(macOS) Performance: constant high CPU usage

[foss-]

System Information:

• Operating system: macOS 11.6.1
• Strawberry Version: Open Strawberry Version 1.0.0-116-g0fbe5d88

Constant high CPU usage on macOS.

To Reproduce With Strawberry open and doing nothing (no scrolling or playing a track or any interaction at all) Strawberry constantly sits at over 40% CPU usage

Playing a track it sits at over 60% while sometimes spiking at over 100%:

Expected behavior CPU usage is too high. Comparing with Apples music app which sits at 0,1% when idle and goes up to under 2% when playing a track.

Additional context Spin Dump: https://bin.disroot.org/?73b77829f80a251e#5vwiHDcJRRTccyUMsLmNgUidDriH9xRhv6HMAEW8hoUn Process Sample: https://bin.disroot.org/?103ce9f6c263e0fb#HzSkmVV7rWMBXs5GyL1nzbP6h6cA92XRhmUJc6ATSDKw

[jonaski]

Uses 15-20% CPU here in my macOS VM. Did you change any specific configuration options? Did you try with a fresh configuration? delete ~/Library/Preferences/org.strawberrymusicplayer.Strawberry.plist

[foss-]

Interesting finding and thanks for going through the effort to verify this problem. Are you also running macOS 11? I enabled storing metadata back to files and disabled the default library background picture. Other than that can't recall changes.

I removed ~/Library/Preferences/org.strawberrymusicplayer.Strawberry.plist as suggested, installed latest main build.

CPU consumption while playing a track is now back to normal levels. Will keep an eye on this and re-open if issue returns, hopefully with more details as to which change triggers the CPU increase.

[foss-]

Well that was a quick one. Connecting an external monitor makes CPU go up to ~50-80% playing a track and ~40-50 when ideling. For comparison: when playing a track in Apples Music app CPU is around or mostly below 2%.

[jonaski]

It might be related to #542

[foss-]

Which gladly is seeing active development and just yesterday received patch set 8. Not sure if it is indeed the cause for the constant high CPU though, as no scrolling is involved in my tests.

[e471wo]

duno if that help, but on my mac, if I put no analyser -> cpu down. (note -> Version 1.0.0-125-g4c6251bf)

[richarddbarnett]

I found this because Strawberry 1.0.1 on macOS 11.6.2 was consuming a lot of CPU (about 40%) when paused. Turning off the analyzer seems to fix it.

MacBook Pro 15", 2.9GHz quad-core i7. External monitor is connected via USB-C.

[foss-]

Also confirming: Strawberry 1.0.1-22-g56b2630a on macOS 11.6.2 sitting idle ~40% CPU Switching from Block analyzer to No analyzer and it goes to 0,0 sitting idle.

[jonaski]

What about the other analyzers, do they cause as much CPU too?

[foss-]

Strawberry idle / playing ~40% / ~60% for all analyzers.

[jonaski]

The problematic code is in https://raw.githubusercontent.com/strawberrymusicplayer/strawberry/master/src/analyzer/analyzerbase.cpp There is a timer that repaints every few milliseconds depending the framerate set. Although this not a problem on any other platforms and is likely a Qt-macOS specific issue.

[jonaski]

Can you try the latest from https://builds.strawberrymusicplayer.org/macos/ those have Qt 6.3.0 (instead of Qt 6.2.x).

[foss-]

macOS 12.3.1 Strawberry 1.0.4-5-g907dfee6 Playing a track with analyzer selected CPU is under 20% which is somewhat acceptable. (Apple music app is ~3% but it is optimised for macOS) Ideling it is ~12% which is high for doing ... nothing.

But since both values have improved a lot. I think it is fair to close this issue. What do you think? Can others test as well?

[Calinou]

It might be worth disabling the analyzer by default on macOS to fix the issue out of the box. I'm not sure how many people actually look at the analyzer anyway. Typically, you minimize the music player a few seconds after choosing a track to play :slightly_smiling_face:

[jonaski]

In my macOS Big Sur VM which is slow in general strawberry is using approximately 4% - 10% when idle and 15-30% when playing, both with the analyzer is on. If I turn the analyzer off when idle, the CPU goes almost to 0, when playing it's under 20%. When removing the timer that does frequent repaints when the analyzer is on, the CPU usage goes down, I also made a small test program, same thing happens with the test program, so it's not specific to the analyzer itself, but frequent repaints. I'm considering filing a bug report to Qt, but at least for me, I also see the Activity monitor having somewhat high CPU usage, so my VM is not really ideal for benchmarking since it's so much slower than a real mac would be. I don't think I can do much with this, so closing it for now. Turning off the analyzer as a solution for those having the issue is written in the Wiki: https://wiki.strawberrymusicplayer.org/wiki/Known_Issues