search

smartfog / fogflow

FogFlow is a standard-based IoT fog computing framework that supports serverless computing and edge computing with advanced programming models
https://fogflow.readthedocs.io
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
122 stars 45 forks source link

it will be nice to move FogFlow from NGSI v1 to NGSI v2 #42

Closed showersky closed 4 years ago

showersky commented 4 years ago

Since most of the other FIWARE GE now only support v2, it will be nice for FogFlow to support v2 as well. In this case, it will be easy to integrate FogFlow with IoTAgent for device integration, with WireCloud for visualization, and with QuantumLeap for saving historical data. With all these together, we can form a minimal edge computing oriented IoT platform. How do you thin? I think this does not require too much change and we can easily support it.

@FogFlow users, how do you think? Please let me know your opinion. Do you also expect to see this feature in FogFlow?

rahafrouz commented 4 years ago

I like the idea, and I think it is good to be interoperable with other features. So for, fogflow is a framework that is self-sufficient, which is very good, but challenging when it comes to adding it to existing systems.

Most of the FiWARE users maybe start with an installation of a context broker.
I think if we want others to start using fogflow, we should think of their perspective: How to introduce documentation for people who know the basics of context-broker, but don't know it is possible to do serverless computing of these context data!

I don't know how much NGSI-LD is adopted now, and would be adopted; maybe that would worth considering as well? I think FogFlow is a great platform, and if it get used by more people, it would get more community support.

tejinderkhattra commented 4 years ago

For now, Scorpio Broker is being used with Fogflow to adapt to NGSI-LD.

kox commented 4 years ago

+1 NGSI v2

Considering that many FIWARE IoT ready devices run with NGSI v2, I think this feature is a "must".

showersky commented 4 years ago

thank you all for your valid feedback. I think it is necessary to make some change to support both NGSI v2 and NGSI-LD in FogFlow. I will discuss with the NTI team to see how this could be done.

sanchitanec commented 4 years ago

Fogflow is now supporting NGSIv2 subscription & notify, So now it is also working for WireCloud to visualize and for QuantumLeap to save historical data as well.