Question: is it possible to have the same digideliveryid for 2 different schools?

stichtingsem / ecosystem

The SEM Ecosystem standardises the exchange of data required for the supply and usage of digital learning materials in schools

3 stars 1 forks source link

Question: is it possible to have the same digideliveryid for 2 different schools? #66

Closed mcginkel closed 2 years ago

mcginkel commented 2 years ago

is it possible to have the same digideliveryid for 2 different schools?

mcginkel commented 2 years ago

when 2 schools use the same address, will the digideliveriid always be unique?

Maybe happening when 2 schools organize one course in one location

hhaarsma commented 2 years ago

Looks like we have an example of an special education school which acts both for primary and secundary education. PE and SE are in our system as different schools, but they have the same digideliveryid connected.

hhaarsma commented 2 years ago

And I see an example of 2 secundary schools (1 for Havo/VWO and 1 for Mavo) having the same addres and also indeed the same digideliveryid. (Eligant & Kompaan, Zutphen)

edwinverwoerd commented 2 years ago

Can you please send me the official registration to DUO (schoolname, address, brin_4 and brin_6). Just to check something. Also the question what will be de value within the Entree Federation Authentication flow for each student. Do they have the same?

Beside this we also have to thing in two staps: 1) School adminstration level and consent 2) Data on level:

Authenticatie
Data sharing

hhaarsma commented 2 years ago

This is the info I see on our side:

Adres Isendoornstraat 3, 7201 NJ, ZUTPHEN

Naam	Eligant Lyceum	Kompaan College
DigiDeliveryId	D800D048-6144-4081-B0E4-BB4F5F5585B5	D800D048-6144-4081-B0E4-BB4F5F5585B5
BRIN	20DH00	?
UWLR ID	0d93523e-bde4-4390-9092-6128a5d12e94	9371fe4d-93d0-4efd-a1e9-6d01d25e63c3

edwinverwoerd commented 2 years ago

Can you please explain what is UWLR ID. Because on this moment the digiDeliveryId is not yet a value in the current data-set. For this we roll-out the new UWLR 2.3 version..

edwinverwoerd commented 2 years ago

General this must not occur. Based on the input I did a further analsye based on available chain data and my conclusion is that in this case there is a data / mapping error. See the pictures below.

kvoer commented 2 years ago

As discussed in the Technical Track the example was a data issue.