rackt/redux/issues/151#issuecomment-150320875.

dvshnt commented 9 years ago

redux-final

Sketch. Could do with a less red sympathizery font-type

rossipedia commented 9 years ago

I also thought that it should play well as a small devtools icon.

x

Just sayin!

johnnyshields commented 9 years ago

image

ghost commented 9 years ago

oooh pretty!

Another duck at the top in inverted color could add the "re" to the "dux" :D

johnnyshields commented 9 years ago

image

johnnyshields commented 9 years ago

Red ducks, get it?

(Drawn in MS Paint)