topjohnwu / Magisk

The Magic Mask for Android
GNU General Public License v3.0
47.88k stars 12.16k forks source link

Do Not Submit MagiskHide Requests #1152

Closed topjohnwu closed 4 years ago

topjohnwu commented 5 years ago

Any further "MagiskHide" and related root hiding development will no longer be in the official Magisk repo and will not be done by topjohnwu, so all Issues along these lines will be immediately closed.

See: https://topjohnwu.medium.com/state-of-magisk-2021-fe29fdaee458 And: https://twitter.com/osm0sis/status/1431948577627119618


You may check this unofficial off-site documentation for any updates going forward: https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide

animo899 commented 3 years ago

so glad my little device has disable gms in the engineer mode =) lol the engineer mode lets me disable or enable set prop aswell as other stuff.. some devices are just cool like that. sad that from what i see these newer devices that are better have too much protection.. i mean omg google releases open source code for everything and these compaines still want to lock it all down for no freaken reason ppl will still sell phones or w.e anyway iv seen it a billion times. i fully support anything you all doin great job people! keep the devs alive.. iv been testing out some tools like exec elvated priv and such from googl kinda like their tool to add any app u need to the whitelist apps .xml i figured if anything if somehow implent those into code or w.e then the system itself will just be like eh your good. ill come back after extensive testing of course n let u know

Haus3master commented 3 years ago

so glad my little device has disable gms in the engineer mode =) lol the engineer mode lets me disable or enable set prop aswell as other stuff.. some devices are just cool like that. sad that from what i see these newer devices that are better have too much protection.. i mean omg google releases open source code for everything and these compaines still want to lock it all down for no freaken reason ppl will still sell phones or w.e anyway iv seen it a billion times. i fully support anything you all doin great job people! keep the devs alive.. iv been testing out some tools like exec elvated priv and such from googl kinda like their tool to add any app u need to the whitelist apps .xml i figured if anything if somehow implent those into code or w.e then the system itself will just be like eh your good. ill come back after extensive testing of course n let u know

Good luck on your research and testing, we hope that you will be able to bring a new hiding method to the table, so, all the best!

MuhmdRaouf commented 3 years ago

My Banking app detects root, I tried to hide it multiple times as much as i could but couldn't, so I tried to track down the logcat and find out the following

ActivityManager: Start proc 22552:com.google.android.webview:sandboxed_process0:org.chromium.content.app.SandboxedProcessService0:0/u0i5 for  {com.BanqueMisr.MobileBanking/org.chromium.content.app.SandboxedProcessService0:0}

it opens up the activity within a chromium SandboxedProcessService and this service is not showing in the MagiskHide to use it, also my app has 2 entries in MagiskHide one for the app itself and one for tmpService the tmpService always go back to unchecked whenever I close Magisk app and open it again.

I hope that could help to hide application like these from Magisk

Nitrovenom commented 3 years ago

But john wu brother, release new update binary when?

Conan179 commented 3 years ago

There is a new root detection option for apps where magiskhide bypasses. 2021-05-10 19 17 20 point 3 oh and yes I followed https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide several times.

xerta555 commented 3 years ago

There is a new root detection option for apps where magiskhide bypasses. 2021-05-10 19 17 20 point 3 oh and yes I followed didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide several times.

It could be the reason why my bancking app detect Magisk since last app update.. Hope that John could find a fix quickly.

BobSnrub commented 3 years ago

Can I add suggestions in the issues sections? Just asking because one of mine got automatically closed @topjohnwu Thanks

ghost commented 3 years ago

Just a heads up that MagiskHide will be dropped https://www.xda-developers.com/magisk-development-continues-without-magiskhide/

Pheromon commented 3 years ago

While I can't blame topjohnwu for his choice (he worked for free while now G will give him a lot of money to undo all of his work), I'm a bit pissed that we can't use our device as we see fit anymore.