JEK-III DPLandscapePaper issues

JEK-III / DPLandscapePaper

Data Publication Landscape Paper

0 stars 0 forks source link

issues

Newest

Newest Most commented Recently updated Oldest Least commented Least recently updated

What is the scope of their essay?

#56 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Do they accept the critique of Parsons and Fox?

#55 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Are they satisfied with the Lawrence et al. definition?

#54 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
They need to be more forthright in saying what data publication means to them, or what parts of it they do not deal with

#53 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Dynamic data as a problem for validation

#52 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
who is responsible for what

#51 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Mention PANGAEA

#50 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Revise independent data publication

#49 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
Proxy papers

#48 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
Add http://researchcompendia.org/

#47 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
2
Justify the scheme you're using

#46 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
3
Stress location of the documentation

#45 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
More DP models

#44 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
independent data might be linked to 1 or many papers

#43 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
What is the takeaway message from this essay?

#42 JEK-III closed 8 years ago
0
Are we overemphasizing the role of citation to provide academic credit?

#41 JEK-III closed 8 years ago
0
Citation: Is the “just-in-time identifier” the way to go?

#40 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
3
Citation: Have we solved the basic problem and are now just dealing with edge cases?

#39 JEK-III closed 8 years ago
1
What is the role of the curator or data scientist in all of this?

#38 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Could formalizing or codifying some of these validation processes accomplish the same as peer-review or more?

#37 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
2
Are there emerging practices or consensus in these team-based validation schemes?

#36 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Are these models sustaining models or just something to get us through the next 5-10 years while we really figure it out?

#35 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
2
Might it also be worthy of typing “publishers” instead of “publications”?

#34 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Do publication models have different business models or imply different social contracts?

#33 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Why are there different models and which approach is better for different situations?

#32 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Are these really the only three models in consideration or does the publication model overstate a consensus around a certain type of data publication?

#31 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
2
Mention Dat

#30 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
2
Add pointers to venues where issues are being debated

#29 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Mention ESSD

#28 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Stronger conclusion

#27 JEK-III closed 8 years ago
0
No-one looks at every data value? No, they use statistics, visualization, and other techniques.

#26 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
More about data pub w/o paper

#25 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
why there is controversy in some areas

#24 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
2
their vs. the applicant

#23 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
"Data as the subject of a paper,

#22 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
half of consider

#21 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
extra 0

#20 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
"refer" be "refer TO

#19 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
HIPPA --> HIPAA

#18 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
Citability

#17 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
2
Abstract: publication vs. scholarly publication

#16 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Trustworthy repositories: more about standards

#15 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
2
Types of data publication: discuss other models / connect to intro

#14 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
0
Why publish data?: mention dutch fraud cases

#13 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Intro: make explicit link from DP->credit

#12 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Clarify OC relationship to data journals

#11 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Page 6, para 3: DP metaphor is limiting and misleading

#10 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Page 5, para 10: PDS not unusual

#9 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Page 5, para 5: lots of repositories have scientific review

#8 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1
Page 4, para 6: clarification of ESIP citation standard

#7 JEK-III closed 10 years ago
1