tabs testbed 4 and beyond

scripting commented 3 months ago

I'm glad so many people are helping out with this. If you guys can stay with it at this level, we can move quickly.

First, with one tab in six being a timeline, I can't get the tabs to freeze.So the next test, #4 will have all six be timelines and they will be the same ones that are on news.scripting.com.

Not sure where we'll go next depending on the results of that test.

scripting commented 3 months ago

Here's testbed 4.

http://scripting.com/code/testing/tabstest4/

It has all the tabs that are in news.scripting.com.

Do the same things you were doing in previous testbeds.

Go back and forth between the tabs and see if it ever stops responding to your clicks.

richb-hanover commented 3 months ago

I don't know if they are still relevant, but I just submitted comments on Testbed 3 at https://github.com/scripting/Scripting-News/issues/287#issuecomment-1987265890

Using Testbed 4:

All taps switch to the new tab (all browsers/tablets tested) (Taps never had a freeze/failure to switch.)
Taps feels "slower" - there's a hesitation between the tap and the highlight of the new tab
Sometimes the highlight comes "right after" the tap (accounting for the slower feel)
Sometimes I see a "delayed highlight" where the highlight does not occur until the content arrives. In that case, I see the blue background flash briefly and the content is displayed all at once.
I have a sense that the behavior might be different when clicking tabs left-to-right vs right-to-left. The delayed highlight seems to/might occur more often going right-to-left. But I can't be sure of that it really is more frequent.

One last request: If you need to do more tests, would you put "Testbed #" at the top of the page? That helps me keep track... THANKS!

grantdunham commented 3 months ago

It works on my Pixel Phone, with Android 14 and Chrome.

scotthansonde commented 3 months ago

Found an Lenovo tabM10 with Android 10 and Chrome. It's slow, but the tabs always respond.

moosebegab commented 3 months ago

Testbed 4

Clicking works. sometimes a slight hesitancy between click and feed showing up.

Works on ipad mini 6 / os 17.0.3 / chrome browser / safari browser Works on Motorola One 5G Ace / android 11 / chrome browser

mbaas2 commented 3 months ago

No problems on iphone 15pro max with safari. When I repeated with Chrome, I noticed that at some point when switching from "Tech" to "Podcasts", iit wouldn't show (it kept the "Tech" content). As I continued, "All" & "Politics" were responding, "Tech" and "Podcasts" stayed the same.

scripting commented 3 months ago

@mbaas -- for this experiment we're only interested in the contents of the tab, ie which tab is highlighted. what's below it is not what we're testing. i want to be clear about what you observed.

mbaas2 commented 3 months ago

ok, sorry for the confusion. Didn't see any issues with highlighting - whatever I clicxked became "curent tab".👍

mokuyo commented 3 months ago

Couldn’t get any tab to fail. iPhone 15 Pro, iOS 17.4 Safari

scripting / Scripting-News

tabs testbed 4 and beyond #295