tdwg / cd

Collection Descriptions

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International

23 stars 10 forks source link

Re-assess GeoOrigin terms for inclusion in first draft #425

Closed essvee closed 1 year ago

essvee commented 2 years ago

I would think that Countries and States would be more useful than continent in a collection description (especially for those that are more specific than "global"). I'm surprised they are not options under this class.

Originally posted by @Jegelewicz in https://github.com/tdwg/cd/issues/131#issuecomment-1302454913

essvee commented 2 years ago

For discussion at the next WG session (10-11-22): Suggest we re-assess which GeoOrigin terms we're including in the first release: at the moment it's just continent, locality, salinityType, region, waterBody and waterBodyType, but a bunch of the other terms look to be complete (list below). Is it worth adding them into the first batch? They're mostly lifted from dwc so other folks will probably be expecting to see something equivalent at the collection level...

137 islandGroup

138 island

139 country

140 countryCode

141 stateProvince

142 county

143 municipality

225 ecoRegion

rondlg commented 2 years ago

See #141 and #142 - use political divisions instead of baking in actual ranks to the term names. This lets the hierarchy grow without restriction and can be used in tandem with a rank field to allow the use of broader vocabularies.

-- politicalDivision0 -> continent -- politicalDivision1 -> country -- politicalDivision2 -> "whatever you want it to be" -- politicalDivision3 -> "whatever you want it to be"

jbstatgen commented 2 years ago

Better late than never ...

On Tab "Registry_openDA_collection" of the "Registry_Vocabularies" spreadsheet file you can find the "Geographic region" schema from the SYNTHESYS+ report (Tilley 2019) for the Collection Digitization Dashboard.

As a first guess, Level 1 (aka 'GeographicSphere' by me) := missing in ltc:GeographicOrigin Level 2 (GeographicCategory) := ltc:continent (mmh, scale also required for oceans ...) Level 3 (GeographicSubcategory):= ltc:region (here: SYNTHESYS+ provides only subdivisions in the Atlantic and Pacific)

essvee commented 2 years ago

Partially addressed by PR #428, but I'm leaving it open until someone reminds me whether ecoRegion (#225) is included or not - the ecoRegion term-level issue isn't tagged with 'done' so it might need another look.

Will break out the renaming of stateProvince and county as flagged by @rondlg into another issue and make any ensuing changes separately to keep things simpler and easier to trace.

essvee commented 1 year ago

Working Group decision following discussion: Include ecoRegion in first draft, see notes from 30/11/2022