add more results plots to multi-scenario NB (things not done in #64)

gplssm commented 4 years ago

Notes

In the current version there're many plots showing all scenarios which makes it somehow hard to grasp. For some plots we should pick out only relevant scenarios.
Implement according to priority (1=high/must-have, 2=medium, 3=low)
Unless otherwise specified, spatial resolution is ABW

1 Demand and Generation

1.1 Installed Capacities Electricity/Heat

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
1.1.3	Installed Capacity Wind+PV (PV=ground+roof)	-	dotplot	x: wind, y: PV, maybe good to quickly grasp the major tech	3

1.1.1: If el+th is too much in one plot, split into 2 plots.

1.3 Electricity and Heat Demand

2 Area required by RES

2.1 Available areas: Scenarios

Overview / cumulative sums:

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
2.1.0.1	Potential Areas	GW, % (2 axes)	barplot grouped	similar to plot `Relative Required Area` in single scenario jupy nb but with abs. numbers -> abs. in GW, rel. in % related to legal SQ areas	1	x

More detailed analysis in 2.1.1-2.1.3 .

2.1.1 Available areas: Wind Energy

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
2.1.1.1	Potential Areas Wind	-	geoplot	All avail. areas (geometries) plotted on mun shapes (s1000f0, s1000f1, s500f0, s500f1), geoms are avail. in DF `region.pot_areas_wec`, please use 'sq' for s1000f0	2
2.1.1.2	Potential Areas Wind per mun	ha	barplot grouped: (s1000f0, s1000f1, s500f0, s500f1) per scn in on group	x: mun , geoms are avail. in DF `region.pot_areas_wec`, please use 'sq' for s1000f0	1

2.1.2 Available areas: Ground-Mounted PV

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio
2.1.2.1	Potential Areas PV ground: railways	ha	geoplot	All avail. areas (geometries) plotted on mun shapes side by side (H, HS), geoms are avail. in DF `region.pot_areas_pv`	2
2.1.2.2	Potential Areas PV ground: motorways	ha	geoplot	All avail. areas (geometries) plotted on mun shapes side by side (H, HS), geoms are avail. in DF `region.pot_areas_pv`	2
2.1.2.3	Potential Areas PV ground: agricultural	ha	geoplot	All avail. areas (geometries) plotted on mun shapes side by side (H, HS), geoms are avail. in DF `region.pot_areas_pv`	2
2.1.2.4	Potential Areas PV ground: area sums	ha	barplot grouped (railway, motorway, agri per scn in on group)	x: scenarios	1

2.1.3 Available areas: Roof-Mounted PV

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
2.1.3.1	Potential Areas PV roof	ha	geoplot	Area sum Summe Flächen pro Gemeinde	1

2.2 Area usage

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio
2.2.1	Rel. Area Usage Wind (cum. for ABW)	%	barplot grouped	For each scenario: rel. usage in relation to land use scenario of scenario, sorted by the 4 land use scenarios (see photo below)	1
2.2.2	Rel. Area Usage Wind (cum. for ABW)	%	barplot	Rel. usage in all scenarios in relation to the total region's area (362900 ha)	1
2.2.3	Rel. Area Usage PV ground (cum. for ABW)	%	barplot grouped	For each scenario: rel. usage in relation to land use scenario of scenario, sorted by the 6 land use scenarios (see photo below)	1
2.2.4	Rel. Area Usage PV ground (cum. for ABW)	%	barplot	Rel. usage in all scenarios in relation to the total region's area (362900 ha)	1
2.2.5	Rel. Area Usage PV roof (cum. for ABW)	%	barplot	Rel. usage in all scenarios	1

Example Wind 2.2.1+2.2.2 (PV ground 2.2.3+2.2.4 analogously): plots1

3 Energy Exchange and Autarky

3.1 Energy Exchange

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
3.1.1	Import and Export (National Grid)	GWh	barplot grouped	x: scenarios, could be merged into 3.2.1?	1
3.1.2	Intra-Regional Import and Export	GWh	barplot grouped	x: scenarios	1

3.2 Autarky

(#85 needs to be done first)

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio
3.2.1	Demand+supply	GWh, %	barplot grouped	like plot `Electrical Autarky per Municipality (Energy Balance) and total region` in single scenario jupy nb but with scenarios instead of muns	1
3.2.2	Autarky: energy + time	%	barplot grouped	time: 2 options: 1) mean of all time step autarky values, 2) perc. of autark hours -> to be specified after #85	1
3.2.3	Autarky: energy violin	%	violin plot	like plot `Relative Electrical Autarky per Municipality (Energy Balance)` in single scenario jupy nb but with scenarios instead of muns	2

4 Energy Mix

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
4.3	Full-Load Hours Electricity	h	barplot grouped by tech (wind, pv ground, pv roof, bio, ...)	like plot `Power Generation and Demand` in single scenario jupy nb but with scenarios instead of muns	2

5 Emissions

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
5.2	Emissions relative	%	barplot stacked by sector (el, th, stor, grid), scaled to 100%	x: scenarios	3

6 Costs

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
6.1	LCOE and LCOH	€/MWh	barplot grouped per scn with el+th	x: scenarios	1

7 Power Grid

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
7.1	Line Loading	%	whisker box plot, like `DSM Activation` plot in single scenario jupy nb	x: scenarios	1

8 Flexibility

It'd be good to have an overview plot on the flex. to quickly see the configuration/character of each scenario. I propose either 8.0.1 or 8.0.2. Alternatively, we could move this to the scenario overview (maybe better).

