search

tmcd82070 / CAMP_RST

R code for CAMP rotary screw trap platform
1 stars 1 forks source link

American -- Comparison of Passage Estimates in Preparation for Release 4.5 #78

Closed jasmyace closed 7 years ago

jasmyace commented 8 years ago

OVERVIEW: Buy-in of outside users of the Platform will be enhanced if the passage estimates that result agree with expectation.

RESOLUTION: Compare results easily obtained, via the Big Looper checking process, with externally obtained results.

DETAILS: Take the Fall passage estimates from year ALL runs reporting and compare to external sources. For the American river, these numbers utilize database CAMPAmerican2013_2015Database_23June2015 of approximately 53,108 KB in size.

The Fall passage estimates utilized here follow. Keep in mind that column bEst is the estimate of passage, while columns bLCL and bUCL are the 95% confidence bounds.

image

Do these align with expectation?

jasmyace commented 7 years ago

Calculation methodologies have changed slightly, precluding accurate use of the data in this Issue. So, I'm closing the Issue.

jasmyace commented 7 years ago

The Big Looper 2.0 has tentatively completed its runs for the release of R package campR 1.0.0. We have made many changes since we last looked at numbers, so I thought I would do some superficial spot checking against numbers from the last release. I could spend hours comparing and contrasting.

Note that these numbers reflect the Fall run from the All Runs report. You may need to go to the original Issue online to be able to compare the screenshots from before and now.

A screenshot comparable to the above follows.

image

Generally, most passage estimates appear in line.