stulp
commented
11 months ago The short answer is that yes, orientations can be represented in principle, but no, it is not supported explicitly. This is one of the main weaknesses of the current implementations,, and support for orientations is at the top of my wishlist.
In principle: yes
Quaternions can be implemented by adding them as miscellaneous variables to the trajectory: https://github.com/stulp/dmpbbo/blob/c73e1418b611f31cfbe652df51f14f8c18552897/dmpbbo/dmps/Trajectory.py#L142-L143
You can then train a DMP with these miscellaneous variables with this function (i.e. instead of gains/forces, you would have orientations) https://github.com/stulp/dmpbbo/blob/c73e1418b611f31cfbe652df51f14f8c18552897/dmpbbo/dmps/DmpWithSchedules.py#L50-L62
In practice: no
However, the DMP implementation does not know that these are quaternions, and would thus not ensure that they are normalized, for instance. So in practice, this is not a satisfactory solution.
The proper way would rather be to have trajectories and DMPs that are aware that they are dealing with orientations and/or quaternions. Although I have no time to implement that, I would be very happy to help design it and review code, in case someone is interested in pursuing this for a student project, for instance.
There are several ways this could be implemented, including
- As in the "DMPs for quaternion control" section of the paper "Online movement adaptation based on previous sensor experiences"
- Using Riemannian manifolds.
I also see that I need to improve the documentation of the Trajectory class...
maoyangchien
Hi, thank you for contributing to this great open-source project.
I have looked at the test process in the demo directory and also looked at the contents of the Trajectory.py and trajectory.txt files. I have a few questions to ask you:
Looking at the structure of trajectory.txt, the first column is the timestamp, the second and third columns are the x, y coordinates, the fourth and fifth columns are the velocity in the x and y directions, and the fifth and sixth columns are the acceleration in the x and y directions. Is my understanding correct?
If my target trajectory has 6 degrees of freedom and uses quaternion coordinates, such as (x, y, z, qx, qy, qz, qw), does dmpbbo support such coordinate trajectories? If I also provide the velocity and acceleration of x, y, z, how does dmpbbo handle qx, qy, qz, qw?