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
8.0.1	Flex. Character	€/MWh	PairGrid dot plot (as in 0) showing the flex. character of scenario (RES power, DSM, autarky, pth stor, batteries, eff. el., eff. th.)	x: scenarios	2
8.0.2	Flex. Character	€/MWh	radar chart showing the flex. character of scenario (RES power, DSM, autarky, pth stor, batteries, eff. el., eff. th.), N charts we assign the scenarios to, e.g. BAThigh+BATlimit in one radar and so on	x: scenarios	2

8.1 Thermal Storages

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
8.1.1	Storage use	-	whisker box plot grouped by scn with dec+cen, like `DSM Activation` plot in single scenario jupy nb	x: scenarios	1

8.2 Batteries

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
8.2.1	Storage use	-	whisker box plot grouped by scn with large+small, like `DSM Activation` plot in single scenario jupy nb	x: scenarios	1

8.3 DSM

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
8.3.1	Total Sum (Ratio DSM / demand hh)	%	bar plot	x: scenarios	1

9 Energy Exchange

As proposed in https://github.com/windnode/WindNODE_ABW/issues/96#issuecomment-670477150 I integrated this section into 3.

nesnoj commented 3 years ago

Only implement a selection of plots listed above

nesnoj commented 3 years ago

Ok, I went through the first part of the plots and from my point of view these ones should be implemented: (The second part will follow later today)

2 Area required by RES

2.1 Available areas: Scenarios

2.1.1 Available areas: Wind Energy

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
2.1.1.1	Potential Areas Wind	-	4 geoplots (2x2)	All avail. areas (geometries) plotted on mun shapes (s1000f0, s1000f1, s500f0, s500f1), geoms are avail. in DF `region.pot_areas_wec`, please use 'sq' for s1000f0	1	x

In 2.1.1.1 the absolute available area per mun should either be displayed by coloring the muns (underneath the area geoms) or as numbers.

2.1.2 Available areas: Ground-Mounted PV

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
2.1.2.1	Potential Areas PV ground	-	geoplot (2x1)	All avail. areas (geometries) plotted on mun shapes (H, HS), types (motorways, railways, agricultural), geoms are avail. in DF `region.pot_areas_pv`	1	x

2.1.2.1 like this plot in the StEmp ABW docs. If possible add available area per mun as described above (2.1.1.1).
Add note that the shown agri areas are 100%, we use 0.1% and 1% in our scenarios.
A comprehensive description of how those areas are determined see StEmp ABW docs.

2.1.3 Available areas: Roof-Mounted PV

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
2.1.3.1	Potential Areas PV roof	ha	geoplot	Area sum Summe Flächen pro Gemeinde	1	x

3 Energy Exchange and Autarky

3.1 Energy Exchange

Intra-reg. exchange is given in the very first plot, so I propose to drop extra plots.

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
3.1.1	Import and Export (National Grid)	GWh	barplot	x: scenarios	1	x

3.2 Autarky

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
3.2.1	Annual+Autark hours	GWh, %	barplot grouped	like plot `Electrical Autarky per Municipality (Energy Balance) and total region` in single scenario jupy nb but with scenarios (entire ABW) instead of muns	1	x

4 Energy Mix

5 Emissions

6 Costs

6.1 Costs per Sector and Technology

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
6.1.1	Total abs. el. costs distribution per technology	€	barplot stacked	x: scenarios, y: stacked by tech. (wind, gm pv, ...), describe that fix+var+certs are included	1	x
6.1.2	Total abs. th. costs distribution per technology	€	barplot stacked	x: scenarios, y: stacked by tech. (oil heating, ...), describe that fix+var+certs are included	1	x

7 Power Grid

Not sure if 7.1 makes sense - it should to be weighted somehow, e.g. with the energy amount? Discuss! :

#	Größe	Einheit	Plot/Tabelle	Kommentar	Prio	Done?
7.1	Max Line Loading Distribution	%	whisker plot (like in single nb `7.2 Line Loading Distribution`)	x: scenarios	2	x

8 Flexibility

I think the last 3 plots reflect flex. characteristics to a sufficient extent. @gplssm Which of your 8 experimental flex dot plots do you want to keep? And I propose to move your dot plots to the very end.

nesnoj commented 3 years ago

Ok @nailend @gplssm I'm done with reviewing the plots and pushed some amendments to dev. Also I added some points to be discussed in the new list above and to the template.

windnode / WindNODE_ABW