tillrose / BRIWECS_Data_Publication

A collaborative work on a data publication for the seasons 2015–2019 of the BRIWECS consortium
MIT License
0 stars 0 forks source link

Extract management data from xlsx #8

Open Illustratien opened 2 months ago

Illustratien commented 2 months ago
  1. Soil
  2. Fertilizer
  3. Plant protection
  4. Disease note
Illustratien commented 2 months ago

@tillrose could you please double check where we can improve?

  1. wether fill the blank from column D (yellow area) to others
  2. some missing date (not only in DKI but also in HAN)
  3. whether need to translate or not in column G in English (e.g., Düngung -> Fertilizer) image
tillrose commented 2 months ago

What do you think, should I overwork the original management files or the extracted lists (would be much easier) and we leave the original files behind?

Illustratien commented 2 months ago

Since the extraction is automatic now. I would suggest to correct/filling the original one.

What do you think, should I overwork the original management files or the extracted lists (would be much easier) and we leave the original files behind?

Illustratien commented 2 months ago

image Do we need these nearly empty columns?

Illustratien commented 2 months ago

Relevant discussion #15 #4

tillrose commented 1 week ago

I think nearly empty columns should not be featured in the extraction.

Illustratien commented 1 week ago

I think nearly empty columns should not be featured in the extraction.

You mean the note ? or image

Illustratien commented 1 week ago

image what are the differences between inhibited or not?

tillrose commented 1 week ago

An inhibitor is a compound added to a nitrogen-based fertilizer to reduce gaseous losses when the fertilizer has been applied to the crop. We used it because we gave the 3rd nitrogen dressing very early because in the rain out shelter there was later no water at the surface that is usually needed for the active use of fertilizer by the crop.

If you think another wording is more common, go for it.

Illustratien commented 1 week ago

I don't have a recommendation for new wording. But I am thinking wether we need an addtional table for explaining the abbreviation or the "term/jargon" shown in the table.

tillrose commented 1 week ago

Perhaps ad a sentence in the manuscript? "nitrogen fertilizer was either applied as calcium ammonium nitrate (CAN), urea ammonium nitrate (UAN) or urea ammonium nitrate with inhibitors (UAN inhibited)."

tillrose commented 1 week ago

I would prefer to delete all fertilizer information except nitrogen. This information is only given in sporadic seasons but in all experiments magnesium, phosphor, potassium were given in sufficient amount. The actual state is confusing.

image

Illustratien commented 1 week ago

I would prefer to delete all fertilizer information except nitrogen. This information is only given in sporadic seasons but in all experiments magnesium, phosphor, potassium were given in sufficient amount. The actual state is confusing.

image

filterout the magnesium rows, since they are the base fertilizer